約克幼稚園涉無牌煮食 教統局調查

Busy

作為YORK的家長, 見到類似的負面新聞, 當然唔開心, 目前來說, 最緊要係YORK快些申領煮食牌照, 好讓家長們安心, 平心而論, 係王國3年多, 見慣好多負面的POST, 言詞好多好激烈, 甚至演變成罵戰...我都覺無奈, YORK就好像係自己的親人咁, 到處俾人鬧, 如果你係家長, 你有何感想??

唔係捍衛!! 只係我都想講出我作為家長的感受, 我囡在此校讀了2年, 我要求不高, 覺得佢整體上有進步已感滿意, 學校商業味重與否, 我不會理會...學校沒有煮食牌照...我都很擔心, 都希望佢地盡快申領, 至於其他媽咪說此校好衰, 又差..又....我聽了就算, 當然內心不舒服, 但希望不喜歡此校的媽咪, 也要尊重YORK家長的感受, 因為作為家長的我們, 都希望子女讀間最好的學校..如果讀不到最好的, 都不想讀間你地認為最衰的一間, 你有你地的感受, 我尊重, 但你亦都應尊重下我地, 再一次說, 如不喜這校的, 就應快快轉校, 甚至唔好投考, 唔好給自己太多藉口, 以免影響你子女的身心!  

Alanhoky

霖媽 寫道:
有事請教？

我阿女現正YORK讀預備班，可能於新學年入讀ST.CAT，但因阿女現在讀得很開心，我有考慮留她在YORK，BUT見以上討論，又想多了解，到底YORK有甚麼劣處和優點，可否從教育、多元智能及德育的角度上多分享一下...。

其實，我要求都很高，去年5月至今，我已替阿女轉了2間學校，YORK已經是第三間，但暫時看學校很不錯，因此很想知道其他家長的意見，讓我多一些資料去選擇。

Sorry for the late reply.

My daughter, Rosaline, also started her schooling with York since pre-nursery and continues her K1 there.

I always believe that your kid can tell you which school is a good one, or at least, which school can suit him/her.  Just like your case, your daughter is telling you that York can suit her.  

Of course, there is still good chance that she will tell you that SC can suit her also!!

So, you are now having a difficult task.  York is difinitely suitable to your daughter while SC is an option most welcomed by the public!!

I don't want to discuss with you in details about the school-York.   I don't want to impact your decision/the future of your kid.  

However, I want to share some interesting behaviour of my daughter-Rosaline.

Although I trust that Rosaline is not performing outstandingly, she behaves:-

1. loving going to school daily
2. wanting to take school bag/drawing case by herself
3. taking the initiative to do her homework daily by herself
4. she is going to have an assessment shortly, she told me to assist her in making her revision yesterday - I couldn't believe a K1 kid could do that!
5. loving to share her good feeling with others; the case was that she wanted to let the others share her happiness of her good result of her drawing class!  She told me that her teacher taught her to share 'good feelings' with others!  (I have to point out that her result actullay was not so brilliant!!)
6.  she always requires me to stop when 'red' traffic light is on

Point 4 & 5 most impressed me.

alowe

我係路過既，見到大家舊事重提，亦都想講一些私人意見。

york係九龍塘區歷來被投訴比較多既學校，例如超收，善改用途，開辦未獲批課程等等。近年因為教統局執法較嚴，投訴的確是減少了。但點解學校時常被投訴呢？大家要諗下原因。

最近學校比教統局查到無牌煮食，d件係違法行為，係刑事罪行。d樣野對學生安全有很大影響，引致火燭或食物中毒就大件事，因係非法，保險有無得賠都成問題。學校如不能守法，又如何教小朋友守法呢？如果我係家長，又愛護學校和自己小朋友，就一定要學校作出合理解釋。

kimimi

有冇york的家長知道學校有否作出回應和行動 ?
我都想比我個女讀york, 因為在intreview 時對york的感覺好好,  希望我無撰錯啦 !!

cclbaby

我想York 出現太多誤會了﹗York 是沒有超收，之前超收的是指迦南。如果話 York 有很多投訴，咁請提出真實証據，不要人云亦云。

另如小朋友不是在 York 讀書，請不要再中傷此校。可能此校的英文程度好，所以遭人妒忌﹗

另學校是沒有煮食的，一般是茶點為麵包、生果、果汁、餅乾.....等的乾量。

Alanhoky

kimimi 寫道:
有冇york的家長知道學校有否作出回應和行動 ?
我都想比我個女讀york, 因為在intreview 時對york的感覺好好,  希望我無撰錯啦 !!

Believe your 'feelings'.

My daughter has been there since January 05.  So far the school is quite good.

kimimi

Alanhoky.
I haven't talk with you a long time lu, how's your daughter ? Remember she join Tom Lee music play group, is she enjoy ??
May I know any open day or parent day from York before starting K1 ?
When I can get the school bus information ?
thank you.