反對全日制.....

chan803

原帖由 DaddyX 於 11-2-5 11:02 發表
我記得以前自已小學生時
半日己經好辛苦
同太早起身好慘

所以我自已心裡覺得半日好D
但實際上我就會選全日,
點解?因為如果半日
有幾多家長會下午令佢地去補習狂谷!!
全日呢個effect會小D D ...

係咪有D 矛盾呢? 自己返半日時就覺得好慘, 到比自己的小朋友讀時就覺得半日好D?

chan803

原帖由 peggy 於 11-2-3 02:10 發表



我都想囝囝幫手做家務 , 囝囝現在P.5, 每日都要做2.5 - 3 小時功課, 放學返來差不多4點, 食完TEA & 沖涼後已4:30 , 做完HOMEWORK 已經7:30 , 有時8點, 跟住就食飯, 食完都成9點, 跟住溫一陣書, 9:30就上床, 邊度 ...

家務有好多種, 由幾分鐘可以完成, 到要用成日的都有.

簡單的, 平日要教, 真係會搵唔到時間去教? 複雜D GE, 星期六/日,假日都搵唔到時間去教?

chan803

原帖由 VV媽 於 11-1-28 17:09 發表
依家d細路咁忙,真的沒有多餘時間比去做d在父母眼中多餘的事...

可能呢個先係最重要的原因

既然覺得多餘, 自然係搵唔到"多餘時間"去做啦

如果升中要考埋家務, 睇下仲會唔會無時間去教/去做呀

chan803

原帖由 kitbebe 於 11-2-1 17:03 發表
真係咁架, 我都覺得太過份啦, 到阿女小五, 我會教佢學下入廚, 煮d簡單野.

"個讀緊大學 ge 女" 仲會咁聽佢老豆話

peggy

原帖由 chan803 於 11-2-6 23:12 發表


家務有好多種, 由幾分鐘可以完成, 到要用成日的都有.

簡單的, 平日要教, 真係會搵唔到時間去教? 複雜D GE, 星期六/日,假日都搵唔到時間去教?

簡單既家務兩兄妹當然識做, eg 每日吃飯時他們會set 枱 , 吃完後會收拾碗筷 , 幫手摺衫 , 用布沬塵; 囝囝煲滾水"六"菜 . 煎午餐肉都識 & 簡單既抄蛋都識. 連蒸肉餅加調味料都識

他們是想學煮番幾味 . made cake & 其他較複雜既家務 , 但真係冇時教佢地!

[ 本帖最後由 peggy 於 11-2-7 00:07 編輯 ]

peggy

原帖由 PoMan 於 11-2-6 23:43 發表
peggy,

我囡囡學校依家就會安排係精英班D同學仔, 好似你仔仔甘返早45分鐘.  佢原先返8:15AM, 如果要返就要返7:30AM, 因我囡囡身體唔太好, 而佢學校的精英班好就好在自由參加, 所以, 我希望佢瞓多D好過, 無比佢參加 ...

囝囝那時規定p3全級既同學都要返,
出年p6既精英班, 5月至7月還要每日放學後留校補課1hr, 預備中學既分班試作準備, 到時又要同囝囝改個晒d活動, 真煩!

chan803

原帖由 peggy 於 11-2-6 23:54 發表

...
他們是想學煮番幾味 . made cake & 其他較複雜既家務 , 但真係冇時教佢地!

可以留返放假時教架MA

peggy

大家加油!:

jkc633

I always have the strong feeling that our kids are spending way too much time at the "whole day school"!!    Take for example for my young son of 6 only (P1):

Statistics:
-Get up, breakfast, school bus etc     7am
-School                                             8 am to 3pm
-School bus home, tea/rest a bit        4pm
          This is already talking about 9 hours!

-Extra activity+travelling             1.5hr                  
-Homework                               1.5hr
-Dictation/test revision               1   
          A minium 4 hours till 8pm already!

