看完德望中學年報, 你會選讀德望, 還是九龍塘宣小?

happymami

其實我真係好想知兩所學校既分別, 學校教學/ 學生品德 等等.....因為我覺得小朋友一入讀就 十幾年, 真係好想知多些, 請大家幫幫忙, 提供多些這兩間學校資料, 謝謝!

DGJS

HY 及 GH的透明度其實都很高。在他們的網頁上，我們大致能找到要看的東西。反而MCS就有D難! HY和GH都是好學校。品德教育及辦學宗旨十分相近。


過去三年, HY的公開試成績是十分穩定。但中學部明年轉直資。


如果兩間小學都收，我會以以下幾點作考慮：
1. 6年學費，HY可以省很多。
2. 如果有信仰，就很容易揀
（天主教與基督教）。
3. 地點，HY中學網比較好。
4. 每班人數HY(40人) vs GH(45人)


寫寫下才發現原來HY好像好D！


原來HY中6學生全部是HY中5升上去的。E個再要加D分。

原帖由 happymami 於 11-3-2 15:26 發表
其實我真係好想知兩所學校既分別, 學校教學/ 學生品德 等等.....因為我覺得小朋友一入讀就 十幾年, 真係好想知多些, 請大家幫幫忙, 提供多些這兩間學校資料, 謝謝! ...

elmolly

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-3-2 17:52 發表
HY 及 GH的透明度其實都很高。在他們的網頁上，我們大致能找到要看的東西。反而MCS就有D難! HY和GH都是好學校。品德教育及辦學宗旨十分相近。


過去三年, HY的公開試成績是十分穩定。但中學部明年轉直資。


如果兩間 ...

留意中學係直資既話就唔可以參加中央派位, 要睇下最後心儀邊間中學.

今年無資料, 但GH前幾年既中六都無outsider, 全部都係自己學校升上去的.

twinsstar1

原來HY中6學生全部是HY中5升上去的。E個再要加D分 ... ghs also. I guess most EMI school would be the same for this area.

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-3-2 17:52 發表
HY 及 GH的透明度其實都很高。在他們的網頁上，我們大致能找到要看的東西。反而MCS就有D難! HY和GH都是好學校。品德教育及辦學宗旨十分相近。


過去三年, HY的公開試成績是十分穩定。但中學部明年轉直資。


如果兩間 ...

DGJS

原來係咁！What is EMI?

原帖由 twinsstar1 於 11-3-3 09:07 發表
原來HY中6學生全部是HY中5升上去的。E個再要加D分 ... ghs also. I guess most EMI school would be the same for this area.

Jackie310

GH 返學時間係7:30a.m., 大家要考慮埋佢個地點同車程, 以及星期六返學校上課外活動既安排 (如有參加的話)...

twinsstar1

i.e. the old system -- schools using "english as a medium of instruction" ....

If you go over the past data abt the available F.6 seats after the 1st round of admitting F.5 students. Most seats of the EMI school are filled up by their own students in the 1st round of admission  

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-3-3 09:32 發表
原來係咁！What is EMI?

nicolemummy

我都玩緊部IPHONE4.

原帖由 angrybirds 於 11-3-3 22:31 發表
今日響荔景站見到個德望中學學生玩緊部IPHONE4

DGJS

有D古怪! 下面是從 GH 2009-2010 report 拿出來的人數. 理論上今年的S1會是明年的S2, 如此類推. 從以下資料, 好像每升一級都有十多個人不見了! 但在同一report, exit rate 只有~ 1%!?

Level	S1	S2	S3	S4	S5
(2007-2008)	270	254	239	227	155
(2008-2009)	254	265	222	209	207
(2009-2010)	239	238	249	207	198

HY & St. Mary 就相對穩定. MCS 就相當神秘!

原帖由 twinsstar1 於 11-3-3 13:54 發表
i.e. the old system -- schools using "english as a medium of instruction" ....

If you go over the past data abt the available F.6 seats after the 1st round of admitting F.5 students. Most seats of t ...

[ 本帖最後由 DGJS 於 11-3-4 11:34 編輯 ]

twinsstar1

Factors of repeat? hahah ...how to calculate exit rate ga?

but as far as  I know .. really a lot of them will go overseas. I don;t know if it is the case in other Band 1 schools also.

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-3-4 10:44 發表
有D古怪! 下面是從 GH 2009-2010 report 拿出來的人數. 理論上今年的S1會是明年的S2, 如此類推. 從以下資料, 好像每升一級都有十多個人不見了! 但在同一report, exit rate 只有~ 1%!?

LevelS1S2S3S4S5(2007-2008)27 ...

[ 本帖最後由 twinsstar1 於 11-3-4 11:43 編輯 ]

DGJS

In general, early exit rate is the % of pupils leaving the school earlier than graduation. GH listed ~1%.

The figure shows that an average of ~6% of pupils exit in each year in each level. It is not general. It is not possible that all of them go overseas.

