有無好的言語治療師介紹? - 特殊教育 - 教育王國

登錄 | 註冊

討論區

教育王國: 教育講場; 使用意見

幼兒教育: 幼校討論; 幼教雜談

小學教育: 小一選校; 小學雜談

中學教育: 升中派位; 中學交流; 初中教育

專上教育: 備戰大學; 選科選校

國際教育: 國際學校; 海外留學

知識增值: 課外活動; 教材閱讀; 公開考試; 深造進修

特殊教育: 特殊教育; 資優教育; 自閉寶寶; 智能評估

徵求專區: 二手市場; 誠徵老師; 組班專區; 徵保母車

聯絡管理員

教育王國 › 討論區 › 特殊教育 › 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

發新帖

樓主: 承承媽媽	go 有無好的言語治療師介紹? [複製鏈接]

Rank: 4


	949

21^#

發表於 04-10-12 07:45 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

Raymond said that my son was very easy to train as he was very co-operative. He gave my son one hour training for three times a week. I didn't know whether this was the reason for him to give me 7:00p.m.

Although my ST is just a fresh graduate from HKU, she is very dedicated to her work and my son enjoys being with her. His progress is quite good. I think that good teacher-student relationship is also an important factor for effective learning.

我們怕孩子的人生路途滿佈荊棘，與其為孩子在路上舖一層地毯，不如在孩子的腳上穿上一雙鞋。

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1463

22^#

發表於 04-10-13 02:05 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

我想問一問各位有識之士的意見.
我本來打算搵香港痙攣協會,但係發覺要起碼等到12月才有位,我今日上網搵吓料,見到香港大學department of Speech and Hearing原來有clinic,可以book佢地d學生or tutor做training,不過當然tutor收費同私人sp差不多.我見私人的sp收費和口碑都各有不同,甚至有時毀譽參半,咁香港大學的clinic值不值得去試呢?

My Lovest Group-- Il Divo
Urs--Sebastien--Carlos--David

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2324

23^#

發表於 04-10-13 07:30 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

As a current university staff, I can tell you that some of my colleagues are good at teaching/researching but not practising, as they've been left the frontline for some time. There's no guarantee that university staff must be an experienced one...

Rank: 4


	949

24^#

發表於 04-10-13 07:53 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

承承媽媽,
The student STs at the clinic are under the supervision of the tutor from the university. Most of them are from Year 2. Student STs in Year 4 conduct practises in hospitals or special schools. It takes 4 years to complete the degree. So, you can imagine how 'green' the student STs at the clinic are. By the way, they just practise for several months. It means that your child will be taught by another person later. In my opinion, a child with speech delay should be taught by the same person so as to keep close follow-up of the child's progress.

我們怕孩子的人生路途滿佈荊棘，與其為孩子在路上舖一層地毯，不如在孩子的腳上穿上一雙鞋。

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3768

25^#

發表於 04-10-13 10:14 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

承承媽媽

既然香港大學的學生與私人的st差不多價錢, 點解要搵學生而不搵d真係有經驗呢?

我不想將我個仔當白老鼠比人當做實驗, 上次去大口環, 個醫生好似教學生甘, 成班學生係度當軒軒係白老鼠我已經好不開心.

Rank: 4


	597

26^#

發表於 04-10-13 20:24 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

承承媽媽,
你有否排政府?
ST是一個頗昂貴的服務,所以如果afford得起,qualified的st當然最好,否則,平平地,找hku學生都可考慮.
如果你排緊政府,可以的話,找qualified的吧!
至於找誰,我覺得好像看醫生,人夾人緣,好難講.