- Dinner + bath                           1            
- Musical instruments practice      0.5
          Already 9:30pm and I have to hurry my son to pack school bag, brush teeth, and go to bed by 10pm.  He only has 9 hrs sleep every night which is not enough for a 6 years old!   

It is a hugh pity that there is just no time for the most important parents and child chatting, bonding time!   

I actually knew a lawyer couple in HK whose kids are "HOME SCHOOLING" only.  They follow outside syllabus for Chin, Eng and Maths.  They get up in the morning and start their homestudy, then by noon they have already finished the whole days' work and they are free to read books, do sports, join team acty like scouts, church groups, drama, orchestra etc.  The kids are perfectly normal in terms of social skills AND they are more advanced in their studies comparing to other kids of their age in HK.  They took open exams as Cambridge Eng exams and got good grades.  I envy them so much.  They have just so much more free time to develop, to think, to enjoy life.     

I strongly suggest HK to allow home schooling!    Parents and kids too should have a choice to choose the type of education they desire.

I tried to find half day school for my son but there is just so few left now.  

For whole day schools, they SHOULD let the kids do the homework at school, and do sports, music acty instead having more drilling classes.   Poor kids of HK.

tws2010

Can't agree with you more.  I really have a feeling that we are torturing our little kids...They really have long studying hours both at school and at home...I am also a working mum.  To a certain extent, we could relax and stop thinking of our work once we are off.   The little kids, however, still have to continue their "OT" at home and could seldom have a break until they go to bed...How abnormal our educational system is in HK.  I try my best to play more with my kid at night.  The ratio will be (within an hour), 30% studying and 70% play time.  However, just try my best to do so.  In reality, it may be difficult...

原帖由 jkc633 於 11-2-15 02:36 發表
I always have the strong feeling that our kids are spending way too much time at the "whole day school"!!    Take for example for my young son of 6 only (P1):

Statistics:
-Get up, breakfast, school b ...

Rhapsody2

jkc633,

But is it illegal in HK not to let children attend school ?

jkc633

The lawyer couple have Canadian passports and so do the kids.  I think they claim themselves to be Canadian rather than HK people.   
Anyway, nobody report them either!  I understand the kids will be going abroad to study (and join the schools there) in high school stage.


I really hope primary school (at least for the lower primary school P1 to 3) can have half day or shorter school hours.  If the school finishes at 2pm instead of 3 or 3:30pm, it makes a hugh difference to the kids.  They can take good rest, refresh themselves physically AND mentally before they resume the "OT" of homework and revision at home again.  

In my youth, all primary schools are half day only (just to cater for the abundant pupils in those days), now most primary schools are whole day (again just to cater for the low birth rate).  This is NOT attending to the real NEEDS of the kids.  

原帖由 Rhapsody2 於 11-2-16 00:11 發表
jkc633,

But is it illegal in HK not to let children attend school ?

tws2010

In fact, kids will have better lives if they go to half day school.  They could have more time on study or even more time other meaningful things or even relaxing at home.  Besides, the teacher could have more time doing preparation for the classes the day after.  It's win win situation.  I am also working mum but I fully support half day school.

原帖由 jkc633 於 11-2-17 19:46 發表
The lawyer couple have Canadian passports and so do the kids.  I think they claim themselves to be Canadian rather than HK people.   
Anyway, nobody report them either!  I understand the kids wi ...

Itochu

I surely disagree with whole day primary school.
You can always find it is bad arrangement regarding lunch arrangement as the food is easily to get cold in winter; choice is very limited; food are not fresh, it is not healthy to kids in long term.

chan803

原帖由 25point5 於 11-2-18 10:00 發表
全日制小學, 扼殺小朋友發展空間, 個個像工廠倒模出來, 全無個人特質, 分別祇在來自A工廠或B工廠!!!

提議聯署反對全日制!!!

吓, 呢個係香江教育特質 wor, 以前半日制咪係一樣...