Chance for applying St Joe, Wah Yan and LS

dmakcpa

Chance for applying St Joe, WY and LS.
Can anyone describe the chance comparison in 自行、統一 and 叩門 stage?
Thx!

tvnotallow

我都有叩門,但機會認該好微!!!

uarecheap

ST Jos 自行要有25分比較穏，統一機會應最大，叩門，機會等於零

Little_cy

How about wah yan? If only 15 marks can?

hellojl

原帖由 Little_cy 於 11-6-17 21:46 發表
How about wah yan? If only 15 marks can?

15分 = 200% 冇機會!

lugano

I guess no one would give up their spots at St. Joe, Wah Yan or La Salle .......

Make a wild guess, maybe someone will consider giving it up if there is offer from St. Paul's Co-Edu or DBS primary ?

thomasha

Your guess is wild indeed.  In one of the threads, BK parents also stated that they gave up seats in St Joe and Wah Yan.

原帖由 lugano 於 11-6-17 23:28 發表
I guess no one would give up their spots at St. Joe, Wah Yan or La Salle .......

Make a wild guess, maybe someone will consider giving it up if there is offer from St. Paul's Co-Edu or DBS primary ? ...

thomasha

Candidates with 20 marks still have to be selected by ballot, so you can imagine how slim the chance is for those who have 15 marks only.

原帖由 Little_cy 於 11-6-17 21:46 發表
How about wah yan? If only 15 marks can?

JanetKaKa

Can I summarise as below:
1. St. Joe - some chance for 25 marks
2. Wah Yan - some chance for 20 marks
3, LA - no info

Am I right?

lugano

原帖由 thomasha 於 11-6-18 01:10 發表
Your guess is wild indeed.  In one of the threads, BK parents also stated that they gave up seats in St Joe and Wah Yan.

I found the below thread you mentioned...

原帖由 lamtsuiyee 於 11-6-17 09:16 發表
20分入到St Joe...但已放位...

原帖由 bebelee 於 11-6-17 12:18 發表


sorry just to confirm - is it the first round or second round (i.e. lucky draw) you get into St Joe?

May I ask which school do you choose for your son?  (I believe it must be very good so if you give up St Joe...)

Any strategy how to fill in the form? (sorry to ask silly question but really want to know....)

原帖由 lamtsuiyee 於 11-6-17 14:53 發表

第一round...自行階段... 20分入...  我決定比小朋友讀國際學校.

我只係 point out 會有家長為子女選擇 "更好" 的學校, 如果錢又唔係問題, 而又有"更好"的 offer 在手, 如 International School, ESF, St Paul's Co Edu, DBSPD, 即將開的 Harrow School.....etc 相信大部份都會選擇 "更好"的

舉個攪笑的例子:
如果小朋友中央派位被派往 St. Joe 對面的 "東華三院李賜豪", 在李賜豪註策日當天, St. Joe / Wah Yan 校長在李賜豪門口開個 counter 叫李賜豪的男準備生歡迎他們即場註策入讀 St Joe / Wah Yan......而且 no obligation, 我諗很多家長都會即場轉校

我諗家長中就算有東華三院總理 OR 望族李賜豪後人都可能會即場轉校 !! 騎騎....

[ 本帖最後由 lugano 於 11-6-20 12:01 編輯 ]

lugano

原帖由 JanetKaKa 於 11-6-19 19:20 發表
Can I summarise as below:
1. St. Joe - some chance for 25 marks
2. Wah Yan - some chance for 20 marks
3, LA - no info

Am I right?

If you have 20 marks...you have chances for all 3...no worries

1. St. Joe - some chance for 20 marks
2. Wah Yan - some chance for 20 marks
3, LS - some chance for 20 marks

dmakcpa

What's "some" chance mean?  1/2, 1/3, 1/4, .....
Can you give more details?

lugano

原帖由 dmakcpa 於 11-6-20 11:58 發表
What's "some" chance mean?  1/2, 1/3, 1/4, .....
Can you give more details?

No one will have those exact data unless you work at the 3 schools or 教育局

In other BK threads, there were parents stated that they got in for the first round with only 20 points.  But never heard of someone with 15 points could get into all 3 schools.

My personal experience, I applied St Joe for 20 points but unable to make it in 1st round.  I chose a DSS and did not participate in 2nd round.

Little_cy

therefore, may i know if i only have 15 marks... 第2round有冇機入到wah yan呢...

scbhongkong

You are not living in Net 12. Right?

chmanpong

Yes, I live in Net12, so even I have only 15 marks , I will take it in 自行 first, then take 統一 again . But not sure how many successful rate on 統一 ? And , not sure any seat for 叩門 stage?

scbhongkong

Based on an unofficial statistics, there are around 800 kids in net 12 participating the central allocation.

Assume half of them are boys, 400 kids are boys.

Then you can determine the chance by yourself.

原帖由 chmanpong 於 11-6-24 13:52 發表
Yes, I live in Net12, so even I have only 15 marks , I will take it in 自行 first, then take 統一 again . But not sure how many successful rate on 統一 ? And , not sure any seat for 叩門 stage? ...

thomasha

如果你所講o既第二輪係統一派位，分數係唔計o既，只係純抽籤。

原帖由 Little_cy 於 11-6-24 11:50 發表
therefore, may i know if i only have 15 marks... 第2round有冇機入到wah yan呢...