讀國際學校點樣知道自己小朋友算唔算成績好？

ckmammy

想請教啲有高中小朋友嘅家長，其實讀國際學校又冇考試，又唔駛考呈分，喺學校又冇名次， 點樣知自己小朋友嘅程度同其他同級學生嘅程度比較？ 喺學校就算係最叻嗰批，出到外面可能有未必係。

Star.Star

我諗老師report大部份tick晒最好果格就算成績好好，同其他學校比都唔會差。唔似香港Band 3考第一都差過Band 1考近尾。

poonseelai

ckmammy 發表於 21-11-15 23:36
想請教啲有高中小朋友嘅家長，其實讀國際學校又冇考試，又唔駛考呈分，喺學校又冇名次， 點樣知自己小朋友 ...

你講高中？中學有測驗考試㗎

ckmammy

poonseelai 發表於 21-11-16 08:32
你講高中？中學有測驗考試㗎

或者先唔講高中，咁初中同高小？

nervousmichelle

我女小六時已經有唔少考試，同學之間亦會知道邊個成績好，邊個唔好。report會分等級，如果全A*，成績已經好好。如果一直到高中，都係A*，我覺得IB成績40分以上肯定冇問題。冇必要和LS學生成績比，大家考評標準不一樣。

MM2H

冇考慮過排名或同其他同學比較，集中睇係佢有冇盡自身能力去做到最好，呢方面從assessment、ATLs、criterion placements 再加老師面談，都有足夠資訊可以去理解

Tanyafish

You can ask the home room teachers of your child round about where he is in terms of each of the key subjects in his class. They should be able to tell you if he is in upper quartile, middle or needs improvement. If you talk about inter-school comparison, you can  refer to the past records of that school in general against other IS and you can gauge the level of academic vigor at your child’s school.Eg if your child’s school keeps producing steady average IB results in the region of late thirties, if your child is remarked as above average by teachers, should generally expect to score around late thirties too in the normal course of things if the child keeps up with his performance.

poonseelai

ckmammy 發表於 21-11-16 09:11
或者先唔講高中，咁初中同高小？

我兩個孩子小學至中學畢業都無同同學仔比較過，主要透過同老師溝通去了解情況，如有地方要留意老師也會出聲。中學有測驗考試，ib school 每科有4個評分 criteria, 會知道那方面要留意下，每年亦有 teacher parents days 去同每科老師面談，到最後就係睇下成績能否符合心儀大學同學科要求。唔記得係三年定四年級起，會考 International School Assessment 的英文和數學卷，孩子在無操練情況下可反映其水平，報告會列出孩子成績在全球考生中位置，可作為參考。

Youweird

In Hkis high school, there are assessments and projects every term which measure your academic performance. And in their primary school, there are Map test twice per academic year

Radiomama

ESF 系的小學，無考試，但有report 及3 ways conference, 透過孩子的功課質素和老師評語，可以了解孩子的能力。
當年完成IBPYP前，會有final year project, 其實家長也有機會觀摩其他同學的project 及presentation, 我自己都覺得大開眼界。
中學之後，測驗功課評核均增加，孩子也會自我反省，開始對自己有要求。

ckmammy

Youweird 發表於 21-11-16 16:16
In Hkis high school, there are assessments and projects every term which measure your academic perfo ...

我想問下如果 MAP 成績好，是否可以反映小朋友學術成績係高？ 因為考咗咁多年都唔係好知呢個 test 程度有幾高或低。

木子兔媽媽

ckmammy 發表於 21-11-17 09:09
我想問下如果 MAP 成績好，是否可以反映小朋友學術成績係高？ 因為考咗咁多年都唔係好知呢個 test 程度有幾 ...

School average of MAP in HK is higher than US average. Use your school’s average as a reference, and it would be a reasonable reflection of the kids.

lollylolly

Radiomama 發表於 21-11-16 19:41
ESF 系的小學，無考試，但有report 及3 ways conference, 透過孩子的功課質素和老師評語，可以了解孩子的能 ...

請問ESF 會冇上面提及嘅MAP 嗎？

謝謝分享，對於我呢啲IS 新手好有用

mandy_ng207

poonseelai 發表於 21-11-16 13:09
本帖最後由 poonseelai 於 21-11-16 15:16 編輯

我兩個孩子小學至中學畢業都無同同學仔比較過，主要透 ...

我仔學校有做InCAS assessment, 係同英國同齡小朋友嘅程度比較，得分係以嗰科嘅「年齡程度」去表達（例如英文屬8歲程度）。不過我想知InCAS有幾可靠，因為好似人人都考得好高分，我仔本身英文internal assessment 有一項未達標，但佢InCAS又高過自己年齡。
有冇人可以解答下？

Youweird

ckmammy 發表於 21-11-17 09:09
我想問下如果 MAP 成績好，是否可以反映小朋友學術成績係高？ 因為考咗咁多年都唔係好知呢個 test 程度有幾 ...

最后有一个百分比，听说95%以上算很好吧。
K12全在一个考题pool里

木子兔媽媽

Youweird 發表於 21-11-17 13:33
最后有一个百分比，听说95%以上算很好吧。
K12全在一个考题pool里

MAF is for US schools.
Don’t mind the percentile of any single test of your kids too much. The trend of the percentile is better for your reference.

hitommycc

lollylolly 發表於 21-11-17 10:16
請問ESF 會冇上面提及嘅MAP 嗎？

謝謝分享，對於我呢啲IS 新手好有用

ESF primary高小做ISA（同樓上poonseelai提及），secondary做NGRT/PTM/Mid YIS，可幫助大致了解孩子在全球考生中所處位置。

21-11-17 14:25 上傳

下載附件 (249.11 KB)

lollylolly

hitommycc 發表於 21-11-17 14:25
ESF primary高小做ISA（同樓上poonseelai提及），secondary做NGRT/PTM/Mid YIS，可幫助大致了解孩子在全球 ...

謝謝分享

poonseelai

hitommycc 發表於 21-11-17 14:25
ESF primary高小做ISA（同樓上poonseelai提及），secondary做NGRT/PTM/Mid YIS，可幫助大致了解孩子在全球 ...

My kids only took the ISA ones up to year 10, I think.The following is a sample individual report for ISA science (can't find a sample for English).I find the report quite useful and keep track of their results over the years.


https://www.acer.org/files/ISA_sample_science_indiv_pdf.pdf

木子兔媽媽

MAP test search in internet today:

https://www.testprep-online.com/map-scores

https://campussuite-storage.s3.amazonaws.com/prod/750226/93147715-c5f6-11e6-b7b7-22000bd8490f/1848025/4e4fb610-dc5c-11e8-adb6-0af9aad03eea/file/Acceleration.pdf

99th seems to be an entry to consider giftedness and 95th is good enough to advance more