York ,太子明慧, 北角明慧點揀??

ReginaRaina

回覆 poksi 的帖子

交11期

lovely_meloci

個人意見，不喜勿插。
我女有太子明慧及York offer. 但問心，我覺得太子明慧的老師冇愛心，因為interview嗰日 我覺得啲老師太young冇乜經驗, 面試開始跳舞個part個老師跟本唔想跳，我見到她好求其係咁二郁幾下，之後又唔講俾我地知去邊度再in, 又唔同啲小朋友拜拜就走, 入到另外一個班房，個老師好少少但我聽佢口音啲英文都唔得. 校舍沒有室外，再加埋日文堂都幾無謂! 三文四語, 咁細個學, 怕阿女混亂.

lovely_meloci

之後再睇番派小一資料，明慧的好麻麻，有offer 但放

matthewcinpat

if I were you, chose ming wai (north point) , close to TKO. York have 2 hours pn class, i can not see how good this kinder be.

sophieMK

北角明慧都要$4800？$4800係國際?local幾$？全日班local又幾$？

moledy

poksi 發表於 14-12-10 15:37
我也有太子明慧offer,諗緊reg吾reg, 因有間比較近家的LLC offer, 想知明慧學費多少，交幾期？因offer lette ...

我都同你一樣呀, LLC 近屋企, 但PM OFFER, 明慧AM OFFER, 都唔知點間好, LLC就近, 但我覺得語境無太子明慧咁好, 好難間, 又唔想佢去咁近, 近哥間又覺得無遠哥間咁好...你點間?

MiffyShe

回覆 lovely_meloci 的帖子

請問邊到有明慧派位資料？明慧website資料唔多清楚

WingWingBee

原帖由 MiffyShe 於 14-12-11 發表
回覆 lovely_meloci 的帖子

請問邊到有明慧派位資料？明慧website資料唔多清楚

我都想知啊

moledy

我記得去INTERVIEW時佢門口係貼左出來的, 不過行左入去, 無細心望清楚呀..

lovely_meloci

愛秩序灣官立小學
Aldrich Bay Government Primary ...
School Rating : 5.57 Student : 1

聖安當小學
St. Antonius Primary School
School Rating : 5.55 Student : 1

嘉諾撒培德學校
Pui Tak Canossian Primary Scho ...
School Rating : 5.47 Student : 1

保良局馮晴紀念小學
PLK Fung Ching Memorial Primar ...
School Rating : 5.38 Student : 1

筲箕灣官立小學
Shau Kei Wan Government Primar ...
School Rating : 4.98 Student : 1

聖公會日修小學

明慧國際幼稚園（太子分校） -- Placement result
MING WAI INTERNATIONAL KINDERGARTEN (PRINCE EDWARD ...
2013reference


拔萃男書院附屬小學
Diocesan Boys' School Primary ...
School Rating : 9.07 Student : 1

聖保羅男女中學附屬小學
St. Paul's Co-educational Coll ...
School Rating : 9.00 Student : 1

瑪利曼小學
Marymount Primary School
School Rating : 7.94 Student : 1

中華基督教會基灣小學（愛蝶灣）
C.C.C. Kei Wan Primary School ...
School Rating : 7.88 Student : 1

香港嘉諾撒學校
Canossa School (Hong Kong)
School Rating : 7.54 Student : 1

番禺會所華仁小學
Pun U Association Wah Yan Prim ... School Rating : 7.40 Student : 1

滬江小學
Shanghai Alumni Primary School
School Rating : 7.33 Student : 1

太古小學
Taikoo Primary School
School Rating : 7.33 Student : 1

勵志會梁李秀娛紀念小學
The Endeavourers Leung Lee Sau ...
School Rating : 7.19 Student : 1

聖保羅書院小學
St. Paul's College Primary Sch ...
School Rating : 7.17 Student : 1

北角官立小學
North Point Government Primary ...
School Rating : 6.90 Student : 1

佛教中華康山學校
Buddhist Chung Wah Kornhill Pr ...
School Rating : 6.88 Student : 1



高主教書院小學部
Raimondi College Primary Secti ...
School Rating : 6.70 Student : 1

聖公會柴灣聖米迦勒小學
S.K.H. Chai Wan St. Michael's ...
School Rating : 6.70 Student : 1

培僑小學
Pui Kiu Primary School
School Rating : 6.53 Student : 1

伊利沙伯中學舊生會小學分校
Q.E.S. Old Students' Associati ...
School Rating : 6.45 Student : 1

