德望 vs 聖瑪利

fionwong2707

你們對兩間學校有何評價 (不論學費)?

如校風, 老師愛心, 學術水平, 入大學比率及學生表現.....

兩者你們會選那間多一些?

angelymama

我覺得差不多, 都是傳統和嚴的名校。

BoBoCute

ha8mo 寫道:
我一定揀St. Mary's先
女校一定係DGS跟手St. Mary's

My ranking:
DGS, Maryknoll, St. Mary's
I think most think that St. Mary's better than Good Hope!? Right?

dailam

have your daughter accepted by Good Hope? I would like to apply for this school in the coming year, can you share your experience?
Thanks!

FUNG12345

BoBoCute 寫道:
[quote]
ha8mo 寫道:
我一定揀St. Mary's先
女校一定係DGS跟手St. Mary's

My ranking:
DGS, Maryknoll, St. Mary's
I think most think that St. Mary's better than Good Hope!? Right?[/quote]
庇利羅士, 女英華, 聖保祿唔差得過呢三間

st mary's 其實同good hope都係差唔多

BoBoCute

FUNG12345 寫道:

庇利羅士, 女英華, 聖保祿唔差得過呢三間

庇利羅士, 聖保祿, St. Paul's co-ed, SH, St. Stephen's girls are very good schools too, but as they are on HK island, people seldom put them together to rank.

BoBoCute

FUNG12345 寫道:
st mary's 其實同good hope都係差唔多

睇吓你覺得自己個女攞1.22 個A 同0.77 個A 係唔係差唔多囉!!
2004 average no. of A in HKCEE:

St. Mary :1.22A
Good Hope : 0.77A

fannychoi

BoBoCute 寫道:
[quote]
ha8mo 寫道:
我一定揀St. Mary's先
女校一定係DGS跟手St. Mary's

My ranking:
DGS, Maryknoll, St. Mary's
I think most think that St. Mary's better than Good Hope!? Right?[/quote]

good hope 會考唔多勁,
what about if 再加埋BPS, st paul's convent , 聖心, 協恩, 你又點rank?

BoBoCute

MCS : 1.49A
BPS : 1.59A

So, BPS>Maryknoll>St. Mary's>Good Hope according to no. of A in 2005.

Others, no figures to compare.  Other measures of comparisons are quite subjective.

mosburger

both schools are similar. if you really want to compare, good hope participated in more activities whereas St Mary put more emphasis in academics? (just my opinion) Anyway, they are very similar. St Mary may have a slightly better "name".
For schools in kowloon, my choice will be
1: Maryknoll
2. St Mary
3. Heep Yunn
if DGS vs Maryknoll ==> i will choose Maryknoll
if DGS vs St Stephen girls===> St Stephen girls
if DGS vs BPS ===> maybe BPS
if DGS vs St Mary ===> maybe St Mary
if DGS vs Heep Yunn===> DGS
if DGS vs Good Hope===> DGS

FUNG12345

mosburger 寫道:
both schools are similar. if you really want to compare, good hope participated in more activities whereas St Mary put more emphasis in academics? (just my opinion) Anyway, they are very similar. St Mary may have a slightly better "name".
For schools in kowloon, my choice will be
1: Maryknoll
2. St Mary
3. Heep Yunn
if DGS vs Maryknoll ==> i will choose Maryknoll
if DGS vs St Stephen girls===> St Stephen girls
if DGS vs BPS ===> maybe BPS
if DGS vs St Mary ===> maybe St Mary
if DGS vs Heep Yunn===> DGS
if DGS vs Good Hope===> DGS

點解唔揀dgs=.=

FUNG12345

BoBoCute 寫道:
[quote]
FUNG12345 寫道:
st mary's 其實同good hope都係差唔多

睇吓你覺得自己個女攞1.22 個A 同0.77 個A 係唔係差唔多囉!!
2004 average no. of A in HKCEE:

St. Mary :1.22A
Good Hope : 0.77A
[/quote]
唔係淨計成績嫁嗎

FUNG12345

ha8mo 寫道:
不要單計A，而係讀完出來，個人有唔同
任我揀，真係一定入DGS，冇得解

Paul con、BPS同St. Stephen更係far far behind

點會far far behind, 同其他都係一個level

BoBoCute

FUNG12345 寫道:
2004 average no. of A in HKCEE:
St. Mary :1.22A
Good Hope : 0.77A

唔係淨計成績嫁嗎[/quote]

I think St. Mary's is no worse than Good Hope in other aspects too, not to mention the school fees and through train issue.

fionwong2707

你們對聖瑪利2005年起, 與天神結龍後會否影響其佳積有何看法?

BoBoCute

N 年前(at least 20 years)都已經係要分好多位俾天神小學嘅啦!一向都係sister schools. 我諗影響唔大。以前見天神嘅students都好快可以追番,遇强愈强吖嘛！

反而津校採用大抽獎方式,則真係可能會成績轉弱,因為都要講學生讀書天份。我朋友個女入到Maryknoll都放棄,去讀私校。不過亦有家長預咗要勤力先敢揀名津校.
太多因素影響將來,目前只能睇current performance.