到底 St Catherine International 有什麼好 ?

NICOLE123

原帖由 bbfonghk 於 10-12-3 12:12 發表
我都係往東九龍區,一般家庭,都收左我個女,所以應該唔會是選擇家長的背景及住宅區.

不過interview就真係安排得麻麻地...

去年安排得真係好好. 好多人鑽
今年係天雨影響真係天意
大家都辛苦 我唔參與其中都感受到
不小朋友今年都有風雨下面試
小朋友都係在風雨下成長 唔跌唔識大
邊個家長唔心痛自己既小朋友
不過"食得咸魚抵得渴"就係咁解
但就係因為咁比人評為"垃圾學校" 是否有點過份 ?

yinyinmama2008

Agree with you.

原帖由 lovelinda 於 10-12-3 11:40 發表
大家唔好咁激動啦!都係discuss下啫,個個都想自己仔女入到心目中最理想的學校,表達各自的意見唔緊要,但唔好傷和氣呀!

我個女都有sc 和 kv 的 offer, 但我2間都唔會choose,我都知sc 和 kv都有 plenty of adv. ...

bbfonghk

其實話邊間學校點好點唔好,都只有本校家自己先知...

hosuper

我的仔仔收到Kv offer but SC waiting。我自己覺得佢兩間表現都不俗。從很多bk留言，知道in KV或SC的小朋友中，表現得好而又不獲取錄的多不勝數，但我感覺到準SC家長對自己子女能有offers而感到異常驚訝的數目（多數因為他們也認為子女表現未如理想）比取得kv offers而驚訝的家長比較多。

SC要求父母填寫小學資料，但KV冇。我有少少相信同呢項有關。冇關係做咩要人填。不過都係一句「願者上約」。玩得呢個遊戲，就要守佢遊戲規則。

fatfatcheung

Agree 2! Welcome ah Yin Yin Ma, i am also a new player here, let's share our experience! Hope yr child will get a good result in Kinder.

原帖由 NICOLE123 於 10-12-3 12:16 發表


去年安排得真係好好. 好多人鑽
今年係天雨影響真係天意
大家都辛苦 我唔參與其中都感受到
不小朋友今年都有風雨下面試
小朋友都係在風雨下成長 唔跌唔識大
邊個家長唔心痛自己既小朋友
不過"食得咸魚抵得渴"就係咁 ...

siden

食得咸魚抵得渴

Yes I agree. This is the rule of the game.

Oh I there are so many years of 咸魚 to eat later.

fatfatcheung

Agree! 我填表時都覺得怪, 家長背景資料跟本沒用, 所以都幾sure, some of the applications will consider their background

Toffeenut

原帖由 hosuper 於 10-12-3 12:27 發表
我的仔仔收到Kv offer but SC waiting。我自己覺得佢兩間表現都不俗。從很多bk留言，知道in KV或SC的小朋友中，表現得好而又不獲取錄的多不勝數，但我感覺到準SC家長對自己子女能有offers而感到異常驚訝的數目（多數因為他們 ...

如果係呢個point(小學), 咁我個case就唔係, 我小學是屯門的屋邨學校. 我相信係睇好多野的.

yinyinmama2008

Hi fatfatcheung mama, thank you for your support, i have 2 sons and 1 baby girl now and i never met this experience before.  I think we can share in further with our good or bad experience..... I got both Vic and SC offer yesterday, but i think i wont choose both...because i want my baby girl to stay in a normal kindergarten may be good for her happy life... Just Kindergarten level already have a keen competition see our mother's life is also .... not easy......Add Oil !

hosuper

Not 100% applicable to all kids (especially those outstanding kids).  
However, it is quite true that there are more "surprising" outcomes from SC because there are many more irrelevant information which is required by SC.

原帖由 Toffeenut 於 10-12-3 12:52 發表

如果係呢個point(小學), 咁我個case就唔係, 我小學是屯門的屋邨學校. 我相信係睇好多野的.

yinyinmama2008

Yes totally agreed.  The reason for SC is famous i think this is because of some parents prepare to shift to CCKG for K2.... and go for DGS...

hydaddy

原帖由 NICOLE123 於 10-12-3 12:16 發表
小朋友都係在風雨下成長 唔跌唔識大
邊個家長唔心痛自己既小朋友
不過"食得咸魚抵得渴"就係咁解
但就係因為咁比人評為"垃圾學校" 是否有點過份 ?

個位家長心知肚明sc唔係垃圾，如果真係垃圾就唔會去申請，亦唔會介意收唔收到信啦。

近排壓力大，個位家長可能一時谷氣，投訴無門，先上黎出感既言論，又唔怪得佢既。不過sc的確太多人話好，期望高左，失望咪越大羅。

[ 本帖最後由 hydaddy 於 10-12-3 15:54 編輯 ]

Toffeenut

原帖由 hosuper 於 10-12-3 12:59 發表
Not 100% applicable to all kids (especially those outstanding kids).  
However, it is quite true that there are more "surprising" outcomes from SC because there are many more irrelevant information wh ...

咁我都同意, 填寫的資料與子女學習表現未必有關.

pooncy

My son got accepted by SC. But my primary school was already closed. My husband's primary school is not famous. My son's performance is not so good as I think.

chowhui97

其實學校都好難做架, 外面啲人等得耐又俾人話, 去到in時又話自己得嗰幾分鐘, 又話老師無俾機會小朋友唔夠耐性.  

咁你入面講得耐自然外面等得耐啦!

我自己都係waiting咋, 不過我唔會怪間學校, 更加唔會因一樣事就話呢間學校係"垃圾"...

chowhui97

原帖由 BeBeMa1012 於 10-12-3 14:06 發表
唔好意思, 我好想問一樣野, 其實係唔係真係咁差呀?
因我仔唔係5 or6號interview的, 我仔in那天沒有下雨, 都好順利, 只等了15mins 內, 但我當日無參觀學校, 因有小朋友在上堂, 我只見到d單車真的幾舊, 其他都唔係好知 ...

我都係 6 號 interview, 我可能早, 9:30am 都算順利, 前後一個鐘左右.  我覺得入面已經有好多好多老師維持秩序, 而且大部份都係笑笑口架.

好難做到個個都滿意, 之前有媽咪怪自己無做好準備, 無帶嘢同bb玩同食, 所以個 b interview in 得唔好, 有啲媽咪就會怪學校law.

講差, 大把學校仲差, 連交表都要親身去排, 仲要係weekday呀!

haydenden1023

我雖然係waiting
不過收都唔讀
我有個朋友個仔而家讀緊k3
考唔到band1學校
叩門連band2都唔收
原來無咩優勢
不過可能係個別事件
所以都唔太執著名校

你可以有你見地, 我亦有我意見~~