是否一定要讀幼稚園

DGJS

法律上如果已經列明, 這議題便不用討論.

但根據教統局的資料, 兒童年齡在五歲八個月或以上（以九月一日入學時為準）而仍未就讀小學，均可參加教育局的小一入學統籌辦法，入讀官立或資助小學一年級。這辦法旨在免除兒童為忙於應付小學一年級入學考試所造成的壓力，以及對幼稚園教育造成不良的影響。

iantsang

Kindergarten study is totally optional under the law of HKSAR.  Children are required to attend schools only from the age of 5 years old and 8 months.

So, even without ever studying in kindergarten, a child MUST BE offered a seat in a primary school thru discretionary places or central allocation.

QtieBB

係......身邊有真實個案係無上幼稚園,然後考到小學的.佢媽咪真係俾左好多心機係佢囡囡身上.

cherrieshum

一定會讓子女讀幼稚園，除非乞食或癲了！！
讀幼稚園除了學習知識外，社交也同樣重要！

cherrieshum

原帖由 QtieBB 於 11-1-28 15:56 發表
係......身邊有真實個案係無上幼稚園,然後考到小學的.佢媽咪真係俾左好多心機係佢囡囡身上.

傻的媽媽！！自討沒趣！想害死小孩嗎？？:;pppp:

w_y

又唔需要咁講, homeschooling  都唔係咩奇事. 當然媽媽要放好多心機, 社交都有其他途徑做到.

記得唔知邊份報紙專欄, 個媽媽買左艘船同兩個女周遊列國, 自己教小朋友學問, 返到香港再入小學. 我不知幾羨慕.

cherrieshum

是的！sorry！
不過自己一定會讓兒女讀幼稚園！

DGJS

在外國很多家庭都沒有讓小孩讀幼稚園, 香港反而有一些家長要小孩讀兩間幼稚園，要贏在起點。

axis

社交重要!! But讀兩間幼稚園am+pm too many la!!
除非乞食or VeryVeryVery Rich !!

梅媽媽

教統局無叫人學鋼琴,但個個父母都要仔女學;教統局無叫人補習但個個仔女都去補,教統局講求學不是求分數.又有多少人能真正做得到.
如果全香港的父母都咁聽教統局的話,就等於全港市民都聽香港政府話,你會唔會?我諗我會考慮自己既實際需要.

QtieBB

孩子的媽係某中學既英文老師,佢既小朋友雖然無返幼稚園,但我覺得佢很有禮貌,亦識得同人相處啊.....仲考到德望小學添......我又唔覺佢媽咪害C個囡喎!

ho_yan2406

原帖由 QtieBB 於 11-2-7 01:13 發表
孩子的媽係某中學既英文老師,佢既小朋友雖然無返幼稚園,但我覺得佢很有禮貌,亦識得同人相處啊.....仲考到德望小學添......我又唔覺佢媽咪害C個囡喎!

我以為一定要讀既添~
咁佢媽咪都好勁喎,返工咁忙都仲咁有心機教女

bosch

原帖由 QtieBB 於 11-2-7 01:13 發表
孩子的媽係某中學既英文老師,佢既小朋友雖然無返幼稚園,但我覺得佢很有禮貌,亦識得同人相處啊.....仲考到德望小學添......我又唔覺佢媽咪害C個囡喎!

響香港, 可以令小朋友唔返幼稚園, 而且係在職媽媽教小朋友, 肯承擔 (唔係話要小朋友返幼稚園果d 媽媽不負責任), 可以教到小朋友好好, 有好學校收, 真係好難得, 好犀利.

唔駛小朋友返幼稚園, 我唔覺得會害C小朋友, 唔清楚就咁講太武斷.   我住呢度d 小朋友一般都係4歲入學 (5歲係法定入學年齡). 我自己都係咁俾我個仔4歲至入學, 唔駛佢讀學前班/pg 等.  慶幸有好多人都係咁做, 坦白講, 如果我身處香港, 我都唔夠膽俾小朋友一黎就去讀小學.

