樂基，根德園，啟思，聖羅撒，劍鳴，創價，迦南，朗思

Christian09

新手媽咪，請問如果想報考傳統名校或直資小學，以上幼稚園邊間優勢大d？

Christian09

Himuimui, thank you for your kind reply.  Do you mean that anyone will be a good choice and there is little difference among them?

Christian09

Thanks a lot.

MYL0808

我都唔係好知,但睇得BK多,試下綜合一下,如有錯誤,請指教!
樂基:近幾年好紅,聽聞入小學成績好好,而且位少,掙崩頭中的掙崩頭!
根德園:傳統名幼,課程深,強中數,英文唔係NET,但聽聞亦教得唔淺,k1冇普通話課,超重視紀律,學位多,但申請人更多......
啟思(應該唔係講啟思附幼吧):課程淺,活動教學,Happy school
聖羅撒:有小學,但我唔知屬邊種
劍鳴:英文強,入小學成績好,小班教學,朋友試in佢的n1,感覺他們要求真係好高(英文方面)
創價:都算happy school,但好似話近年d課程調深左,因為紅左,所以又係掙崩頭
迦南:具體唔知,兩位識得既朋友都分別轉左校重讀k1及讀緊n1那位都唔打算直升,好似都係話太淺,冇乜野學到
朗思:貴!今個學年開學時因為新舊校舍問題攪到家長好唔開心,唔知件事攪成點

其實我所知真係有限,如果有媽咪有多d資料,不如都share下啦,過來人經驗,好過睇幼稚園天書

Christian09

好多謝MYL0808！希望有經驗的媽咪給多d意見同建議！

小曳人

樓主，點解你個list無SC嘅？
我自己覺得，要讀傳統學校，最好做功課做得快d，講功課多，KM>KV
另外，hkps都比較早要學寫字

但係你講邊間優勢大d，我自己就覺得，面試睇小朋友表現多過佢講邊間學校喎~
就算你有某校嘅畢業生成績睇到，都係只可以講，嗰間學校d家長傾向俾小朋友讀邊間/類學校

Christian09

多謝你的回復！關于SC，好遺憾，我們錯過報名時間了 。

原帖由 小曳人 於 11-10-21 16:54 發表
樓主，點解你個list無SC嘅？
我自己覺得，要讀傳統學校，最好做功課做得快d，講功課多，KM>KV
另外，hkps都比較早要學寫字

但係你講邊間優勢大d，我自己就覺得，面試睇小朋友表現多過佢講邊間學校喎~
就算你有某校嘅畢業生成績睇到，都 ...

Christian09

！！！！！！
多謝！

原帖由 LUCUSMaMa 於 11-10-21 17:04 發表
你列出既學校大約可分成2-3類, 我自己會分有學卷果幾間為TYPE A, 朗思同樂基為TYPE B, 劍鳴同根德園為TYPE C,

TYPE A既學生唔等於唔可以入傳統名校, 不過可能要家長自己再下些苦功, 眼見都有不少成功例子

TYPE B ...

IRK

My kid is now studying in playgroup (i.e. n1) of HKPS and we have tried n1 interview of some famous schools last year. Let me share some experience here...

HKPS 樂基 is a good school which is strength at language. Even my kid only attends around 2 months and still cries for going school alone, he loves his teachers and sings a lot of songs learnt from school, including school song in mandarin (I haven't trained him mandarin at home). I really appreciated the language environment of this school. BTW, I don't think this school forces kid to learn writing too early coz on our first parent day, the principle has already mentioned that it's not good for kid to write too early.

For others, just my personal feeling during interview:

KM 劍鳴 - I like this school too coz its interview arrangement is very good. Especially when I know that it was complained by lots of parents a year before, I can see its commitment of improvement which make me really appreciated.

Cannon 迦南 is a christian school which I like. Three of my friends' kid studying N1 there this year (3 different campus) and all feedback are positive especially their teachers are very caring. However, some parents may found its program is a little bit easy by comparing with others.

