- 在線時間
- 656 小時
- 最後登錄
- 23-3-2
- 國民生產力
- 0
- 附加生產力
- 6754
- 貢獻生產力
- 0
- 註冊時間
- 09-2-4
- 閱讀權限
- 10
- 帖子
- 1796
- 主題
- 52
- 精華
- 0
- 積分
- 8550
- UID
- 472369
 
|
我好懷疑你係未真係睇唔明道理係邊 (?!) , 你嘅文章犯左畿個根本錯誤
事實卻是學生自小一開始便要為TSA而操練，中英文教科書也是遷就TSA的考評內容而編寫。既然考評局亦指出TSA只代表課程的部份要求，那麼如果學校偏重TSA的操練，也就是說我們孩子的學習空間就被大大扼殺了。
>> 已經用非常淺嘅中文解釋比你知, 係供求之下, 就算無左 TSA, 部份学校都會用相同時間操練其他有助提升評刻嘅嘢上面. 明未?
就正如学卷幼稚園, 家長會覺得佢淺(因為教局指示下), 變左好多有能力就脫離学卷制, 咁就可以深 d, 吸引家長! 学卷家長亦會主動加操. 因乜? 升小! 明未?
I try to answer u with simple English. Don't mix many different topic up re P1 admission, that's should be another topic.
TSA is so called a low risk assessment to test the BASIC ability. However, EDB has increase the difficulty of the test throughout the years, which had already been raised out by so many teachers, is one of the reason contributing to the drilling. But the TSA result, which suppose not to tell the parents, would be used as a benchmark to compare across the schools where the Board of School will then exert pressure to the Headmaster. That is the real cause for the school to drilling the test.
那小三呢？小三，8歲而已，為甚麼這麼小就要經歷這些無謂的壓力？孩子還在天真爛漫地探索著世界的事物。初小，不是鼓勵和實行廣泛閱讀，奠定創意思維的最好時機嗎？就是一個TSA，就把整個學習領域壓縮得只像個皮球那麼小。小孩子面對一次又一次的操練，恐怕換來的只有對學習的抗拒與恐懼。我同意適量的壓力是學習的推動力，但過量就物極必反。"
>> 問下家長學校唔操 (TSA or AST or no matter what name it is) 升中會跌, 或者問下学校唔操 (TSA orAST or no matter what name it is)升中改善唔到會收生競爭力低左.... 佢地肯唔肯?
百分之九十即肯唔制啦! 梗係操!
之前鏗鏘集訪問某地區一線小學校長, 佢想推減小功課政策, 操小d...但升中成績就跌左小小, 家教會即刻好大意見! 要多返功課!
明未? 現實世界就係咁 I told in other post before. It is a matter of choice. If you want to study in GH and cope with those drilling culture, no one will stop you. But now, how can a P1 parent know if the school is really drilling or not drilling the TSA as you said, by changing the name of the supplementary exercise. Also, I support to remove the TSA as the KPI which is the same rationale behind some schools that remove the class ranking for exam in order to tackle with those monster parents in some extent.
Do you think there's no impact on all the P1-3 students, no matter you can or cannot cope with the exam with our without drilling?? I have quoted an example before, do you think the teachers will spend same amount of time to make sure all kids know the format of writing the invitation cards in Chinese if the TSA won't test this. Or do you think your kids require to write up thousands of invitation cards when they grow up?
>> School is drive by parent demand, if majority parent demand is good result, school will direct teacher to execute... if there is TSA as tools, they use TSA... if there is no TSA, but is another tools call AST, TTSA, ASTTT... they will study it and ask teacher to execute
this is market, supply and demand
we should change the society , not the tools... tools A dead, tools B come, understand?
|
|
發表於 15-11-5 11:45
erfect sytem" in the world ! 
