玫瑰崗vs蘇浙, 可以俾d意見嗎?

cindy1529

兩間都有pm Offer, 已經俾0左留位費玫瑰崗, 而家要決定俾唔俾留位費蘇浙.

以兩間程度0黎講, 邊間好d呢?

同時亦等緊聖心result.

希望大家可以俾d意見啦, thanks!

cindy1529

原帖由 cindy1529 於 11-1-22 23:50 發表
兩間都有pm Offer, 已經俾0左留位費玫瑰崗, 而家要決定俾唔俾留位費蘇浙.

以兩間程度0黎講, 邊間好d呢?

同時亦等緊聖心result.

希望大家可以俾d意見啦, thanks! ...

真係心大心細, 唔知點揀呀, 大家可以俾D意見嗎? Thanks!

tanglulu

of course KCS la !!

cindy1529

tanglulu, 點解你會覺得KCS好過RSH呀?
可唔可以分析下, 俾多D意見呀? Thanks!
兩間學校我都有鍾意同唔鍾意嘅地方, 但係又唔了解佢地小學嘅程度, 所以唔知點揀呀.

tanglulu

just look at the academic level of primary, KCS is already better then RHS. i have to admit that the environment of KCS is not as good as RHS, however, the academic level of KCS is really impressive.

Kim08

but KCS doesn't guarantee promotion into K1... RHS guarantee from my understanding? Please correct me if I am wrong!

tanglulu

yes, need to sit for interview for KCS K1 again, but N1 students should have greater chance

fefemom

原帖由 天賜小公主 於 11-1-25 09:48 發表
We have the same situation, both schools have am offer(其實蘇浙是唯一一間有offer, rhs就因現在讀pn, 所以可以真升k1).  已經俾0左留位費玫瑰崗, 而家要決定俾唔俾留位費蘇浙.
個人比較喜歡RHS, 因為環境, 老師 ...

恭喜曬小公主

cindy1529

原帖由 天賜小公主 於 11-1-25 09:48 發表
We have the same situation, both schools have am offer(其實蘇浙是唯一一間有offer, rhs就因現在讀pn, 所以可以真升k1).  已經俾0左留位費玫瑰崗, 而家要決定俾唔俾留位費蘇浙.
個人比較喜歡RHS, 因為環境, 老師 ...

我地都係比較喜歡RHS, 我囡囡都係比較慢熱, 要觀察好耐. 如果KSC著重於主動嘅小朋友, 我都驚我囡囡唔適合.
但係D人就話KSC優點就係兩文三語, 但係RHS都有兩日普通話同兩日英文, 係咪都可以好快學到呢兩種語言呢?
以你喺RHS所觀察, D小朋友語言能力好唔好呢?
所以, 我地而家都重未決定俾唔俾留位費.

fefemom

Overall, I like SHCK best too....

If we don't get an offer from SHCK, my husband prefers RHS because of the environment, teachers and teaching etc. I think St. Clare's has the advantage to guarantee P1 promotion.

We have not applied to KCS as we aim at kindergartens with religious background. I also learn that their PN has large classes >30 students per class and we would like a bit more attention to our girl though we don't know about the class size in KCS K1.

I think if one thinks PTH is a very important factor, then KCS has an advantage over RHS. Despite the 2- day per week PTH learnt in RHS PN, my girl doesn't seem to understand the language much (in contrast to English which she can carry out a short converstaion and understands it well). In contrast, I know a girl who studies at KCS PN and her PTH is stronger. I also understand there is individual variation...

Good luck for SHCK!

cindy1529

fefemon & 小公主, 咁係咪如果SH收的話, 你地會揀SH呢?
我都要諗定, 如果好彩收的話, 都唔知點揀, 真係好頭痛呀!

fefemom

Yes, we will choose SH if my girls is lucky enough to get an offer.

PS: I have also pm you sometime ago. Please check.

mandy_ma

share the similar case....

my daughter have a choice between LH(AM) & KCS(PM)....don't know how to choose...

waiting the result by SH (even it's little chance cos my baby girl is small b)

can u share your opinions for KSC VS SH for girl? and why??

原帖由 cindy1529 於 11-1-25 15:39 發表
fefemon & 小公主, 咁係咪如果SH收的話, 你地會揀SH呢?
我都要諗定, 如果好彩收的話, 都唔知點揀, 真係好頭痛呀!

cindy1529

我地尋晚商量後決定唔交KCS留位費啦.
因為擔心囡囡唔明老師講咩(在家中都不是用PTH及英文溝通), 難以適應, 怕攪到佢唔想返學呀.
而且, 暫時真係鐘意RHS多D.
希望我地呢個決定無錯啦.

ahnew

小小意見: RH & KCS 個人覺得不太相同... 建議你地想想....日後想小朋友升讀什麼類型的小學/中學... for eg. 如想傳統型的可能RH 會合適點 (個人意見 RH 課程比較深 ) 但如果想讀著重 language 的小學 如陳守仁蔡繼有等等, 可能 KCS 會有點點優勢.

如果你問我, 我會選 KCS