其實不一定找那些所謂志願機構,因他們這些st服務,都是賺錢的,不過,大公司,感覺好點.但如果排太耐,就不要考慮了(我聽說協康星期六的appointment排到下年!不知是真是假)

我有些資料,希望幫到你.
1.HKCS（香港基督教服務處）http://www.hkcs.org
2.Heep Hong Association（協康會）http://www.heephong.org
3.The Spastics Association of Hong Kong http://www.spastic.org.hk
4.香港聾人福利促進會 http://www.deaf.org.hk/speech.htm
[email protected]
5.The Hong Kong Association of Speech Therapists香港言語治療師協會
http://www.speechtherapy.org.hk (Contact HKAST for the list of private Speech Therapists at [email protected])

[

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3768

27^#

發表於 04-10-14 09:11 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

不好期望政府的st或者ot的訓練, 佢地的所謂訓練, 之不過係1個月1 次(st), 甚至2個月1次(ot), 還衰到要小組訓練, 如果排到小組訓練, 連個別訓練都會cut埋.

還有, 小組訓練不係長時間架bor, 得2-3堂之bor.

我成日諗, 交甘多稅都不知做mug, 去左邊?

Rank: 2


	59

28^#

發表於 04-10-14 10:21 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

HKU

<a href="http://www.picgoo.com" target="_blank">

[img]

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	103

29^#

發表於 04-10-14 10:34 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

detete

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3186

30^#

發表於 04-10-14 10:36 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

"我成日諗, 交甘多稅都不知做mug, 去左邊?"

fully agree

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1463

31^#

發表於 04-10-14 10:54 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

katharine,
如果你仔仔要5歲才發現有自閉傾向的話,我相信你小朋友的情況都不會太worse.我個仔由差不多一歲九個月開始已經有人同我講叫我去搵人check吓,而且我個仔係真係唔點肯望人,又唔肯講o野,所以至可以咁早去做assisment.不過佢自從返咗幼兒園已經好好多,起碼佢想食o野時叫佢講謝謝佢都會講(大部份時間),以前佢只會轉身走咗去咋!

My Lovest Group-- Il Divo
Urs--Sebastien--Carlos--David

Rank: 4


	949

32^#

發表於 04-10-14 13:26 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

Dear katharine,
My son's situation is similar to you.  My son was diagnosed as developmental delay by government CAC at the age of 3 years and 10 months.  But private child psychiatrist diagnosed him as autism, not just autistic.  If you hear from his scary saying, you really want to die.

My son also visited Raymond before.  But we hire another one later.

The ST from Duchess of Kent trained my son once every month for 15 minutes.  My son went there for three times and the service was stopped once my son got the 'I' place.

A newly graduated educational psychologist told me that a child with autistic features was not a child suffered from autism.  Even normal children may have a little bit.  He says that with proper training, the features (if not so severe) will diminish as he grows up.  He also mentions that parents should do their best to train their children before 7 years old.  After 7, it would be less effective.  His conclusion is that if the child's behaviour is not anti-social and does not affect his learning, just let go.  He is really a very caring psychologist.  He cares about my feeling.  Maybe, he just tries to comfort me.

我們怕孩子的人生路途滿佈荊棘，與其為孩子在路上舖一層地毯，不如在孩子的腳上穿上一雙鞋。

Rank: 4


	949

33^#

發表於 04-10-14 13:37 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

我成日諗, 交甘多稅都不知做mug, 去左邊?

We pay tax but we seldom benefit from the government. If my son completely relies on government's minimal ST service, my son will not make great progress. The CAC diagnosed my son to have fine motor skill delay for 9 months, but no OT was given. Even my son's 'I' place school's OT commented that my son is O.K.. I feel very angry about all these. If I don't seek for any training for my son, nobody will care. My friend's son (resides in Canada) suffers from moderate autism, he gets Applied Behaviour Analysis for 48 hours @ week and a special teacher teaches him on a one-to-one basis every day. The government provides all these. He is now 7 years old and his A-features are very very mild. How come our government just collects us tax but never cares about our children?

