港島東那間中學好?

MonaLeung

Wahyanpooh,

Thanks for your advice.

因小女應是band 1 尾, 所以又唔想太保守.
如2 間band 1 & 2 間band 2 又如何呢? thanks!

	1.  筲箕灣官立
	2. 嘉諾撒書院 3.  民生書院 4. 中華基金中學 (直) 5. 中華傳道會劉永生中學

原帖由 wahyanpooh 於 08-10-10 11:34 發表


港島民生書院、金文泰中學、劉永生中學、衛理中學
上列4間會有部分band 1中至尾同學揀的，所以在band 2只會剩下極少位，應該會在1st全部被揀晒，只可 以揀一間在1st，若全部填晒，等於放棄2,3,4的選擇...

福建好過顯理及嶺 ...

wahyanpooh

原帖由 MonaLeung 於 08-10-13 12:53 發表
因小女應是band 1 尾, 所以又唔想太保守.
如2 間band 1 & 2 間band 2 又如何呢? thanks!
1.  筲箕灣官立
2. 嘉諾撒書院
3.  民生書院
4. 中華基金中學 (直)
5. 中華傳道會劉永 ...

首先你要肯定女兒是否band 1，定係band 1 & 2踩線人，若是band 1，擺位無問題，但2nd嘉諾撒書院較保留，之前已經分析過2間兩女校在東區的化學作用，有興趣看看..
http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=1635949&page=2#pid26141479

若係band 1 & 2踩線人，只可以搏1st是band 1學校，其他要全部揀band 2學校，否則跌到好後。

MonaLeung

明白, 多謝你的指點.

原帖由 wahyanpooh 於 08-10-13 13:16 發表


首先你要肯定女兒是否band 1，定係band 1 & 2踩線人，若是band 1，擺位無問題，但2nd嘉諾撒書院較保留，之前已經分析過2間兩女校在東區的化學作用，有興趣看看..
http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=1635949&pag ...

jjmame

原帖由 wahyanpooh 於 08-10-13 13:16 發表


首先你要肯定女兒是否band 1，定係band 1 & 2踩線人，若是band 1，擺位無問題，但2nd嘉諾撒書院較保留，之前已經分析過2間兩女校在東區的化學作用，有興趣看看..
http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=1635949&pag ...

Hi wahyanpooh:

I live in Island East but my son is studying in a government school in Wanchai.  He ranks around 10-20 in 150 students, so I believe he's in band 1.  Which school do you suggest for him in Wanchai net?  Would it be stupid to change him back to Island East school net?

My son doesn't have much talent.  He's has 3rd violin and learning badminton but doesn't have competition award for both.  His academic result is not outstanding.  Only because his school's academic standard is not high thus he maintains reasonable rank in form.

Thanks a lot for your advice in advance.

rgds, jjmame

wahyanpooh

原帖由 jjmame 於 08-10-13 16:24 發表

Hi wahyanpooh:

I live in Island East but my son is studying in a government school in Wanchai.  He ranks around 10-20 in 150 students, so I believe he's in band 1.  Which school do you suggest for  ...

係灣仔區讀書，無非都係想入皇仁或華仁，轉番去東區，係一個超笨的選擇，無論係自行及統一，都係搏呢兩間。

就算你咁唔好彩派得唔好，以你兒子的成績，叩門中國婦女會都很有機會。

jjmame

原帖由 wahyanpooh 於 08-10-13 17:30 發表


係灣仔區讀書，無非都係想入皇仁或華仁，轉番去東區，係一個超笨的選擇，無論係自行及統一，都係搏呢兩間。

就算你咁唔好彩派得唔好，以你兒子的成績，叩門中國婦女會都很有機會。 ...

Thanks a lot for your advice.  I know it sounds stupid.  I just thought it seems more choices for boys in Island East rather than in Wanchai.

Queen's is for the very very top band 1 boys, my son is not up to that standard.  Wah Yan has primary school, I just don't think it's easy for an outsider to get a seat in its secondary school.

