Top 3 schools in HK

BusyFather

Dined with some friends tonight and all of us agreed that the top three schools in HK are, in aphabetical order, DGS, Queen's and SPCC.
Would you share your opinion?

FUNG12345

BusyFather 寫道:
Dined with some friends tonight and all of us agreed that the top three schools in HK are, in aphabetical order, DGS, Queen's and SPCC.
Would you share your opinion?

喇沙好過spcc同qc
一定要3間, 我會揀ls, db, dg

BusyFather

Well, we also talked about La Salle and DBS.  One of my friend was a La Salle old boy. He was quite unhappy and kept aguing when we said DBS was better than La Salle. I think La Salle in good in sport. But DBS in good not only in sports, but also music and academic performance. Anyhow, my friend also agreed that La Salle and DBS are not that good in academic performance as compared with aforesaid top three schools.
Queen's is excellent in academic performance.
SPCC is excellent in music and academic peformance.
DGS is excellent in music, academic performance and sports.

囝囝爸

純以學業成績來說, 不少地區名校上升中, 反而傳統名校有下降趨勢.

如06年張祝珊會考成績已好過皇仁05年(06年未公佈), 大家中英數差不多, 但理化及其他科目皇仁較遜.  

DBS/LS 今年都喊會考成績下降.  DBS轉直資可能情況有所改善, 但中小學一條龍收生反不及其他地區名英中, 首三成收哂好嘢其他七成都全部是 band 1 . 直資小學不一定全部 band 1, 要好成績除非每年汰弱補回外校好學生.  

joyjoyma

top three school? e d topic 多數end up鬧交wor .
我唔多明點解會有人vote SPCC,計會考成績,音樂,運動,出名的社會領袖...,未至於top 3 嘛.
DGS,DBS 就一定是1,2. 第三C, 另外,LS都好好呀!
見仁見智,唔好鬧我.

15分

不如更改標題為最貴三間香港學校啦

WYmom

SPCC, DGS, DBS, LS, QC, MCS have used to be the traditional top elite schools in HK, just like Ivey League schools in US.  On the other hand, there are also top international schools like HKIS, CIS, GSIS, Li Po Chun, etc. All these schools have their own unique culture and characteristics, students are trained to be much all-rounded, which is something not so quantifiable by academic results.

Now a lot of regional local schools also show excellent academic results, yet don't seem to have very unique personalities.

Afterall, what's the point of selecting top 3?  We can only select one school which is suitable for our kid.

sudoku

太不公平!直資學校 不可同津小/中學校較量。

The topic should be changed into
1) Top 3 直資學校
2) Top 3 津小/中學校

15分

再分區會唔會好些

deniset

Agree.     Besides, one should also consider the university entrance track record released by these schools. The info must be transparent to demonstrate competency of their students.

WYmom 寫道:
SPCC, DGS, DBS, LS, QC, MCS have used to be the traditional top elite schools in HK, just like Ivey League schools in US.  On the other hand, there are also top international schools like HKIS, CIS, GSIS, Li Po Chun, etc. All these schools have their own unique culture and characteristics, students are trained to be much all-rounded, which is something not so quantifiable by academic results.

Now a lot of regional local schools also show excellent academic results, yet don't seem to have very unique personalities.

Afterall, what's the point of selecting top 3?  We can only select one school which is suitable for our kid.

justinnma

15分 寫道:
再分區會唔會好些

再分科會唔會好些

  

dory13b

好似分埋男校、女校、男女校公平D wor

justinnma 寫道:
[quote]
15分 寫道:
再分區會唔會好些

再分科會唔會好些

   [/quote]

circleda

It's interesting to see only academic, music and sport were compared. I do think good school should be judged by the style of their graduates - are they hardworking? are they just top talker? etc.

From my limited impression - QC is down to earth; SPCC is intelligent and humble; DGS is dominant and agressive; DBS is refined; and one of the schools mentioned, well, talk more than work.

Just my 2 cents.

ChiChiPaPa

如果以增值評級來選top 3中學，咁top 3應該係:

1. St. Paul Convent
2. Marymount
3. 福建中學

多年來它們的會考中英數科增值評級和會考最佳6科增值評級都是9級(i.e.最頂級)。

很多名校都唔願公開增值評級。星島日報兩、三年前曾登過男拔的增值評級。03年男拔的會考中英數科增值評級只是5，而會考最佳6科增值評級是7。最高增值科目是生物。00年的會考中英數科增值評級更只是3 (即是並非正增值)。近年男拔就再沒有公開增值評級數字。

『星之子』的那間中華基督教會譚李麗芬紀念中學的增值評級都有8。

dad999

請問邊度可以揾到呢D資料?

