英華vs顏寶玲 - 升中派位

hoihoima

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	8186

22^#

發表於 15-2-17 18:17 |只看該作者

YYmommom 發表於 15-2-17 13:27
5**=A
5*=B
5=C

如果這樣，3322 就等於 EEFF？

點評

joyjoyparent

發表於 15-2-21 22:17

bbforever

伯爵府

Rank: 8 Rank: 8


	19619

23^#

發表於 15-2-17 18:24 |只看該作者

如果有興趣IB課程可揀顏寶玲~

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	9387

24^#

發表於 15-2-17 19:16 |只看該作者

回覆 yiphalook 的帖子

Not necessarily. All YWPS students will be admitted to YWC due to the through train relationship. It means that YWC S1 intakes may include some Band 2 students of YWPS.
Before the revive of its feeder primary school, all S1 intakes of YWC should be Band 1.

yiphalook

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	8220

25^#

發表於 15-2-17 21:14 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 yiphalook 於 15-2-17 21:27 編輯

KikiDaddy 發表於 15-2-17 19:16
回覆 yiphalook 的帖子

Not necessarily. All YWPS students will be admitted to YWC due to the through ...

我係講呢兩年英華書院開始接收英華小學轉直資後直升嘅S1生，就算小學頭幾名轉會，整體S1生質素應有所提升，所以英華書未來DSE成績理應向上。

bubuG

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	5113

26^#

發表於 15-2-17 21:17 |只看該作者

引用：回覆+yiphalook+的帖子 Not+necessarily.+

原帖由 KikiDaddy 於 15-02-17 發表
回覆 yiphalook 的帖子

Not necessarily. All YWPS students will be admitted to YWC due to the through ...

Same situation in schools like DBS/SPCC??

celia8823

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	153

27^#

發表於 15-2-17 23:57 |只看該作者

如果運動唔好,淨講讀仔,那間會好Ｄ,

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	9387

28^#

發表於 15-2-18 01:11 |只看該作者

回覆 yiphalook 的帖子

My concern about the quality of YWC S1 intakes are based on the followings: -

1. Top private schools like APS normally have around 70% Band 1 students. Assuming YWPS students quality are similar to those top private schools, YWC still need to admit 30% Band 2 / 3 students from YWPS;

2. YWPS is not a primary school that focus only on academic training. It offers a large variety of activities for students to participate. If you are music / sport school team members, you need to spend lots of time in practicing and competition. Hence, the academic standard of YWPS students may not necessarily be better than those Band 1 students admitted from other primary schools;

3. At least at this moment, YWC is not a first choice DSS school for most of the Band 1A students. If you are a Band 1A student, you will probably accept the offer from SPCC / DBS to give up a chance of trying QC / LS at Discretionary Stage of SSPA. If the offer is from YWC, most of the Band 1A students would probably give up; and

4. YWC have a strong preference to those S1 applicants with superior sport achievement.

Hence, it may be premature to jump to the conclusion that the DSE results of YWC will improve just because of having a feeder primary school.

I am not saying YWC is not a good school but more transparency about its DSE results would be welcome.

點評

heytravel

發表於 15-2-20 16:20

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	9387

29^#

發表於 15-2-18 01:18 |只看該作者

回覆 bubuG 的帖子

The situation of DBS / SPCC is better.
Both schools need to accept Band 2 students from their primary feeder schools. However, SPCC's S1 intakes from external schools are all Band 1A students while most of DBS' S1 external intakes are Band 1A students except for a small batch of students with excellent achievement in music / sports.

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	9387

30^#

發表於 15-2-18 01:28 |只看該作者

回覆王家爸爸的帖子

The problem of YWC is the lack of transparency in its DSE results. External people is difficult to assess its performance. Some schools like SPCC, DGS, SJC, SY and Munsang have a very detailed analysis of their DSE performances.
Just based on the DSE English results disclosed, I would say YWC is just mediocre even for a Band 1B school.

hadwinboy

大宅

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3667

31^#

發表於 15-2-20 01:31 |只看該作者

引用：回覆+王家爸爸+的帖子 The+problem+of+YWC

原帖由 KikiDaddy 於 15-02-18 發表
回覆王家爸爸的帖子

The problem of YWC is the lack of transparency in its DSE results. External pe ...

