有冇媽媽考慮St Cat vs Victoria??

angie_mama

如題。有冇前人2間都in過，敎學方法、老師及環境，邊間優勝？請指教。謝謝

Vlone778

咁不如考慮兩間都報，兩間都收再算

ddung_baby

我都想知，推

seelokyu

兩間都吾易interview, 收左先算。

seelokyu

兩間都吾易interview, 收左先算。

sindychan35

2間都係歷史悠久(St. Cat創校42年/ Victoria創校 47年)、出名質素高的名校。
敎學方法、老師及語言環境都好好，無咩話邊間比較優勝。好視乎家長想子女行什麼路? 傳統? 國際? 留港? 出國?
觀乎身邊親戚朋友而言, St. Cat比較多來自不同階層/背景的學生。而Victoria小朋友的家庭背景會比較接近。可能因為Victoria的學生比起St. Cat的，較多會走國際學校條路或出國讀書。
我覺得兩者最大分別係，St. Cat 無論PN定K1都不會收細仔，而Victoria則有細仔班，專門俾8-10月出世的細仔(大、細仔不同班)。不過兩間都好難考入，尤其係宜家出生率高。係學校揀學生,不是學生揀學校。所以我都建議樓主, 兩間都入form, 見了收了再考慮。

angie_mama

其實我2間都會apply,但早年有媽媽話interview 撞期。。。想多聽意見啫

angie_mama

原帖由 sindychan35 於 12-09-11 發表
2間都係歷史悠久(St. Cat創校42年/ Victoria創校 47年)、出名質素高的名校。
敎學方法、老師及語言環境都好 ...

謝謝分析 :)

sindychan35

Victoria的interview一般在3月, 很少同其他kindergartens撞期. 不用擔心.

picture

victoria holds open days for each campus regularly.

You can check their open days on their website and go see for yourself.

I have been to Belcher's and Harbour Heights and was personally quite impressed by the K3 kids who were all very confident and eloquent in 3 spoken languages.

However, I took a lot at their work stuck up on the wall which was quite prone with spelling and grammatical errors.

Unfortunately St Catherine's is comparatively secretive with how they teach their kids and even when I asked to learn more about their program they gave me a very unsatifying answer that they do have seminars and talks on their teaching methods and program BUT EXCLUSIVELY FOR EXISTING STUDENTS' PARENTS.

It takes a lot of faith in the school to put your child in St. Cat.  But afterall, it is very famous and their students seem to do well.

angie_mama

Thanks

mamaokasan

just wonder, on victoria website, I recall they mention there may have some vacancies in K2 or K3 and welcome the parents to inquire. So does that mean it is not that difficult to get it? I guess both are good schools but in term of hardware, Victoria Kowloon does not have outdoor playgroud. (guess it is good for the children to be in touch with sunshine.

giyim

維記應該唔會同SC撞期, 唔同月份, 舊年只係同KM撞期~

Barbayauyau

原帖由 sindychan35 於 12-09-11 發表
2間都係歷史悠久(St. Cat創校42年/ Victoria創校 47年)、出名質素高的名校。
敎學方法、老師及語言環境都好 ...

好多維記學生都派返維記小學, 咁維記小學好唔好? 如果想讀傳統小學, 係咪唔好選維記呢?

lalawowo

很多victoria畢業生去到好好的local primary school, 你只要上網睇下升小派位就一清二楚。victoria的透明度很高的，不用估估下。

hayley1328

Victory同St.Cat呢兩間今年唔會撞呀，in咗先啦，日期出咗，維記3月1至2號，SC就3月7至9號，學之園都係3月唔知邊日，如果劍明都係3月肯定有撞的

angie_mama

Thanks. 相差一星期，好吖冇撞期
打電話去維多利亞，原來每間只有40-50個位，St Cat就16-17班。。。

elytis

回復 ddung_baby 的帖子

agree so much

lingling06

三年前，我替大兒子選擇了SC的K1，放棄了維記，但我沒有後悔。
去年，我也替小兒子選擇了SC的PN，放棄了維記，但曾有一些後悔。

其實兩間學校都是好的學校，視乎小朋友的特質和家長的期望。我大兒子性格文靜、被動，喜歡學習，他較適合坐下來聽老師講解，同學間的互動學習他是比較差；我曾比較朋友同級維記的中文，SC雖說是比KV較淺，但仍比維記教得深。
但細仔較活躍和BB,他需要較多照顧，可能SC的PN較新,老師未必會習慣照顧那麼年幼的小朋友，個人感覺細仔在維記返playgroup時，開心過返SC PN,但幸好返回九龍塘K1後，可能老師很有經驗，課程設計又適合小朋友，他現在開心得多。

hayley1328

回復 lingling06 的帖子

上星期無意中見到SC海濱南岸請緊幼兒園老師, 如果幼師唔係穏定同有經驗都係個問題