我們怕孩子的人生路途滿佈荊棘，與其為孩子在路上舖一層地毯，不如在孩子的腳上穿上一雙鞋。

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1308

34^#

發表於 04-10-14 23:08 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

katharine

我的情況同你相近，仔仔5歲幾，有自閉傾向，做左年幾訓練已經見到有進步。歡迎上o黎問下問題或者分享下感受。最緊要係接受同了解小朋友的強項、弱項，然後做適合的訓練。

每個小孩都是上帝用來提醒我們，這世間還有希望。——泰戈爾

Rank: 2


	59

35^#

發表於 04-10-15 10:56 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

看到你的說話，心裏也到好受些，希望如那位educational psychologist所講，我可以盡力去配合，令仔仔有所改變。

我想我是太遲才去證實他的問題，都是我的疏忽，三歲時忘了帶他去做智能測驗。四歲幾時才記起帶他去，就發覺他有問題，才去做follow up 排隊做assessment。其實我們也覺得他是的說話技能發展慢些，也明白每個孩子也不同，同時他比較內向，怕醜，點知原來是有問題，是他不太理解一些抽像問題.....等等，所以各位bk媽媽要醒些，早些發覺問題，早些處理，不用像我，我希望我不是太遲啦！

<a href="http://www.picgoo.com" target="_blank">

[img]

Rank: 2


	59

36^#

發表於 04-10-15 11:05 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

先前那回應是給mrsphcheung，忘了打上去，sorry。

kmwun,謝謝你，待我仔仔下星期二做完assessment，我再上來分享，及請教你的心得。

其實我已有心理準備，但總有個希望醫生告訴我他不是自閉的。你的仔仔有什麼病徵的呢﹖我看書，發覺我的仔仔較少主動去同人玩，不是時時有eye contact﹐也不明白抽像的東西，他很喜歡做某一個小動作，回答說話也較慢......

<a href="http://www.picgoo.com" target="_blank">

[img]

Rank: 2


	59

37^#

發表於 04-10-15 11:11 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

承承媽媽

我也希望像你所說不是太worse。我只怕我是太遲去處理問題。我相信及早發現，應該會好些，所以我也會自責，為何我那麼遲才去證實是否有問題，不過，我也知現在應盡力去面對，不是後悔。

<a href="http://www.picgoo.com" target="_blank">

[img]

Rank: 1


	26

38^#

發表於 04-10-16 22:20 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

I think all the tax we paid has gone to the " fireworks , unresponsible Govn't officers, totally useless fomalities ..." :evil:
That's why we should not just relied on the government but we need to do our therapy and home program harder.

Rank: 1


	26

39^#

發表於 04-10-16 22:22 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

Hi Katherine,
no need to blame yourself la.
Try your best in the future to help him is the solution.
Add oil

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1308

40^#

發表於 04-10-19 23:13 |只看該作者

Re: 有無好的言語治療師介紹?

katharine

我仔仔是在K2時學校跟我說仔仔上堂時有特別的表現，我們才帶仔仔往做評估。健康院見他未能完成三歲的智能測驗，只安排三歲半再回去，三歲半未能完成只安排三個月後再回去。所以那怕你有去做三歲的智能測驗亦未必有用。

我仔仔很抗拒eye contact；不明白其他人的表情或身體語言；對抽像的東西很難明白，例如他不難明知為什麼每個人亦稱呼自己做我；間中會有固執行為等等。幸好他是智力正常，醫生亦說仔仔可以叫高功能的自閉症，或有亞士保加症。但我很同意心理學家所講，叫甚麼不重要，重要的是我們接受他們，了解小朋友的需要。坦白說要不是仔仔有自閉傾向我們相處的時間一定會比現在少，我亦不會這樣留意他。別的小朋友輕易做到的事情，他們可能要經過訓練才能做到，但那時候那份喜悅又是別人所沒有的。

Anyway既然擔心能亦改變不了現實，放開一點。做完assessment，記得上來分享！

每個小孩都是上帝用來提醒我們，這世間還有希望。——泰戈爾

‹ 上一主題|下一主題 ›

發新帖

熱門主題

最高瀏覽主題

Copyright © 2002 - 2024 Baby-Kingdom.com Limited, All Rights Reserved.
有關我們
使用條款
免責聲明
私穩政策
廣告查詢