路過，我仔是YW P2. 我覺得YWPS 英文程度都算深(比起某些地區名小或一缐尾私校), 因我比較過評估卷。如果以這程度上到YWC考DSE 取5* 也只是 27點幾%, 那麼勁top 名校那些學生例如SPCC 真的好勁! 好彩唔收我個仔，唔係收左都讀唔掂

點評

bobbob 唔係5*,係5咋發表於 15-2-20 09:15

bobbob

侯爵府

Rank: 9 Rank: 9 Rank: 9

醒目開學勳章


	20236

32^#

發表於 15-2-20 09:30 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 bobbob 於 15-2-20 09:31 編輯

王家爸爸發表於 15-2-17 09:36
跟SJC既62.7%比較YWC既27.7%當然低，但係如果同香港平均9.1%比較已經係3倍。其實其他B1中學校，例如聖言， ...

SPCC	DGS	SPCS	GHS	SJC	BPS	YWGS	UCCKE	HKUGAC	CCSC	Tang Hin	YWC
90.6	88.5	81.8	80.0	62.7	58.9	57.8	42.3	38.3	35.3	35.1	27.7

莫講話神校，連地區名津或B1尾新派直資都比唔上，英文成績令人失望。

Rank: 15


	132916

33^#

發表於 15-2-20 13:24 |只看該作者

bobbob 發表於 15-2-20 09:30
莫講話神校，連地區名津或B1尾新派直資都比唔上，英文成績令人失望。
...

用另一角度睇，鄧顯係新界第二成績好既B1頭地區名校，都係35.1%。作為B1中嘅學校，27.7%一啲都唔失禮。記住，平均香港只有9.1％。

點評

twcho 乜鄧顯唔係新界最勁的學校咩？發表於 15-2-24 23:14

heytravel

發表於 15-2-20 16:21

ccj2008

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	5521

34^#

發表於 15-2-20 19:59 |只看該作者

回覆王家爸爸的帖子

請問鄧顯第二，邊間第一

點評

王家爸爸葵青區的聖公會林護紀念中學發表於 15-2-20 21:42

Rank: 15


	132916

35^#

發表於 15-2-20 21:45 |只看該作者

ccj2008 發表於 15-2-20 19:59
回覆王家爸爸的帖子

請問鄧顯第二，邊間第一

林護的英文比鄧顯好，其他科差別不大。

bobbob

侯爵府

Rank: 9 Rank: 9 Rank: 9

醒目開學勳章


	20236

36^#

發表於 15-2-20 21:59 |只看該作者

王家爸爸發表於 15-2-20 13:24
用另一角度睇，鄧顯係新界第二成績好既B1頭地區名校，都係35.1%。作為B1中嘅學校，27.7%一啲都唔失禮。記住 ...

點解響咁多學校你只提鄧顯？HKUGAC同UCCKE又點解呢？除咗上述學校，我相信唔少b1b-b1c嘅津校嘅英文成績好過ywc (e.g. st mark's)，只不過列出5 or above嘅學校唔多。
而且YWC響ek家長心目中係「類神校」，入得去嘅都要過5關斬6將，學術成績理應睇高幾線，唔係一般嘅b1b學校，如果我係家長我唔會收貨。

bobbob

侯爵府

Rank: 9 Rank: 9 Rank: 9

醒目開學勳章


	20236

37^#

發表於 15-2-20 22:01 |只看該作者

王家爸爸發表於 15-2-20 21:45
林護的英文比鄧顯好，其他科差別不大。

唔知點解你會話林護好過鄧顯，整體成績一定鄧顯好啲

點評

elbar 心水清

發表於 15-2-20 22:07

Rank: 15


	132916

38^#

發表於 15-2-20 23:50 |只看該作者

bobbob 發表於 15-2-20 21:59
點解響咁多學校你只提鄧顯？HKUGAC同UCCKE又點解呢？除咗上述學校，我相信唔少b1b-b1c嘅津校嘅英文成績好過 ...

只提鄧顯係因為鄧顯被吹到好勁，所以用來比較。我唔知點解你覺得YWC會係「類神校」，佢只係一間典型B1中學校。

Rank: 15


	132916

39^#

發表於 15-2-21 00:25 |只看該作者

林護同鄧顯其實係因為區內其他對手弱，加上學校近十年策略正確，製造另類邊緣效應。吸引區內同鄰近地區嘅B1A學生（尤其喺唔想長途跋涉出九龍及香港島嘅人），學生越收越好，所以成績好主要係因為收到既學生勁（估計幾乎係B1A生）。
但係WYC唔同，WYC收到既應該有唔少B2學生（自己小學）同B1中生+邊緣人（外校生）。WYC收到嘅學生平均只有B1尾左右水平，但係整體DSE有B1中水平，所以其實WYC嘅附加價值更多。

yiphalook