As mentioned, you can also check the reports in St mary and Heep Yunn. They do not show that high exit rate except from F.3 to F.4.

I am not critising GH. I like GH as well. I just don't know why. Especially, their report shows that the exit rate is only ~1%.

原帖由 twinsstar1 於 11-3-4 11:40 發表
Factors of repeat? hahah ...how to calculate exit rate ga?

but as far as  I know .. really a lot of them will go overseas. I don;t know if it is the case in other Band 1 schools also.

twinsstar1

Thanks for your clarification

of course I know you're not critising ghs la ... I don't mean that you're critising actually :) Sorry if my words have made you feel bad ...

But can't it be repeating? so the students are still there but the no. of the students in that form drop. ... ? But you're right ... even after counting the factor of "repeat" .. the % seems quite high too.... hahah really don;t know the reasons ....

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-3-4 13:46 發表
In general, early exit rate is the % of pupils leaving the school earlier than graduation. GH listed ~1%.

The figure shows that an average of ~6% of pupils exit in each year in each level. It is not  ...

[ 本帖最後由 twinsstar1 於 11-3-4 14:32 編輯 ]

DGJS

No, it cannot be due to repeating. The figure in the table shows the total # of pupils in each class in each year. If one pupil has repeated, the coming class will have one more pupil quitted in order to make the same number of pupils in that form.

原帖由 twinsstar1 於 11-3-4 14:00 發表
Thanks for your clarification

of course I know you're not critising ghs la ... I don't mean that you're critising actually :) Sorry if my words have made you feel bad ...

But can't it be repeating ...

[ 本帖最後由 DGJS 於 11-3-4 14:39 編輯 ]

twinsstar1

then really don;t know ...

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-3-4 14:34 發表
No, it cannot be due to repeating. The figure in the table shows the total # of pupils in each class in each year. If one pupil has repeated, the coming class will have one more pupil quitted in order ...

DGJS

我把HEEP YUUN 的也列出來。今年的S1會是明年的S2。HEEP YUUN 是相對地穩定。GH 的 ~6%太奇怪了!

Heep Yunn
level	S1	S2	S3	S4	S5
(2007-2008)	219	218	208	199	200
(2008-2009)	200	213	208	206	191
(2009-2010)	190	203	210	199	205
GH
Level	S1	S2	S3	S4	S5
(2007-2008)	270	254	239	227	155
(2008-2009)	254	265	222	209	207
(2009-2010)	239	238	249	207	198

原帖由 twinsstar1 於 11-3-4 14:42 發表
then really don;t know ...

DGJS

如果把網上能得到的資料全取下來，情況更古怪。GH所收的學生, 自 F.1 讀到 F.5, 從平均260人跌到平均200人。有60人不知去向！

（2003-2004）年的就更奇怪！他們中一有260人。到中二還是260人。中三是232人，中4是195人，到中五只剩下155人! 這一屆應該有問題。這一屆升到中七 時是 （2009-2010）年度, 剛好就是成績最差的一屆。

問題是從F.1 到 F.5, 升了四次班後平均有60人不知去向！這是一個迷!

GH
Level	S1	S2	S3	S4	S5
(2003-2004)	260	245	254	222	218
(2004-2005)	266	260	226	244	207
(2005-2006)	264	253	232	206	219
(2006-2007)	266	251	236	195	191
(2007-2008)	270	254	239	227	155
(2008-2009)	254	265	222	209	207
(2009-2010)	239	238	249	207	198

[ 本帖最後由 DGJS 於 11-3-4 17:23 編輯 ]

Sumyeema1

首先聲明，我認同 GH 是一所好學校。

DGJS, 你能自 School Report 的學生人數中分析出成績下降的原因，真系

twinsstar1

then why can't it be overseas studies / going to other schools? and repeat too?

i think these 2 are the chief factors ... just that I don't understand why it is 1%. That's why i ask how the exist rate is calculated

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-3-4 15:44 發表
如果把網上能得到的資料全取下來，情況更古怪。GH所收的學生, 自 F.1 讀到 F.5, 從平均260人跌到平均200人。有60人不知去向！

（2003-2004）年的就更奇怪！他們中一有260人。到中二還是260人。中三是232人，中4是195人，到中五只 ...

[ 本帖最後由 twinsstar1 於 11-3-4 16:16 編輯 ]

twinsstar1

hey hey .. what about each form they got people repeating, plus people going overseas ... then there won't be one person more in the coming form even there's one person repeating in a year.

Moreover, the F.1 intake of each year is different too .. so it's a bit difficult to estimate how many that each form has originally.

seems a bit complicated ar ..

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-3-4 14:34 發表
No, it cannot be due to repeating. The figure in the table shows the total # of pupils in each class in each year. If one pupil has repeated, the coming class will have one more pupil quitted in order ...

[ 本帖最後由 twinsstar1 於 11-3-4 16:14 編輯 ]