Creative 啟思's teacher is the most caring one in our interview record. I remember that was my kid's first interview and he was only 15m old. He lose his temper during interview. The interviewer was so caring and even comforted me during the interview. However, it's activity-based teaching  is not match with my preference.

Lastly, Think 朗思, I don't like this school starting from application form submission coz of their arrangement and I can't feel their caring throughout the whole program. Actually, their school fee are high too.

Above just my personal feeling for sharing. Some parents may have their own view. Actually, I'll suggest you to apply all coz during the K1 hunting process, you will know which school is suitable for your kid and your family. Like me in last year.

[ 本帖最後由 IRK 於 11-10-21 19:44 編輯 ]

Christian09

Appreciate you very much for sharing your experience   and admire you and your kid deeply (Studying in HKPS)

原帖由 IRK 於 11-10-21 17:26 發表
My kid is now studying in playgroup (i.e. n1) of HKPS and we have tried some famous n1 interview last year. Let me sharing some experience here...

HKPS 樂基 is a good school which strength at languag ...

小曳人

原帖由 IRK 於 11-10-21 17:26 發表
My kid is now studying in playgroup (i.e. n1) of HKPS and we have tried some famous n1 interview last year. Let me sharing some experience here...

HKPS 樂基 is a good school which strength at languag ...

可能我資料舊喇
hkps (ascot) K1開學就寫字
km 就K1下學期
一般學校就K2先寫字
如果九龍塘hkps咁講，咁佢"應該"要K2寫字先啱~

Yipapa

Why not adding some Dragon-kG

Musang, PC & etc

bbJP

原帖由 IRK 於 11-10-21 17:26 發表
My kid is now studying in playgroup (i.e. n1) of HKPS and we have tried some famous n1 interview last year. Let me sharing some experience here...

HKPS 樂基 is a good school which strength at languag ...

IRK

It's only God blessed. Add oil and keep praying. He will guide you to a school suitable for your kid.

HaYi

HKPS 樂基 is a good school which is strength at language..... - agree, but know parents fm HKPS (KLT) said compare with KM, they are not so demanding in N1 and K1 in writing. - I hv attend their K1 intervew few years ago, not so difficult, just as other school, but as most K1 seat are occupied by their own N1 students, so outsider got very few chance if want to get in fm K1, not sure about N1's situation as didn't be there.  

KM 劍鳴 - is pretty demand, some test during K1 already, so need parents to revision with them.. I hv attend their N1 interview few yrs ago, not so demanding as other school, teachers only observe, not question.. not sure if now hv change ..seesm not difficult for N1, but if interview in K1, will be same story as HKPS, very few seat for outsider.


Cannon 迦南- relatively is 淺, and I know quite few students fm there, the feel is their 自理能力 not so competitive as other kinder's, not to say academic .


Creative 啟思 - kids are quite "follow the order " type, academic / language is not demanding, emphasis in Chinese only. Many kids I know now in traditional gov't P1 and need go to tutorial center already as can't catch up.


Think 朗思 - good english enviorment, but seems like prepare for international school, not strong in chinese too.  The students are 有好奇心, 但不守規則多. Many go to DSS like Logos, GT..

聖羅撒 - 之前聽網上說k 同 p 的校長唔對口形, 所以 k 的上p 時有困難, 且k 的程度較淺, p 又是津校, 同p 不是一條龍, 入k是否值得就要三思.

soka 創價 - 好似是靈活教學, 不太深, 但因辦學團體的問題, 有不少家長 (包括我), 不會考慮.

[ 本帖最後由 HaYi 於 11-10-21 20:34 編輯 ]

bbeasy25

My son has writing homework in K1, and now K2 is a lot of writing homework which I think it is too much.  He is in HKPS(KLN Tong)

Christian09

So happy to get so many suggestion from all of you.   Add oil and keep praying.