What do you think if I put Queen's and
張祝珊 in first round (自行)?

thx, jjmame

wahyanpooh

原帖由 jjmame 於 08-10-13 21:50 發表

Thanks a lot for your advice.  I know it sounds stupid.  I just thought it seems more choices for boys in Island East rather than in Wanchai.

Queen's is for the very very top band 1 boys, my son is ...

先講自行時揀埋"張祝珊"，除非你覺得皇仁、華仁同張祝珊的份量差不多便可以的，否則要想清楚。

老實講，令郎未達皇仁及華仁"自行"的資格，主要係靠統一，如果張祝珊自行時收了令郎，便沒有機會統一時派入皇仁了。

港華有直屬小學，在統一時學生已有質素保証，所以自行時更願意收他校精英，詳看下列連結....
http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=1635949&page=5#pid26214191

至於擔心兒子在皇仁追不上，呢個有點杞人憂天，入到先算啦，小兒今年入了港華，身邊係多了很多勁人，但是...書咪一樣咁讀，就算張祝珊競爭性都好大架，唔通怕個仔輸，入Band 2 & 3學校，俾佢考到第一都唔馨香啦，唔使太擔心的。

jjmame

原帖由 wahyanpooh 於 08-10-14 11:05 發表


先講自行時揀埋"張祝珊"，除非你覺得皇仁、華仁同張祝珊的份量差不多便可以的，否則要想清楚。

老實講，令郎未達皇仁及華仁"自行"的資格，主要係靠統一，如果張祝珊自行時收了令郎，便沒有機會統一時派入皇仁了。

港華有直屬 ...

In your opinion, 張祝珊 can nowhere compare with Queen's and Wah Yan, right?

I know I can 靠統一 bet 皇仁及華仁.  What do you think if I put 聖公會鄧肇堅 in 2nd or 3rd place?

Heart

JJmame,

既然你兒子在軒官讀,比其他小學又有大allotment/quota 去QC,在自行若不成功,
也可寄望在统一喎.無理由返回東區的.若你
仔細看清楚左鄰右里派位數据,連聖x各也有+30名入QC,若Hen記表現優勝,歷史記錄,QC會分配多些位給Hen記 ---所謂联繫中小學.

wahyanpooh

原帖由 jjmame 於 08-10-14 11:49 發表


In your opinion, 張祝珊 can nowhere compare with Queen's and Wah Yan, right?

I know I can 靠統一 bet 皇仁及華仁.  What do you think if I put 聖公會鄧肇堅 in 2nd or 3rd place?

...

皇仁及華仁係傳統名校，張祝珊只是地區名校，有得揀梗係入皇仁及華仁啦。

自行：1st 皇仁  2nd 華仁
統一：甲部1st 皇仁  2nd 華仁
         乙部1st 皇仁  2nd聖公會鄧肇堅

華仁係統一時好似只係得10個位，夠膽揀的人會較少，而皇仁約有100位，但揀的人則較多，兩者值搏率差不多，不過...皇仁名氣大D，都係揀佢啦。

給你少少定心丸，上年小兒學校(屋邨學校)1個考全級18，都可以叩門入到中國婦女會，以你兒子的成績，叩門能力好強，一般band 1都會收的。

jjmame

原帖由 wahyanpooh 於 08-10-14 12:21 發表


皇仁及華仁係傳統名校，張祝珊只是地區名校，有得揀梗係入皇仁及華仁啦。

自行：1st 皇仁  2nd 華仁
統一：甲部1st 皇仁  2nd 華仁
         乙部1st 皇仁  2nd聖公會鄧肇堅

華仁係統一時好似只係得10個位，夠膽揀的人會較 ...

Dear Wahyanpooh, very detailed explanation.  Thank you so much for your valuable advice.  I'm clear now and will help my son strive for that.

Hi Heart, thank you also.  I understand the connection of my son's school with QC but I'm just afraid that he's not lucky enough to be chosen by QC in 統一.