陳守仁 (TSL) vs 聖瑪加利 (St. Margaret’s)

gordon

These 2 schools are quiet similar. 如果兩間都收你, 係會掂選擇?

Why?

Thanks
Gordon

CheCheMan

I just pass-by BK and read this topic.  For my own view, I don't like TSL coz one of my friend's daughter is studying inside and the comment is......

Hence, I pick CKY instead.

原文章由 gordon 於 07-10-17 12:31 硐表
These 2 schools are quiet similar. 如果兩間都收你, 係會掂選擇?

Why?

Thanks
Gordon

aclam

I don't like st.margaret. The campus is too small for both primary and secondary school. The higher grade students  look too 'in' to me.

catcatmom

CheCheMan

the comment is......可唔可以講d來聽? pm 得嗎?

我識人係tsl度讀, 佢地d老師係外國讀完書, 而聖瑪加利就係abc, 陳守仁就谷好多,因佢無中學, 但比起其他"保記"少好多多功課.

原文章由 CheCheMan 於 07-10-17 13:20 硐表
I just pass-by BK and read this topic.  For my own view, I don't like TSL coz one of my friend's daughter is studying inside and the comment is......

Hence, I pick CKY instead.

WYmom

原文章由 catcatmom 於 07-10-17 14:01 硐表
CheCheMan

the comment is......可唔可以講d來聽? pm 得嗎?

我識人係tsl度讀, 佢地d老師係外國讀完書, 而聖瑪加利就係abc, 陳守仁就谷好多,因佢無中學, 但比起其他"保記"少好多多功課.
...

CheCheMan,

Can you just tell the comments of TSL even it is negative?  I think every school has positive and negative comments and it is better for parents to know both.  I also heard some friends with kids studying there  saying that it is satisfactory, though the teachers are not native English teachers.  

PLK schools are well known to be more traditional and pushy as they want their schools to be famous.  CKY is using different approach in primary, but they also have to push in the secondary stage if they want their public exam results to look good after a few years.

catcatmom

st.margaret 既校舍唔夠培僑,浸小甘大, 同優才差唔多,所以優才都要用埋"志潔"既校舍先至收多d學生.

最初我去過st.margaret外圍,覺得無mud特別,真係好細下!所以小一只能收兩班80人,分三組教. 但係open day我去過每個課室美勞,電腦,家政,圖書館,音樂室...  覺得眼前一亮,好靓好有心思設計, 我個人覺得雖然細dd, 比起其他幾間學校都要"好"! 唔掛得年年加學費,都有甘多家長去報名. 至於software就要入去讀至知啦!

佢既中學經常被人"彈", 係band2中學,所有學生係出面收番來, 好多新直資中學無自己學生, 初期都要收band1尾or band2,到有自己培養出來學生,就5會收出面既學生或者收少好多.         

原文章由 aclam 於 07-10-17 13:56 硐表
I don't like st.margaret. The campus is too small for both primary and secondary school. The higher grade students  look too 'in' to me.

[ 本文章最後由 catcatmom 於 07-10-17 14:43 編輯 ]

sara

其實我自己好鍾意呢類學校,而且好近我屋企,學費reasonable!
but我自己學校有一個來自陳守仁的學生,紀律勁差,不過間間學校都有好學生&壞學生,所以我覺得不能一概而論,but我朋友教北區一間EMI名校,佢又話佢間學校有2個細路來自陳守仁,又係紀律好差,除英文好外就一無事處,唔知會唔會係前幾年間學校reputation無咁好,收左d無咁好既學生呢?
但係點解咁多人報??
所以我都好擔心個女入左呢d學校後,d紀律變得越來越差,又學唔到野,到頭來得番個桔 真係令我好頭痕!

ST.MARGARET個中學部一定收埋D唔好既學生,因為之前REPUTATION唔好,但由小學升中學的學生應該會好D!好似培橋中學既學生都係一般(因為我學校有個成績一般既學生轉左去讀),因為都係無得揀!我相信呢類學校將來中學部的學生一定會好D!

其實ST.MARGARET既COMMENT係點?有無多D資料??

gordon

Sara,

果然志同道合, 睇黎其實大家都係傾向st. margaret 多d.

gordon

原文章由 sara 於 07-10-17 19:19 硐表
其實我自己好鍾意呢類學校,而且好近我屋企,學費reasonable!
but我自己學校有一個來自陳守仁的學生,紀律勁差,不過間間學校都有好學生&壞學生,所以我覺得不能一概而論,but我朋友教北區一間EMI名校,佢又話佢間學校有2個 ...

catcatmom

我想一般直資學校既小朋友都會係活活潑潑,有好多可能仲係資優tim, 多口型,計仔多多, 充滿自信果類, 所以d家長先至唔比佢地讀傳統小學,比錢讀直資學校, 但係唔係無紀律, 就唔知啦! 我識個讀陳守仁既小朋友又好乖喎! 不過佢係女仔.!

