滙基東九龍 vs 聖保羅書院

Jackieson

Hazen爸爸 發表於 13-2-10 17:01
滙基已in等消息, 聖保羅23/2 in , 不考慮交通和學費, 請問那間較好? 謝謝!

首先個人覺得只有較適合學生的學校. 所以好難講那間較好, 視乎你認為'好'的定義是什麼.
呢兩間學校好難比較, 唔係'apple to apple', 以前亦曾有相同的帖子討論過:  http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2281587&extra=&highlight=%E5%8C%AF%E5%9F%BA%E6%9B%B8%E9%99%A2&page=1

呢兩間學校(滙基東九龍 vs 聖保羅書院)都係好學校, 最大分別係: 新貴vs百年老校; 男女校vs男校; 有宿舍(中一要住約三個月)vs無宿舍; 在學校食lunch vs 自由出街食;
相同既係: 宗教-基督教(但滙基比較濃, 校長話所有老師都係基督徒); 畢業生同樣對母校好有歸屬感; 兩間學校的老師同樣關懷及關愛學生, 唔會放棄學生.

我相信如果子女在滙基長大的話, 家長會很放心, 因為滙基校風純樸, 加上濃厚基督教辦學的全面教育, 子女學壞的機會好細. 滙基今年中一英文試改用新加坡課本, 會深d.

如果'好'的定義係成績的話, 唔講以前, 單以去年dse成績入u計, 兩間差不多, 的確有很多成績更亮麗的學校. 但我相信聖保羅成績會比滙基高, 況且成績有高低起跌, 亦不應單憑成績去介定'好'學校 . 如果論國際視野及為小朋友安排出國留學的話, 相信聖保羅書院會比較適合.

你也可在以下再認識多d呢兩間學校:
滙基東九龍
http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2356208&extra=page%3D1&page=21
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8EscvoDtvJI

聖保羅書院
http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2356208&extra=page%3D1&page=24

如果小朋友的成績是b1, 滙基好大機會有offer, 而聖保羅書院就未必(去年好多b1學生都無offer,在waiting list, 到最後都無).如果兩間都有offer的話, 最好問吓阿仔鍾意讀邊間, 留比用家決定好d.

CPU1995

Out of the F.1 students admitted by SPC last year, just one famous primary school from Kowloon side occupied 18 seats in SPC:

http://www.ktsps.edu.hk/3/02_4.html

mesmerising

The above link can just show ktsps is a good school.  It can't tell to where the other seats of SPC were/were not distributed.

Anyway, banding should be just one criteria out of many to measure a school.

熙媽媽

Jackieson 發表於 13-2-15 03:08
如果小朋友的成績是b1, 滙基好大機會有offer, 聖保羅書院就未必(去年好多b1學生都無offer,在waiting list, 到最後都無offer).如果兩間都有offer的話, 最好問吓阿仔鍾意讀邊間, 留比用家決定好d.  ...

個人幾鐘意SPB，不過朋友讀東九嘅仔女好鐘意自己學校，對學校好有歸屬感。
朋友女女已經唔係中一，主動報住宿舍(要知道宿舍係唔准用手機)，話想讀書。初中生主動咁做好難得。

既然2間都唔錯，有時候比小朋友自己揀都好。

fckmama

中學部成績下滑, 請問學校有冇檢討過原因, 和有冇實質措施去改善呢 ?

fckmama

以前睇的資料話小四才用普通話教, 是否現在改咗 ?

elbar

原帖由 熙媽媽 於 13-02-15 發表
個人幾鐘意SPB，不過朋友讀東九嘅仔女好鐘意自己學校，對學校好有歸屬感。
朋友女女已經唔係中一，主動報住 ...

