真係唔明喇沙點解咁勁？

Lilo

有親戚個女靠人仕入到女拔，最後追唔上比學校勸退，初初父母堅持唔走，因為佢地問過教育局學校唔可以踢佢出校，但小朋友成日因成績比人話，如是者拉拉扯扯兩三年，返學唔開心，搞到個人無晒自信。最後父母敵不過現實同佢轉校，所以話叩到又點，勉強無幸福

wanlucky

最重要係間學校是否適合個小朋友，錯配咗有排受！

oscarmama

十二年的努力，可能殊途同歸。上到大學才是一較高下。在大學時遇到不少頂尖高手是普通中學畢業，但表現卻比名校讀死書學生(即高分低能)超幾班。LS，DBS只是家長用來Show Off自己仔女的能力。但背后的代價是小朋友的黃金歲月，就是放在無謂的競爭。

ANChan59

回復 oscarmama 的帖子

Any evidence to support your remark. If you are right with evidence, interesting finding.

motherotk

在大學時遇到不少頂尖高手是普通中學畢業, yes, that's true.

表現卻比名校讀死書學生(即高分低能)超幾班, not necessarily....

wanlucky

名校= 讀死書 schools?

ANChan59

回復 motherotk 的帖子

More fair comments.
Which programs and faculties you refer to? In medicine, global business, law, arch, engineering, science and social science, any difference in them.

Another perspective, any difference in student union and clubs in terms of leadership, teamwork, integrity of students from different backgrounds?

I raise the above two points to have a more objective and 3-D view of students in university from diverse backgrounds.

LSC is a great school. But some parents quoted their greatnesses are incorrect, like all their talents are home grown from P1,...  Great school not necessary a perfect school, tell me which is perfect school.

Declare my interest, we didn't apply LSC due to religious reason.

fsforth

原帖由 wanlucky 於 12-03-01 發表
名校= 讀死書 schools?

我反而覺得地區名校才多讀死書的人。

oscarmama

ANChan59 發表於 12-3-1 01:25
回復 oscarmama 的帖子

Any evidence to support your remark. If you are right with evidence, interest ...

真吾好意思，以上嗰段嘢係我C6亂咁用咗我account寫，我澄清吾係我立場，已經教訓咗我C6

ANChan59

回復 fsforth 的帖子

Be fair, it's bell curve. All schools have this type of students, just more or less and which group only.

Arlene

karen55407 發表於 12-2-29 20:59
真係好谷㗎！功課閒閒地都十樣八樣，啲默、測、考都唔嘢小，靠課本都唔夠。我呀女讀St Mary都甘拜下風！係 ...

I guess pushy or not pushy aligns with the kid's ability.  My experience is that LSPS is way less pushy than a lot of local schools with no connected high schools.  Though it has 2 tests & 2 exams but the coverage for each test/exam is not very extensive which makes reviewing less hectic.

And the homework volume varies from 3 to 10 including all those corrections.  Take no more than 2 hours to finish other than Fridays.

ANChan59

回復 Arlene 的帖子

According to your info, reasonable workload and pressure for boys in primary.

Gagagogo

小學收尖子我想也無可厚非，因小一進來的真是五湖四海，LS也是傳統名校，要維持一定水準。

我猜他們所講的home grown athletes是只由中一或小學進來的學生，由學校帶大，培育加培訓，大多學生都很有歸屬感，很有喇沙精神，不是跟有些學校一樣，在高中時收外援生，為校增光，這點亦值得商榷（不同價值觀，有人又覺得冇問題），亦非blue blood的問題，只是稍為功利，在學生角度，對自己培育的學校飲水思源。

KLN

syshawn 發表於 12-2-29 12:40
無論學術或運動都咁犀利，佢收生都係自行計分+大抽獎姐

可能這是答案

<喇沙小學之所以成為全港數一數二的小學，並不是因為我們的學生天資過人，而是因為我們秉承了優良的傳統和無私奉獻的價值觀，同時亦擁有一支高質素的管理和教學團隊，而更難能可貴的，是召集到一羣願意為學校及孩子付出時間及精神的家長！>

~~Snippet from LSPS 家教會快訊

oscarmama

ANChan59  No problem. Don't take it personal. Unfortunately, other parents take it seriously.....
BTW, What's your view?  發表於 2 小時前


.........你問我？..........我Buy名校架，始終有佢價值先至成為名校但我都明白未必每個小朋友都合適，如果適應到我都係覺得名校好

motherotk

Personal observation without statistical significance, of course.

wanlucky

喇沙不只是一間學校，而是一種精神！當然，名校出來不一定是精英，普通學校也能出尖子。但今時今日仍堅持不轉直資，提供免費教育的傳統名校，已經買少見少。