IB課程之反思

shadeslayer

原帖由 ANChan59 於 13-10-05 發表
這篇轉貼文章用了很多二分法的對比，我的看法在0 與1之間有不少組合及優次。

*********

我會將這批學生成績減 2 分作比較及分

Cxxxxx

Thanks. 減兩分比較不是 IBO sanctioned 吧？有這取向的大學有幾多？

hkparent

原帖由 ANChan59 於 13-10-05 發表
這篇轉貼文章用了很多二分法的對比，我的看法在0 與1之間有不少組合及優次。

*********

But their students scored well in Chi A, which is very difficult for many of our kids here if they take Chi A. Why reduce by two points then?

I read from earlier newspaper that many of their students go to the 3 universities in HK and some to Imperial College UK. This is impressive. If my son's school can do that I will be very satisfied.

kym

個人感覺大學對 Bilingual Diploma 也不是太重視。

ANChan59

回復 shadeslayer 的帖子

你誤會了！

我不是指IBO 或大學正式扣分，我只是用當年會考英文科有甲乙之分，此A不同彼A的類此比較。
我的處理方法可以將成績作跨校比較。你可以有相反意見！

ANChan59

回復 hkparent 的帖子

你弄錯了，我是指英文而非中文。
遲些各校詳列學生的大學及學科，大家會明白我所指的分別。當然我的要求會高些，比較會細細緞些。

例如43分足可以入到三大神科，如果孿生醫科，法律，GBus欠奉，只是一般科目，why?

ANChan59

kym 發表於 13-10-5 09:03
個人感覺大學對 Bilingual Diploma 也不是太重視。

香港的大學不太重視是事實。

hkparent

原帖由 ANChan59 於 13-10-05 發表
回復 hkparent 的帖子

你弄錯了，我是指英文而非中文。

That's why I prefer IS for my child. Mindset of local students is that only medic, law and global business are good subjects because students can make a lot of money by studying those subjects. I know quite a number of students with IB scores of 43 or above choosing other subjects (eg math, pure science, music) as their first choice, not because they are not qualified for those 3 "good" subjects, but they are truly interested in the other subjects.

ANChan59

hkparent 發表於 13-10-5 10:25
That's why I prefer IS for my child. Mindset of local students is that only medic, law and global bu ...

你的道理較特別，選神科不一定全為高薪厚職，不應事事二分法。
各司其職就好！

你知唔知我講緊邊類學校？如果搭錯線，好難再討論。

poonseelai

ANChan59 發表於 13-10-5 09:23
香港的大學不太重視是事實。

兩星期前在學校聽中大和港大代表介紹non-jupas收生程序時，中大只要求考生要識聽講廣東話，因要到醫院實習，始終total IB score才是入門𨶹鍵

poonseelai

poonseelai 發表於 13-10-5 10:51
兩星期前在學校聽中大和港大代表介紹non-jupas收生程序時，中大只要求考生要識聽講廣東話，因要到醫院實習 ...

我指中大醫科

shadeslayer

原帖由 ANChan59 於 13-10-05 發表
回復 shadeslayer 的帖子

你誤會了！

明白。我還是較關心lBO和大學的看法。

hkparent

原帖由 ANChan59 於 13-10-05 發表
你的道理較特別，選神科不一定全為高薪厚職，不應事事二分法。
各司其職就好！

Are we talking about Logos? It's a kind of school between local school and IS. I don't know if their students are encouraged to pursue subjects of their own interest rather than those 3 "good" subjects only, like what most IS have been encouraging their students to do. It has a different philosophy from other local schools.

caa

大學除了中文系，不是所有學科都以英文為教學語言?如只有英文B的程度是否可應付?醫科丶商業甚至哲學等，都是看英文課本和參考書，正常IS都是default Eng A

hkparent

原帖由 caa 於 13-10-05 發表
大學除了中文系，不是所有學科都以英文為教學語言?如只有英文B的程度是否可應付?醫科丶商業甚至哲學等，都 ...

So Chi A or bilingual diploma is not necessary for most universities except those in US.

kym

美國大學收生要看很多因素，SAT、校內成績、課外活動等。沒有要求一定要是bilingual diploma的。

caa

I think most US people do not speak any language other than English. Only European and HK (due to historical reasons) people speak more than one. IB originates from Europe. But when I look at some UK schools with excellent IB results such as Sevenoaks, I can't find any mentioning of bilingual diploma but it gives detailed breakdowns of scores got by its students on each subject listed by HL or SL.

samsam123321

caa 發表於 13-10-5 12:23
大學除了中文系，不是所有學科都以英文為教學語言?如只有英文B的程度是否可應付?醫科丶商業甚至哲學等，都 ...

Del.

caa

回復 samsam123321 的帖子

Sorry don't quite get it. Which part is not ＂真相＂？
Actually I was just talking about textbooks and reference books. But why would university students skip classes if a Chinese professor speaks English in class?

slamai

回復 caa 的帖子

At the information day of HKUST last week, the briefing session of the Global China Studies mentioned that the admission criteria for DSE applicants were English x 2 + 5 best subjects (i.e. Chinese not necessarily counted except for a minimum 3 to satisfy the JUPAS requirements).  The reason given was that the students would be required to refer to primarily English journals for their academic writings. Given the nature of this programme, we can realise the importance of Chinese as seen from the perspectives of the local Us.