我個仔就快3歲, 佢以前時好少同人玩, 我都怕佢唔識同人相處.  我以前都覺得應該要佢3歲去返學, 要有社交生活. 但而家我睇佢個情況, 返唔返都得, 而家佢去人地屋企, 唔會玩自閉, 同其他小朋友熟左就同人玩, 又會同大人玩, 社交方面冇問題.  我平時有同佢去超巿, 去公園, 去搵朋友, 佢都有機會去同人溝通, 學紀律 (e.g. 排隊等等).   我聽幾位教幼稚園既親友, 冇去托兒所/playgroup 既小朋友既表現當然會有d 唔同, 但之後大家都係一樣.

返幼稚園仲會去學課本知識, 如果熟悉學校既syllabus, 對教小朋友會更有幫助.  呢樣我都仲係鑽研中.  不過好多人要小朋友幾歲就去學4-5種語言, k3 就要識背九因歌, 我對呢樣有保留...  嬴在起跑線係冇用, 要有後勁至得架....

InitialD

For super big boy, they can start P1 at 6 years old and 8 months.. There are some contradict with your message???



是否一定要讀幼稚園


法律上如果已經列明, 這議題便不用討論.

但根據教統局的資料, 兒童年齡在五歲八個月或以上（以九月一日入學時為準）而仍未就讀小學，均可參加教育局的小一入學統籌辦法，入讀官立或資助小學一年級。這辦法旨在免除兒童為忙於應付小學一年級入學考試所造成的壓力，以及對幼稚園教育造成不良的影響???

[ 本帖最後由 InitialD 於 11-2-9 12:24 編輯 ]

DGJS

教統局的資料, 兒童年齡在五歲八個月或以上....

No contradiction!

原帖由 InitialD 於 11-2-9 12:23 發表
For super big boy, they can start P1 at 6 years old and 8 months.. There are some contradict with your message???



是否一定要讀幼稚園


法律上如果已經列明, 這議題便不用討論.

但根據教統局的資料, 兒 ...

InitialD

Is it against the law if you do not send the kid to Primary school at age of 5years8 months? If yes, please advise which law 法律?

[ 本帖最後由 InitialD 於 11-2-9 14:23 編輯 ]

DGJS

You may search the EDB website then advise to me.

I did not mention it was a law or not for primary issue. Even in Kinder issue, I was only raising a question.

原帖由 InitialD 於 11-2-9 14:22 發表
Is it against the law if you do not send the kid to Primary school at age of 5years8 months? If yes, please advise which law 法律?

[ 本帖最後由 DGJS 於 11-2-9 17:41 編輯 ]

iantsang

May be I am the one who mentioned this is regulated by law to send children to school.

The law was initially applied to children from the age of 6 to 11, for 6 years of compulsory education back in 1971, I think.  It was later being extended for three more years to the first three years to the age of 14/15.  Whether the start has been push early to 5 years and 8 months, this I didn't verify.

Sorry if I created any confusions.

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-2-9 17:37 發表
You may search the EDB website then advise to me.

I did not mention it was a law or not for primary issue. Even in Kinder issue, I was only raising a question.

恩林

個個地方生活環境都不同...我覺得外國的中學生都唔係番學咁架la....wakakaka
佢地主張生活中學習, 佢地地方環境許可, 但香港搵個山行下都難, 所以好難咁比較~!!
另外, 香港的學生真係好慘, 人地主修英文, 輔修其他語文, 香港就中英都係主修....淨係d樣野都咁慘~~~!

原帖由 DGJS 於 11-1-28 17:36 發表
在外國很多家庭都沒有讓小孩讀幼稚園, 香港反而有一些家長要小孩讀兩間幼稚園，要贏在起點。

w_y

香港行山路徑好正架! 阿女都愛上行山. 好多日本人專程來港行山. 只係大部份家長覺得行山不及多做幾張工作紙有用.

不過外國國情同香港係有一定分別就真.

香港搵個山行下都難