ChiChiPaPa 寫道:
如果以增值評級來選top 3中學，咁top 3應該係:

1. St. Paul Convent
2. Marymount
3. 福建中學

多年來它們的會考中英數科增值評級和會考最佳6科增值評級都是9級(i.e.最頂級)。

很多名校都唔願公開增值評級。星島日報兩、三年前曾登過男拔的增值評級。03年男拔的會考中英數科增值評級只是5，而會考最佳6科增值評級是7。最高增值科目是生物。00年的會考中英數科增值評級更只是3 (即是並非正增值)。近年男拔就再沒有公開增值評級數字。

『星之子』的那間中華基督教會譚李麗芬紀念中學的增值評級都有8。

ChiChiPaPa

Dad999，

每年教統通知學校評級數據後，明報和星島都會有新聞報導，會有一部份願意公開數據學校的資料。

星島那本07升中入學家長天書都有05/06年度學校增值表現。不過，只有很少學校願意公開這方面的數字。

cinema

There are only two grades of school :
DGS and others

DGS is superb and others are not comparable.
SPCC or famous others is relative weak now as their selection of pupils are not effective in picking the 'cream' of 'cream'

FUNG12345

BusyFather 寫道:
Well, we also talked about La Salle and DBS.  One of my friend was a La Salle old boy. He was quite unhappy and kept aguing when we said DBS was better than La Salle. I think La Salle in good in sport. But DBS in good not only in sports, but also music and academic performance. Anyhow, my friend also agreed that La Salle and DBS are not that good in academic performance as compared with aforesaid top three schools.
Queen's is excellent in academic performance.
SPCC is excellent in music and academic peformance.
DGS is excellent in music, academic performance and sports.

喇沙成績好過qc嫁, 體育更加係好勁
db就成績同qc差唔多, 但體育音樂都勁
dg就樣樣都勁
spcc就成績好勁

BusyFather

joyjoyma 寫道:
top three school? e d topic 多數end up鬧交wor .
我唔多明點解會有人vote SPCC,計會考成績,音樂,運動,出名的社會領袖...,未至於top 3 嘛.
DGS,DBS 就一定是1,2. 第三C, 另外,LS都好好呀!
見仁見智,唔好鬧我.

Look at some of SPCC's notable alumni as follows.

Academics:

Lawrence J. Lau - Vice-Chancellor of The Chinese University of Hong Kong
Arthur Li - Secretary for Education and Manpower of Hong Kong; former Vice-Chancellor of The Chinese University of Hong Kong
Chung-Kwong Poon - President of the Hong Kong Polytechnic University
Vivienne Poy - Senator of Canada; former Chancellor of the University of Toronto


Public services / professionals:

Audrey Eu - member of the Legislative Council of Hong Kong
Moses Cheng - former member of the Legislative Council of Hong Kong
Selina S Y Chow Liang - member of the Executive Council of Hong Kong and Legislative Council of Hong Kong
Eric Ka-Cheung Li - former member of the Legislative Council of Hong Kong
Andrew Kwok-Nang Li - Chief Justice of the Court of Final Appeal of Hong Kong; Also Vice Chairman of the School Council
Maria Wai-Chu Tam - former member of the Executive Council of Hong Kong and Legislative Council of Hong Kong
Herbert H K Tsoi - former president of the Law Society of Hong Kong


Business:

Richard Li - Founder and chairman of PCCW Limited; younger son of Li Ka-Shing
Victor Li - Managing Director of Cheung Kong (Holdings) Limited; elder son of Li Ka-Shing


Artistes:

Kai-Tai Chan - Hong Kong actor
Danny Pak-Keung Chan - the late popular Hong Kong singer
Michael Ching-Kit Kwan - Hong Kong singer
Mark Chung-Tak Lui - Hong Kong pop song composer and producer
Justin Lo - Hong Kong pop song composer and singer
Man Chung Lam - Hong Kong actor and comedy star
Eugene Pao - Famous Hong Kong Jazz Musician and Guitarist


Others:

Betty Tung - wife of the former Hong Kong Chief Executive Tung Chee Hwa