近年受歡迎程度 新貴 應更勝 老校

readers

我個仔和女在中西區讀小學，女兒今年小六, band one全A成績，我放棄了百年老校英華女校，已報讀東九滙基，因女兒喜歡男女校，而我們喜歡東九滙基的真正基督教教育。滙基是所正增值學校，創校只有十年而有此成績真是校長老師的努力成果。你可以問問孩子的意願，而家長要過的是自己的虛榮心，我的朋友或其他家長總愛問：為甚麼不揀超級名校，但選校只要對孩子（和天父）交待，其它人的看法並不重要，只要你了解完學校覺得它真正適合孩子就可以。就如滙基教得比較活是我覺得會適合女兒的，在滙基女兒應有多些空間去找自己的興趣和志向，百年老校總有太多包袱和框架，否則怎能操出公開成績來!只要學校教得學生積極上進，那怕成績不好。

Hazen爸爸

回復 Jackieson 的帖子

謝謝各位家長寶貴意見

motherotk

回復 Hazen爸爸 的帖子

滙基 is Band 1 or Band 2?

I knew from my friends' children, band 2 results in primary school was admitted to 滙基 last year. Good school though..and kid enjoyed school life.

CPU1995

readers 發表於 13-2-15 23:37
我個仔和女在中西區讀小學，女兒今年小六, band one全A成績，我放棄了百年老校英華女校，已報讀東九滙基， ...百年老校總有太多包袱和框架

I agree that traditional school does have many heritage and traditioanl values which cannot be dispensed with.  It might be due to the vanity and fame which attract many parents making pilgrimage to such schools.

However, many a times a traditional school can produce a brilliant student.  About two years ago, I know that a Ying Wa girl was admitted by Cambridge Medicine though she eventualy studies in Hong Kong medicine programme.

I think it is quite a concidence that a traditional school can produce such a brilliant student who is admitted by one of the most famous U in the world.  This might be a younger DSS which cannot compare with.

Of course, I concur that United Christian is also a good school too.

readers

Engage your son in making decisions. Tell him the strength of each school. If you think both schools are acceptable, you can tell your son that your are happy whichever he picks. Parent's support is important.

HuiTung

hogwarts 發表於 13-2-14 17:53
英雄當不應論當年勇，其實班仔都好努力，明天會更好吧!

hogwarts,
How many TRUE all-rounded schools in HK?  I am sure SPC is one of them!

hogwarts

Hui Tung,

Well, not seeing you for sometime, how are u & your boy?

Just to a gathering last Saturday, quite a few university lecturers were around.   When SPC was mentioned, they all praised the liberal tradition of the school.

Despite saying about the many plus sides of the school. It is still up to the boy's own hardworking to determine the outcome.   By the way, I know some of her old boys do have different & challenging lives, which might not be considered as wise.   

Do u know that SPC might be the only HK school produced political prisoners in all two shores three lands?  I don't know whether the school should be proud or what.  At least the two going to the Mainland and HK prisons do go back to school from time to time to deliver speeches or encouraging sharings.

However, United Christian is also matching with SPC of this unorthodox tradition to produce political dissident, even in much younger ages.   I do admire this young voice from UCC and I am please many of his comrades do come from SPC.

It seems the two schools are matching one another in all areas, hard to make decision la.

Hazen爸爸

明早要去nterview, 很緊張, 但又唔感話比阿囝知, 希望明早他有好的表現啦?
阿囝.... daddy 支持你

elbar

原帖由 Hazen爸爸 於 13-02-22 發表
明早要去nterview, 很緊張, 但又唔感話比阿囝知, 希望明早他有好的表現啦?
阿囝.... daddy 支持你 ...

Add oil

hogwarts

Yes, just relax, be your own-self and enjoy the process.

CPU1995

Personally I like SPC more than other traditional boys' school.

Just relax and the interview is not difficult at all comparing with other schools.

ohnono

Hazen爸爸 發表於 13-2-22 20:20
明早要去nterview, 很緊張, 但又唔感話比阿囝知, 希望明早他有好的表現啦?
阿囝.... daddy 支持你 ...

「盡在不言中」，祝好運！