雖然陳守仁d英文好好, 因科科都係英文(除中文), 但果個小朋友每星期都要去搵外籍補英文oral, 差唔多$1000/m, 錢又一問題, 仲有時間呢!佢好似要去到中環(佢住新畀) 這些與外籍老師不足原因有關,老師係外國讀完書番離, 始終唔係土生土長,d音都係差好多!  

我想讀st margaret,應該不用去這些course嗎? 最多都係補英文既grammer機會多d, 或者到時grammer可以自己教, oral就一定唔可以自己教.

這些points純粹個人推測.我估想英文好,兩間都唔錯.外籍老師有外籍老師好處, 本地老師有本地老師好處.

原文章由 gordon 於 07-10-17 19:26 硐表
Sara,

果然志同道合, 睇黎其實大家都係傾向st. margaret 多d.

gordon

[ 本文章最後由 catcatmom 於 07-10-17 21:21 編輯 ]

gordon

catcatmom

千奇唔好誤會, 我並冇覺得TSL d學生無紀律, 更何況我先生根本就係lay間學校前身 (portugese camoes school, 好似係咁上吓名) 既畢業生. 都係好睇個小朋友自己. 我地比較open minded, 我估人地講既無紀律, 在我地眼中可能係活潑.:
只係st. Margaret's 既concept, 我同我先生非常agree.

原文章由 catcatmom 於 07-10-17 21:07 硐表
我想一般直資學校既小朋友都會係活活潑潑,有好多可能仲係資優tim, 多口型,計仔多多, 充滿自信果類, 所以d家長先至唔比佢地讀傳統小學,比錢讀直資學校, 但係唔係無紀律, 就唔知啦! 我識個讀陳守仁既小朋友又好乖喎!  ...

catcatmom

gordon

唔好意思!我求其羅左你個message來回應, 等你誤會了!
睇sara既留言,佢應該係學校做, 選校應該好有心德, 起馬消息靈通d,TSL係好自由, d小朋友係好active, 之前我個仔既同學's弟弟讀TSL,佢媽咪想佢轉番亞哥間傳統學校, 但佢亞媽話,算啦! 無可能啦!TSL係好free,轉到佢亞哥果間一定唔慣喎!

保良局陳守仁小學原名賈梅士小學，改名因為新校舍獲得陳守仁捐出三百多萬興建，故新校舍以陳守仁先生命名。賈梅士之前係尖沙咀近佐敦,又低調, 英文又教得好,d畢業生英文係好好,當年用了很多外籍老師(南亞籍老師),葡籍學生?
資料對嗎?
我今年參觀了很直資(TSL我miss左),有好多直資學校既理念很好,很理想化,最怕眼高手低,但st. margaret's好商業味,但i like.陳守仁就會谷d,比起其他直資而言.

原文章由 gordon 於 07-10-17 21:25 硐表
catcatmom

千奇唔好誤會, 我並冇覺得TSL d學生無紀律, 更何況我先生根本就係lay間學校前身 (portugese camoes school, 好似係咁上吓名) 既畢業生. 都係好睇個小朋友自己. 我地比較open minded, 我估人地講既無紀律, ...

[ 本文章最後由 catcatmom 於 07-10-17 22:12 編輯 ]

gordon

掂都好, 大家要加油. 為目標而努力.

請問仲有冇多 d 家長對這兩間學校有唔同comments. 歡迎 歡迎

原文章由 catcatmom 於 07-10-17 22:02 硐表
gordon

唔好意思!我求其羅左你個message來回應, 等你誤會了!
睇sara既留言,佢應該係學校做, 選校應該好有心德, 起馬消息靈通d,TSL係好自由, d小朋友係好active, 之前我個仔既同學's弟弟讀TSL,佢媽咪想佢轉番亞哥間 ...

old8hk

原文章由 sara 於 07-10-17 19:19 硐表
其實我自己好鍾意呢類學校,而且好近我屋企,學費reasonable!
but我自己學校有一個來自陳守仁的學生,紀律勁差,不過間間學校都有好學生&壞學生,所以我覺得不能一概而論,but我朋友教北區一間EMI名校,佢又話佢間學校有2個 ...

陳守仁轉左校長，教學方向可能同前個位唔同。我就見過果個女校長，感覺唔到佢對小朋友有愛心。見到家長同小朋友晨早去interview,竟然叫個校工落閘，唔好啤人入去佢間學校。個時喺８：３５，面試時間喺９：００。俾人入去去下廁所，俾小朋友定下神都要啦。

vet

前陳守仁校長好friendly架,我在open day 和面試都見過她,
小朋友好似好鐘意佢,成日都四萬甘口,
陳守仁校舍那有閘可落?
他們全用推閘,未夠鐘當然唔開啦!

