KV 有咩好?

smartmatt

原帖由 manstap 於 09-11-16 16:27 發表
hahha totally agree

they train kids to recite like ROBOTS. Just wonder the parents what do they think

Unless your kid is an exceptional talent then reciting is one way parents use to get good results fast.   But, I don't think KV train kids to be ROBOTS, at least the ones I know are not robots.

cheungmingwai

我不大肯定, 大家未掌握數百名學生的生日月份!
但小女的一班, 從每月之星的壁報板,就沒有11月及12月出生的小朋友!

原帖由 ikebukuro 於 09-11-16 23:47 發表
Is it usually accept big BB only? As I see the mama said it's better and easier for big BB to adapt such teaching method. Thanks!

orange22

我囝囝三年前在KV畢業，在小學生活沒有難度，適應比其它的快。唔覺得英文不足，如果想選SC話英文比較好，我就選維記好過。

beautiful_mama

原帖由 orange22 於 09-11-17 00:47 發表
我囝囝三年前在KV畢業，在小學生活沒有難度，適應比其它的快。唔覺得英文不足，如果想選SC話英文比較好，我就選維記好過。

I think KV's english OK.
But if U say Victoria's english is better than SC's.
Well.....I don't think so. (personal point of view)

MAMAMEEE

聽講SC的學生除咗英文好之外, 仲好Presentable + confidence. 如果真係嘅話, 咁就啱哂我杯茶!

bebelee

Honestly my cousin studied in KC (K3) now.  Her english is good but if you are expecting presentable and confidence then I don't think my cousin is up to this level.

原帖由 MAMAMEEE 於 09-11-17 13:57 發表
聽講SC的學生除咗英文好之外, 仲好Presentable + confidence. 如果真係嘅話, 咁就啱哂我杯茶!

smartmatt

原帖由 bebelee 於 09-11-17 14:06 發表
Honestly my cousin studied in KC (K3) now.  Her english is good but if you are expecting presentable and confidence then I don't think my cousin is up to this level.

What do you expect?  The kid is only 5 yrs old.  Unless the kid is using a prescribed script that has been practice I would think any HK kid would find it difficult to do a presentation even using home language.  

I would be disappoint if SC K3 kids can't have a simple English conversation given the number of foreign English teachers at SC.

小曳人

大家多數都响HK大.. 清楚舊時小學老師d英文水準架.. 以常理推測, 幼師嘅背景唔會比小學教師好 (通常較差)
咁大家大咗有無發現老師舊時教錯你呀? (e.g 發音)

個人覺得, 有無NET嘅分別係, 有個人同小朋友講流利而正磪嘅英語

要教生字句式文法, 有心機嘅自己都教得掂 (我相信大家嘅英文唔會比幼師差~) 但係地道嘅口語對答, 生活用語, 就只有NET教到!

所以~ 教得點好都係中國人教英文
問題係, 家長自己有咩計劃.. 佢嘅好處係咪大過呢少少問題呢??

bebelee

I agreed and just want to clarify to another mami that the kid studied in SC will not then to be a "super" kid with high level of confidence.  I didn't mean the kid can do a presentation but you may surprise to hear that doing a presentation / summary of a story in front of a group of kids and teachers is one part of the test required by DGS P1 this year.

原帖由 smartmatt 於 09-11-17 14:32 發表


What do you expect?  The kid is only 5 yrs old.  Unless the kid is using a prescribed script that has been practice I would think any HK kid would find it difficult to do a presentation even using h ...

ahchungma

我不能評價sc ， 因小女是讀kv.但好似其他家長所說， 英文斑或普通話班很多，反之能打好中文及數學基礎並不容易。我相信讀kv並不表示我們不著重英文。

smartmatt

原帖由 bebelee 於 09-11-17 15:14 發表
I agreed and just want to clarify to another mami that the kid studied in SC will not then to be a "super" kid with high level of confidence.  I didn't mean the kid can do a presentation but you may s ...

No surprises, many P1 interviews require story telling in front of teachers and other kids.  Kids at KV do have presentations skills training and story telling at K2 and K3 in front of other kids.

beautiful_mama

Kids @ SC also need to present newspaper in front of the class.....well, every kindergarten have different style of teaching, I don't think one will be better than the others.
Most importantly, is the follow up training at home (personal point of view).

anniema1225

Peronal impression from the application submit (in person at school) and interview experience, KV teachers are quite serious, not that flexible nor friendly in their interactions/responses.  They seem to emphasise a lot on Chinese, quite concerned on the "self-care" ability of "small" BBs.  The disciplinary training from this mode of education could to good but on the other hand, teachers are also like a mirror to kids, they'll pick up the attitude from the teachers.  Frankly speaking, I will not let my child to study at KV after the personal experiences with them......as compared to other KGs like KM, York, Think, SC etc etc....

ChingChingChoy

我個friend女兒讀了三年sc, 現小一, 永不叫人, 每次都係躲在媽媽隔離...噤叫confidence !!!!, 我相信有d嘢係好個人

smartmatt

原帖由 anniema1225 於 09-11-17 23:52 發表
Peronal impression from the application submit (in person at school) and interview experience, KV teachers are quite serious, not that flexible nor friendly in their interactions/responses.  They seem ...

You are correct KV teachers do take teaching kids very seriously.

BBG1

其實邊間kg都有可取或缺點的，這是個人問題呢！人人性格不同，不可劃一標準的。屋企也要教呢！在kg3個鐘識飛天咩！

原帖由 ChingChingChoy 於 09-11-18 00:17 發表
我個friend女兒讀了三年sc, 現小一, 永不叫人, 每次都係躲在媽媽隔離...噤叫confidence !!!!, 我相信有d嘢係好個人

smartmatt

原帖由 BBG1 於 09-11-18 08:17 發表
其實邊間kg都有可取或缺點的，這是個人問題呢！人人性格不同，不可劃一標準的。屋企也要教呢！在kg3個鐘識飛天咩！

Agree, most likely a personal thing and I guess parents teaching also important.   

Saying good morning or talking to adults is not a representation of confidence.   I know a boy whom never says anything to me and come to think of it never hear him say anything to adults, but all top P schools either grant him a place or get 2nd int.

ysnmama

十隻手指也有長短. 一個家庭也會教養出不同的孩子. 有些家長常說面試後感覺不好, 一定不會讓子女讀. 其實收了嗎? 收了再說吧.

每間學校也那麼多學生. 特別SC及KV. 有學生標青, 有學生不標青. 有學生很多小學收, 有學生沒著落, 有學生英文好, 有學生要外求, 有什麼奇怪?

除了學校外. 家庭, 父母, 子女本身也會影響小朋友的各方面.

我認識小朋友讀根德園的. 英文一樣有流利. 因為有工人加家長常用英文溝通. 也有的考小學不太成功. 有認識讀SC. 他們還要再上一連五天的國際幼稚園才能幫助英文方面. 有的一樣老師發現其子女仍不太敢用英文溝通. 有讀約克的考小學全軍覆沒. 也有些考到不錯彧叩門成功. 有讀樂基的一樣很怕醜. 很不合群.....太多不能盡錄.

出外上英文班不代表小朋友英文差. 讀國際學校及讀基督堂一樣出外讀拼音上普通話班. 父母及小朋友操流利英文. 一樣外出上英文班. 因為每間學校總不會盡完美及每位父母要求也不同.

Big-Mouth

我小朋友現讀k1, 他現已識很多中文生字, 以前我也嘗試教他中文字, 但教太很久也不識, 我唔知老師用什麼方法,其實英文可以出去上堂。
已我所認識2個k3學生, 他們到考到心儀小學SFA。