Ian 有問題請教

ck07hk

請問聖心小學上中學大概有幾多%小朋友呢? 有人話唔係好多上到中學??

iantsang

around 200 students

原帖由 ck07hk 於 11-1-10 10:29 發表
請問聖心小學上中學大概有幾多%小朋友呢? 有人話唔係好多上到中學??

iantsang

Oh sorry you asked about the percentage too.

For SHCSPS (am),  it should be around 70-80% to SHCC, another 20% to other band 1 schools.

For SHCS (pm), they don't post the result but I can use the data to work backwards to know around 60-70% to SHCC.  I have no information on how many percentages would go to other band 1 school.

Naturally, at least the top 10-15% of these feeder primary schools would head elsewhere, rather than their own secondary school.

ck07hk

咁即係大部份都會升返聖心中學啦?? 而走嗰d都係因為揾到更好的, 係咪??

iantsang

Actually I just answered something similar in another thread on the kindergarten forum.

Basically SHCC reserve 90% of their seats for own primary students, I think that's already the best they can do.

Most of those who left are either the top part or the bottom part.  The top part will probably be heading to some better schools, or simply leave because they may want to stay in Central & Western Disctrict/ Wan Chai District to study, rather than heading to island south where SHCC is located.  There will be some students who can't reach SHCC if either they are the unlucky band 2 or the small number of band 3 students (I don't know for certain if they have any or the actual size of them).

原帖由 ck07hk 於 11-1-10 15:32 發表
咁即係大部份都會升返聖心中學啦?? 而走嗰d都係因為揾到更好的, 係咪??

ck07hk

明白了, 唔該哂你呀! Ian.

iantsang

welcome!  

原帖由 ck07hk 於 11-1-10 17:28 發表
明白了, 唔該哂你呀! Ian.

iantsang

Do you actually have this data?  Because I have read the annual reports of both SHCSPS and SHCS for previous years and don't notice a significant number of students leaving.... just a few per year.

原帖由 babyqueendom 於 11-1-11 11:41 發表
另一方面，上午校因家庭背景，也有較多學生出國留學

iantsang

Let me share some information for you as reference:

According to the school's annual report, the departure rate is in average 0.8%, that's about 5-6 students (entire school) a year.

Naturally in the development of HK education, the role of private school is they have the flexibility to provide stronger and tougher curriculum.  If you try to understand the current secondary one placement system, you would understand why many students from band 1 feeder primary school would head to other schools due to the flexibility it provide to the top few percents of students in entire HK.

The result is this, historically (and I am talking about really long time ago), private section certainly provide the clear edge over gov't aided section.  So, in the old days, SHCC students are mainly from SHCSPS.  The percentage of SHCS students attending SHCC would be low.  However, many changes over the year (like SHCC moved to island south, and the changes of placement system of secondary) and the situation has changed quite a bit.  On percentage, SHCSPS still has higher percentage over SHCS.  However, SHCS has a much bigger student body over SHCSPS, so although SHCSPS has higher percentage, the number of students heading to SHCC may be higher from SHCS.

Hope this information is useful for your reference.

Ian

原帖由 babyqueendom 於 11-1-12 10:17 發表
I obviously don't have any actual data, but heard from the old girls. I knew that when I tried to find out the quality between am and pm schools. The feeling that I have got is that am graduates are o ...