雖然她已退休,聽說新的男校長也不錯,
最可惜我個女入唔到

3b

*Quote*
雖然陳守仁d英文好好, 因科科都係英文(除中文), 但果個小朋友每星期都要去搵外籍補英文oral, 差唔多$1000/m, 錢又一問題, 仲有時間呢!佢好似要去到中環(佢住新畀) 這些與外籍老師不足原因有關,老師係外國讀完書番離, 始終唔係土生土長,d音都係差好多!
*Unquote*

catcatmom,

想請問下這個小朋友本身英文程度如何 ? 幼稚園是否就讀於基本以中文教學為主的學校, 所以跟不上 ?

G-Ma

st. margaret's 既校舍同隔離英華比就一定細架啦, 英華一級5班, 35-40人一班, 剛是小學已經有1000到1200人, 仲未計中學, 梗係要大d啦.  st. margaret's 小學每級只係得80個學生, 小學生總數都只係500人以下,  而且中, 小學返學放學, 小息, 午飯時間都唔一樣, 無咩機會共用學校場地, 其實地方係好夠用, 所以呢方面大家唔需要擔心.  有時間係返學, 小息時間去參觀吓, 就會知道小朋友既活動空間係好充足.

原文章由 aclam 於 07-10-17 13:56 硐表
I don't like st.margaret. The campus is too small for both primary and secondary school. The higher grade students  look too 'in' to me.

catcatmom

這個小朋友d英文很好,入去陳守仁之前已很好. 雖然讀屋村中文幼稚園(英文極很差,無外籍老師果類幼稚園,但中文就很好.), 但佢媽咪1.5歲比佢讀ymca playgroup,3歲就搵外籍教,跟到去小學.

係陳仁守裡面,邊個中文好,就邊個跑出, 唔係"英文"!佢係全級10名.成績很好!  

原文章由 3b 於 07-10-18 10:51 硐表
*Quote*
雖然陳守仁d英文好好, 因科科都係英文(除中文), 但果個小朋友每星期都要去搵外籍補英文oral, 差唔多$1000/m, 錢又一問題, 仲有時間呢!佢好似要去到中環(佢住新畀) 這些與外籍老師不足原因有關,老師係外國讀 ...

sara

我係在EMI中學(唔算好TOP,BUT都叫BAND ONE)做野,而家放產假等生所以得閒D!不過就真係同揀學校無咩關係!我D同事D仔女全部都讀"谷"及傳統名校,係得我揀呢D佢地認為係好RISKY既學校!

其實在傳統EMI學校,根本唔係個個細路可以接受英語教學,以我觀察所見,5班裏面其實得3班叫跟得上,其餘兩班都係跟得好辛苦!

那天去st.margaret second in,我都有向個head teacher query,因為st.m唔係行IB,遲d會參加香港會考文憑(即334 system個試)!咁會唔會銜接唔到?個HEAD TEACHER話其實佢地上到唔知小學幾多年級就會開始著重成績,如果成績唔好,佢地年頭10月就會通知定家長 ,叫家長留意子女可能要留班 ,然後會cut個細路既午膳or課外活動時間,參加增潤課程!星期六都有增潤課程,我唔太記得係點run,不過好似係學生(唔記得幾多年級)alternative sat.要返去上,or參加制服團隊,不過又唔知係唔係會實行到呢?

CandiceMaMi

I would choice are St. margaren's, 因為少班教學,英文很深,
P1要講英文,同國語.

:

CheCheMan

Sorry for making some parents feel worry abt my comment on TSL.

As told by my friend that her daugther got a place there around 3 years ago.  As at that moment, some students from other countries, like India, Indonesia and Pakistan, has allocated to the same class of my friend's daughter.  U know, the culture of the countries is rather different to HK, so my friend's daughter suffered a lot and the teachers there also busy in tackling problems arised from this issue.

Moreover, most Eng. teachers are NOT native, so many students need to attend other Eng. courses after school.

So luckily that my friend's daugther has successfully changed to CKY last year.  As told by my friend that her daughter like CKY very much coz there's so many activities arranged for her to choose and the teachers are so nice to her.  The most important is the girl no need to face the kids of other countries who always behaved so rude....etc.

Although the school fee is comparative expensive in CKY, but my friend told me its worth coz my friend has save extra money for the girl to attend other language courses after school.   Her daughter also learnt to find info and to do project by herself.

That's the reason I pick up CKY for my boy lor~

Wish such comment doesn't affect the decision of other parents.

CCM

原文章由 WYmom 於 07-10-17 14:19 硐表


CheCheMan,

Can you just tell the comments of TSL even it is negative?  I think every school has positive and negative comments and it is better for parents to know both.  I also heard some friends  ...