聖保祿天主教小學
St. Paul's Primary Catholic Sc ...
School Rating : 6.45 Student : 1

聖公會聖米迦勒小學
S.K.H. St. Michael's Primary S School Rating : 6.37 Student : 1

保良局陸慶濤小學
Po Leung Kuk Luk Hing Too Prim ...
School Rating : 6.10 Student : 1

港大同學會小學
HKUGA Primary School
School Rating : 6.08 Student : 1

聖嘉勒小學
St. Clare's Primary School
School Rating : 5.97 Student : 1

香港中國婦女會丘佐榮學校
The H.K.C.W.C. Hioe Tjo Yoeng ...
School Rating : 5.72 Student : 1


愛秩序灣官立小學
Aldrich Bay Government Primary ...
School Rating : 5.57 Student : 1

聖安當小學
St. Antonius Primary School
School Rating : 5.55 Student : 1

嘉諾撒培德學校
Pui Tak Canossian Primary Scho ...
School Rating : 5.47 Student : 1

保良局馮晴紀念小學
PLK Fung Ching Memorial Primar ...
School Rating : 5.38 Student : 1

筲箕灣官立小學
Shau Kei Wan Government Primar ...
School Rating : 4.98 Student : 1

lovely_meloci

I found it online....

http://www.bookofschool.com/scho ... Report?categoryid=0


真心，派位不是我想象中好！加上對明慧的老師印象好麻麻。。。。。。都系放offer. 留俾其他覺得好的媽媽。

Conniekiki

原帖由 oocholeoo 於 14-12-10 發表
Tseung Kwan O

我都住將軍澳， 兩間明慧都報佐，如果我係你，我會揀北角pm  ，寧願近屋企啲， bb 可以快啲返屋企午睡。時間好就啲。

hayleymama24

其實升小係自己考，都吾太關學校事

moledy

正常TKO都會選北角岩D, 同埋北角校都好似話好過太子, 始終太子都叫新D

lovely_meloci

hayleymama24 發表於 14-12-12 16:41
其實升小係自己考，都吾太關學校事

I don't think so, if 升小係自己考，都吾太關學校事, then why all of us want our children to goto in St Cat, Vict, HK Preschool, these all famous and high reputation K for a good platform to 直資名小 P.1? 事實是，名幼如 St Cat, Vict, HK Preschool， 大家爭崩頭都想入, 是什麼原因？家長心知。。。。。

oocholeoo

原帖由 lovely_meloci 於 14-12-10 發表
個人意見，不喜勿插。
我女有太子明慧及York offer. 但問心，我覺得太子明慧的老師冇愛心，因為interview嗰 ...

介唔介意講下你會要邊間offer?

lovely_meloci

回覆 oocholeoo 的帖子

明慧會放，明天唔交留位費了。有幾個offer, 交咗3次$970!

kayleyleung23

原帖由 lovely_meloci 於 14-12-12 發表
回覆 oocholeoo 的帖子

明慧會放，明天唔交留位費了。有幾個offer, 交咗3次$970!  ...

交幾個甘誇？

Julybabe

oocholeoo 發表於 14-12-10 09:29
York 10:45 - 12:45太子明慧 am offer
北角明慧 pm offer (已寫信轉am)

hi 樓主，we have got similar questions and situation as yours (except that we didn't apply both MW as aggressive like your good self....)
We are comparing York vs North Point MW now, and can't make up our mind and decision as yet.  We have the following thoughts-

Our priority is - (1) target dragon school so K1 or P1 admission is of our highest priority (2) convenience (3) timing

For (1) - it appears that York meets our expectation more as compared to MW, however, it's only based on our limited information as per the school websites only, we can't tell exactly the statistical figure as it doesn't show clearly on both of the schools website.... So we can't tell which one is exactly doing better... But according to what's on the current websites, it *seems* that York matches our expectation more, as compared to MW....

(2) apparently MW is more convenient to us...

(3) this year York has changed all of its PN class to 2 hr, as parents, we are disappointed. We have got the same offer as yours, i.e. 10.45 session, we don't know how to arrange the lunch time for our little one?!

So we are in a dilemma, and it's due for 970 reg fee submission soon... We hope we could make up our mind soon and is looking for parents comments now....

kayleyleung23

原帖由 lovely_meloci 於 14-12-12 發表
回覆 oocholeoo 的帖子

明慧會放，明天唔交留位費了。有幾個offer, 交咗3次$970!  ...

請問交左邊3間呀？全部am ?