樓主: redkoni
|
go
2013年升中 khmama對各區英中學額分析(巳更新)+各區學生人數 [複製鏈接] |
|
||||||||
|
||||||||
|
||||||||
|
||||||||
|
||||||||
|
引用:Quote:原帖由+Band5+於+13-04-19+發表我的
點評
elmkc
Band 2 schools of last year can be Band 1 schools of this year. So, the so called "first" band 2 school is difficult to determine.
| ||||||||
|
||||||||
|
||||||||
|
||||||||
|
點評
elmkc
It is because everyone holds a list of bands 1 to 3 schools. They don't know that your first band 2 school is an unknown, which cannot be determined until the results are finalised in the coming July
elmkc
Your suggestion will make other parents think that if they put all band 1 schools on the list before the first band 2 school, then their children must get in this band 2 school.
elmkc
I mean partially correct.
elmkc
Your deduction is correct. But, the question is: where is this "first" band 2 school in your rank? A band 2 school (as previously known) can become band 1 if it is filled with all band 1 students.
| ||||||||
|
點評
jcctiu
第六間選band2太保守了,建議最少第11間才開始揀band2.
| ||||||||
|
引用:今天見老師,她說囡囡是band1組別學生,本
點評
jcctiu
多數是,但也有可能是老師自己都唔識.
| ||||||||
|
引用:+本帖最後由+kls12+於+13-4-20+06:51+編輯+
| ||||||||
|
||||||||
|
||||||||
|
||||||||
|
引用:+本帖最後由+kls12+於+13-4-20+18:51+編輯+
| ||||||||
|
點評
elmkc
For some well received schools, it is possible to predict that they will accept all B1 students. For borderline schools (the so called B1c, B2a, B2c, B3a schools), the uncertainty increases.
elmkc
There is no guarantee that the B1 student can get in the so called B2A school as the rank order of schools is just an estimation. There are no B1,2,3 schools but B1,2,3 students.
elmkc
HY412 was wrong because that B1 student will not compete with B2A students but other B1 students.
elmkc
So, a band1 student chose this so called band2A school and guesses that he or she can get in it. Finally, he or she may not get in it.
elmkc
For an extreme example, if a so called Band 2A school was chosen by most band1 students in this year as first choice, then it will become a band1 school this year as it receives all band1 students.
| ||||||||
|
回覆:2013年升中 khmama對各區英中學額初步分析 + 各區學生人數統計
| ||||||||
‹ 上一主題|下一主題 › |