請問各位會怎樣選擇?陳守仁,SFA,德望及蔡繼友

hidingdong

Dear ningman,
請問你的女兒讀邊間幼稚園呀? 謝謝

cathycr611

I think SFA is better based on DGJS unsuccessful. I have some doubts about CKY esp. it is so new and so many different version regarding the school. So is GHS. Whatever reasons, if a school has many different views, I think the school has some problems.

15分

           

Cathyneo

1.   我贊成interview 既家長唔等於入讀既家長，唔可以用來批評學校。
2.   不同地區家長既打扮只係一個觀察，我無conclusion既。
3.   唔同既家長有唔同既要求，好難話邊間最好。

如果經濟條件好好，預定囡囡初中或高中已經出國，我會揀CKY。
如果經濟條件OK，想係香港讀大學，我會揀德望。
如果想學費平啲，升中派得好啲，我會揀SFA。
如果小朋友活潑啲，想ENG TALK得，預左中學讀直資，或唔驚派位，我會揀陳守仁。
cathy

15分

"想ENG TALK得"

Hay, 應該其他三間英文都不錯, 有些更好過佢.  

ningman

我很十分感謝各位家長意見,我會詳細想一想那間學校比較適合我女兒.
另本人想問一問有小朋友在tsl讀書的家長,學校有些外國學生,他們是否很頑皮及野蠻,因在interview時與到他們在一組內,他們將所有拼圖據為己有,不給予其他小朋友,而他們的家長沒有理他們,要老師向他們拿取才給回小朋友.

塞曼莎

可能這些就是外國文化

請問係邊個國的文化.

ningman

印巴藉。
我不是種族岐視外國小朋友   

ink

ningman 寫道:
印巴藉。
我不是種族岐視外國小朋友   

同意，我也不是種族岐視，雖然好多小朋友來自唔同國籍，但某些小朋友唔知是否因種族問題，經常愁眉苦臉，有d又會好自卑，所以我小朋友雖教到tsl 但都放棄左。

塞曼莎

明白, 這就是文化差距.

佢個List都有不少外國朋友. 一係同化佢,一係被佢同化.

  

HuiTung

People would easy to get a misconception about "developing a child with world vision" in such scenario.  Talking about developing a global child only exists in international school.

bau

Did TSL test kid's Potunghua ability?

15分

HuiTung,

what are you trying to say?   

G-Ma

係未夠資源去讀或者唔想讀國際學校嘅時候, 陳守仁都係一間唔錯嘅學校, 可以提供到一個環境比學生去認識吓其他民族嘅文化, 雖然係印巴藉, 但對於小朋友嚟講都係唔錯嘅體驗.  據知仲有日藉及韓藉嘅小朋友.

HuiTung 寫道:
People would easy to get a misconception about "developing a child with world vision" in such scenario.  Talking about developing a global child only exists in international school.

hoho2000

G-Ma 寫道:
係未夠資源去讀或者唔想讀國際學校嘅時候, 陳守仁都係一間唔錯嘅學校, 可以提供到一個環境比學生去認識吓其他民族嘅文化, 雖然係印巴藉, 但對於小朋友嚟講都係唔錯嘅體驗.  據知仲有日藉及韓藉嘅小朋友.

[quote]
HuiTung 寫道:
People would easy to get a misconception about "developing a child with world vision" in such scenario.  Talking about developing a global child only exists in international school.

[/quote]

With reference to BK parents' comments about TSL, most would think that TSL is an "International-like" school which charge least tuition fee. Most parents tend to believe that students studying in TSL would acquire good English - so it is worthwhile to study there. The other important point is: the child could benefit from other foreign students. I doubt what is the use of learning other cultures while you have to stay in HK to compete with other students for a place in a traditional secondary school!

I'm not saying that TSL is not a good school, in fact, so many parents support it, it must has its advantages. However, the secondary school allocation is really a consideration.

Seriously, if my child has so many good offers, I would be really happy, but at the same time, I would carefully select one that would benefit my child most.

G-Ma

hoho2000,

同"求學不是求分數"原理一樣, 唔係學樣樣野都為咗考學校嘅, 知識只不過係用來充實自己, 唔一定要有目的嘅.

steven804805

那真要看小朋友的性格，因為SFA及德望都較傳統，尤其是德望，功課壓力大，很少課外活動，學生較辛苦，但有中學銜接，而且學生很乖•
陳守仁及CKY 同屬保良局，陳守仁有較多國籍的小朋友，英文水準不俗，CKY太似國際模式，校風自由，紀律略為寬鬆，以英文及普通話為教學語言，學生溝通能力比書寫能力好，但未能銜接本地教育，如果只想小朋友開心，實踐求學不是求分數的理念，則可選CKY

BBCMum

現在搵食要講 creativity, presentation, EQ, managing uncertanity, analytical power, communication, problem solving 等技能，競爭亦全球化，以前有個degree已經有保證，現在有degree無skills就只可以做clerical的工作，並要面對平價地區人力資源的競爭。

所以個人認為，傳統背誦操練的教學在將來會不合時而，固不會考慮SFA及德望這類特色的學校。

CHUCHU

叫TSL以後穿拖鞋同涼鞋唔好派FORM,嘻!
interview 時好似酒店咁,衣著不整,不許進入,哈! 掂呀


cathyneo,

我都幾agree 你所講.

如果係我就:
1) 唔想煩中學,我會選德望 (但我又怕辛苦)
2) 想深又程度更高,我會選SFA (但我又唔鍾意係深水埗)
3) 想英語教學,九龍區冇mug 選擇,我會選tsl (但我又唔高興佢冇中學,派位過往又一般)
4) 想讀有國際學校橂式,但又想學下中文喎,我選cky (但我冇打算將來送佢到外國讀書喎)

Cathyneo 寫道:
1.   我贊成interview 既家長唔等於入讀既家長，唔可以用來批評學校。
2.   不同地區家長既打扮只係一個觀察，我無conclusion既。
3.   唔同既家長有唔同既要求，好難話邊間最好。

如果經濟條件好好，預定囡囡初中或高中已經出國，我會揀CKY。
如果經濟條件OK，想係香港讀大學，我會揀德望。
如果想學費平啲，升中派得好啲，我會揀SFA。
如果小朋友活潑啲，想ENG TALK得，預左中學讀直資，或唔驚派位，我會揀陳守仁。
cathy

Cathyneo

我都係煩緊呢樣野，不過我已經放棄左陳守仁，因為st.jo收左，嗰幾日即係頭都頭都爆，幾鍾意陳守仁既學習環境，但係又諗到囝囝要好努力fight低三分二人先至可以keep到band1，仲要再考中學
同樣努力係st jo，可以直上中學。最係都係揀st jo。

cathy