中學是否應提供統一的主要升學數據，方便大家比較選校

ANChan59

hkpapa852 發表於 17-10-24 11:19
到底學校招收體藝學生, 係為咗教學佢地, 定係會鳥盡弓藏呢? 相信不同學校亦有不同處理手法

現實係, 唔係 ...

Don't be so negative.

Eventually, I received many enquiries from EK web pals (PM)  related to sportsman entry of secondary schools, my typical questions are:

1. How's their standing in academic in primary 6?
2. How's their talent in sports or other talents?
3. Any other options or other schools?
4. Local university is their destination?
5. What's their inspiration in sports and other activities?
....

Different families have different reasons to pick the better fit schools, no right or wrong answer.

akys

運動係要付出，通常比讀書嘅付出還要多。有學校比多條出路呢啲學生係值得欣賞嘅，唔認為每個人都要行同一條路。喺呢類名校一邊讀書，一邊受訓可以說是雙贏，學生就算真的不是讀書材料，將來出路總比B3多，就算以特別生入學嘅機會或支援亦比一般B3學校多。

運動員並不如某人所講對社會沒有貢獻，畢業後可從事教練，老師，運動相關行業或全職運動員。一個成功運動員會為社會帶來凝聚力，呢啲唔係上幾堂愛國愛港堂，講兩講就可以得到。

無論如何，出路並不只有一條，有學校肯付出資源，唔理部份家長批評，接受整體低啲嘅學業成績，係可喜的。

kennyklt

akys 發表於 17-10-24 13:00
運動係要付出，通常比讀書嘅付出還要多。有學校比多條出路呢啲學生係值得欣賞嘅，唔認為每個人都要行同一條 ...

講得非常好

ANChan59

akys 發表於 17-10-24 13:00
運動係要付出，通常比讀書嘅付出還要多。有學校比多條出路呢啲學生係值得欣賞嘅，唔認為每個人都要行同一條 ...

Well said.

I am highly regard those schools to help sportsman to achieve dual targets at different stages. HK education system needs more alternative routes, not just NSS, HKDSE .....

Like Sarah will go back to school, we shouldn't comment her secondary school and HKCEC exam results. She achieved a lot for herself and HK.

Even some sportsmen's achievements not as high as Sarah or Rex, still represented HK in different international competitions.

YmOra

akys 發表於 17-10-24 13:00
運動係要付出，通常比讀書嘅付出還要多。有學校比多條出路呢啲學生係值得欣賞嘅，唔認為每個人都要行同一條 ...

認同呢!運動員付出的努力不比愛讀書的人少,熱愛運動的學生要追十分好嘅成績一定比人辛苦,無論學生身處於名中學或是Band3中學,相信學生都會為個人的運動生涯而努力攞好成績,畢竟運動員生涯十分短,所以,既然目標只有一個,倒不如去一所資源充足和經驗豐富嘅名中學裡受訓,至於學術成績問題,可能學生去到邊所學校都是面對著相同的學習問題,不如就交俾一所較有經驗嘅名中去處理學生的學業成績問題會是更好,往往這類運動員學生對自己的學術要求不會定得太高,但願可以穩陣入到U就是了,不可以拿他們與其他尖子相比其成績呢!

hkpapa852

ANChan59 發表於 17-10-24 12:29
Don't be so negative.

Eventually, I received many enquiries from EK web pals (PM)  related to sport ...

One major conflicts: parent's expectation and kid's expectation

I believe this is one major issue

ANChan59

hkpapa852 發表於 17-10-24 13:59
One major conflicts: parent's expectation and kid's expectation

I believe this is one major issue

Understand, I always suggest parents to consider kid's expectation.  In secondary school, all parents need to adjust their expectations on their kids.

Typical example, a top B1 kid among all B1 kids, still top 3 in class is quite a challenge ......

hkpapa852

ANChan59 發表於 17-10-24 14:10
Understand, I always suggest parents to consider kid's expectation.  In secondary school, all parent ...

In primary school, many parent trained up their kid's sport/music skill to acquire the medals in order to increase to chance to elite school

After the kids successfully enter their parent's dream school, many parents turn their face and become less support or even refuse to let the kid to continue the development in sport/music skill......

This is most "interested" scenario  I seen in the past and nowadays......

chunyatmama

YmOra 發表於 17-10-24 13:41
認同呢!運動員付出的努力不比愛讀書的人少,熱愛運動的學生要追十分好嘅成績一定比人辛苦,無論學生身處於名 ...

Well said.  I share with your view and you inspired me to review again my perception to some schools.  Thanks.

chunyatmama

akys 發表於 17-10-24 13:00
運動係要付出，通常比讀書嘅付出還要多。有學校比多條出路呢啲學生係值得欣賞嘅，唔認為每個人都要行同一條 ...

Very good point!  I share your view.

ANChan59

hkpapa852 發表於 17-10-24 14:36
In primary school, many parent trained up their kid's sport/music skill to acquire the medals in or ...

I see what you mean.

That's not purely expectation ....... violated false trade description .....  

mcl203

hkpapa852 發表於 17-10-24 14:36
In primary school, many parent trained up their kid's sport/music skill to acquire the medals in or ...

要有資格成為特異人仕係好難...用神功入學係更難
一旦成為職業學生...要抽離亦唔係易事
部份可以抽離返學業為主...唔再用神功辦事...其實可能根本未算特異人仕...亦唔係靠神功入學 ~~~

Arabellahk

akys 發表於 17-10-24 13:00
運動係要付出，通常比讀書嘅付出還要多。有學校比多條出路呢啲學生係值得欣賞嘅，唔認為每個人都要行同一條 ...

有些名校錄取運動出色的學生是有條件的，必須維持高水平的運動成績，這些學生壓力不小。