Finally 全軍覆末 @.@

kc_united

我真的不太明白. 為什麼我呀囡沒一間kowloon tong 幼稚園收?  報了 kv, sc, soka, 我用全軍覆末形容, 最貼切!

我同先生都是專業人仕(正正是中產), interview 前實地觀察,  了解學校.  interview 時答話得體大方. 不過家住普通大型屋苑. 不知會否影响?

囡囡4/07大囡, 自理能力高, interview 時衣著整齊, 樣子可人, 不過in sc/kv 時, 的確少說話, 但 in soka 時, 表現十分好. 什麼問題都有答, 什麼什麼推椅, 叫早晨, byebye等全自動, 但結果都是 rejected offer.  總結無論說話不說話, 似乎沒有影響小女結果. 不過個人小小推論.
sc/kv - 因小女少說話. in kv時, 唔唱歌,  爸爸in sc時, 唔記得推椅.  亦不知是否我同丈夫答問題時, 答得太perfect太詳細.

soka - 我一點都指不出囡囡有什麼做得不好. 只能說, referal case 較多, 學位較少.

過往, 一些小朋友少說話, in sc/kv 都收.  但今年開心的surprised 無我囡囡份, 是什麼出錯, 確實唔知! 只能說你做得好時, 別人更好.  

其實大家可否給予我意見, 看看有什麼問題能指出, 能改善?

monchuBB

你囡囡是細仔嗎?

原帖由 kc_united 於 09-12-7 10:55 發表
我真的不太明白. 為什麼我呀囡沒一間kowloon tong 幼稚園收?  報了 kv, sc, soka, 我用全軍覆末形容, 最貼切!

我同先生都是專業人仕(正正是中產), interview 前實地觀察,  了解學校.  interview 時答話得體大方. 不 ...

esther.cy

Totally understand and shared your feeling.

I heard from a friend that her kids never speak a word but were admitted to St. Paul KG a few years ago since there were less kids / applications at that time; but in these 2 years, over 80,000 babies (2007 & 2008)  were borned and make very keen competition, nowadays KG will NOT take kids speak no word during the interview (e.g. SHCK principle said to my friend).

As far as I know, there are far too many applications:

1) KCS-KG : over 1,500 application
2) St. Cat: 4,000
3) SPK: over 3,000 application
(P.S. Correct me if I am wrong)

I just take it as "entering into a Lucky Draw"... Somehow I regret to give birth these few years which make my kids so difficult :(

But I will never give up trying. U too, don't give up! Support you!

babykitty@

点解唔試York,這間學校好俾機会D小朋友,大部份都Accept.
可能有些家長会覺得唔吃香,咁易收,但我覺得總好過其他名幼稚園都唔知收生用咩準則,Interview好唔收,又要分大B細B.不公平.
你不要失望,rejected letter不代表什麽,不是小朋友問題而是學校遊戲規則問題.
Add Oil:yummy :

Bert

Moreover, I think there are far more applications for SC this year.   Last year, they completed their interview in 2 days, but this year they require 3 days to complete all the interviews.

share123

原帖由 kc_united 於 09-12-7 10:55 發表
我真的不太明白. 為什麼我呀囡沒一間kowloon tong 幼稚園收?  報了 kv, sc, soka, 我用全軍覆末形容, 最貼切!

我同先生都是專業人仕(正正是中產), interview 前實地觀察,  了解學校.  interview 時答話得體大方. 不 ...

你係咪交表交得好遲?

jaycee_mami

原帖由 babykitty@ 於 09-12-7 11:13 發表
点解唔試York,這間學校好俾機会D小朋友,大部份都Accept.
可能有些家長会覺得唔吃香,咁易收,但我覺得總好過其他名幼稚園都唔知收生用咩準則,Interview好唔收,又要分大B細B.不公平.
你不要失望,rejected letter不代表 ...

yes, york is easy to give you an offer though my kid (small B) did very bad in the interview.

kc_united, you can call york quickly for details.  I know there will be a seminar for parents this sat (12/12), if you attend it, the chance of acceptance is very very high.

os2002

唔好諗咁多先,即刻打去york 問

os2002

你聽完個briefing, interview完,如果唔鍾意先算

clara1477

After interviewing 7 KGs, 3 schools accepted, 1 is waiting, other 3 are waiting for the result.   I feel that for a school to decide whether to accept a boy/girl, it depends on the combination of the following factors :

-whether your kid can talk.
-whether yr kid has response.
-the character of the kid..too passive / too active?
- hand-eye coordination
- politeness

- whether yr kid has get rid of diaper
- whether the parents can cooperate with the school
- whether the partents can spend time with their son/daughter
- whether the parents' education philosophy = school
- 和老師眼緣
- some people say schools will also consider parents' job.... i think it is not necessary

As many kids can perform more or less the same, I think the school will focus more on interviewing parents in determining whether the applicant is accepted or not.

原帖由 kc_united 於 09-12-7 10:55 發表
我真的不太明白. 為什麼我呀囡沒一間kowloon tong 幼稚園收?  報了 kv, sc, soka, 我用全軍覆末形容, 最貼切!

我同先生都是專業人仕(正正是中產), interview 前實地觀察,  了解學校.  interview 時答話得體大方. 不 ...

[ 本帖最後由 clara1477 於 09-12-7 12:46 編輯 ]

cwcutecute

From my past experience (both my own case and my friends' cases), apart from parents' occupation and kid's performance, SC & KV will also consider whether the parents were graduated from famous local primary school. This is not difficult to understand as this will increase their acceptance rates of their students to enter those famous local primary school.

However, if the kid is really outstanding/smart, SC & KV will also take him/her disregard their parents' education background. Afterall, SC & KV has to take 600-800 students each year.

kc_united

是不是報這間, 學費貴唔貴?  http://www.york.edu.hk

NICOLE123

原帖由 kc_united 於 09-12-7 13:00 發表
是不是報這間, 學費貴唔貴?  http://www.york.edu.hk

係呢間
不過貴....我個人覺得付擔到既話 佢既貴係值得既

share123

原帖由 Bert 於 09-12-7 11:14 發表
Moreover, I think there are far more applications for SC this year.   Last year, they completed their interview in 2 days, but this year they require 3 days to complete all the interviews.

It's 4 days.

share123

原帖由 kc_united 於 09-12-7 13:00 發表
是不是報這間, 學費貴唔貴?  http://www.york.edu.hk

學費不算貴,但要加埋課外活動d錢,例如學cambridge英文同埋咩數學,一個月要5,6K

qqchiu

只因為2007太多金豬and 學位太小!

我只覺得, 每一間學校收生都有佢地既準則, 既然我地唔知個準則, 做父母既盡佐力 (小朋友都係), 都唔須要再去問點解!
有好多野都係整定既, 如果盡佐力就算la, 你點知將來個囡條路會差過由KV/ SC讀起呢?
收reject letter當然令人失望,但呢個都係一個學習既機會, 學識面對失敗都係一個重要既課程…無論係大人或者小朋友....前路漫漫, 我覺得個mind-set最重要Cheers up!

原帖由 kc_united 於 09-12-7 10:55 發表
我真的不太明白. 為什麼我呀囡沒一間kowloon tong 幼稚園收?  報了 kv, sc, soka, 我用全軍覆末形容, 最貼切!

我同先生都是專業人仕(正正是中產), interview 前實地觀察,  了解學校.  interview 時答話得體大方. 不 ...

kc_united

yes very expensive! and only p.m. class left.  the school fee for 09/10 is $3000 per month.   the coming 10/11 will be raised to $3600 (news from bk some parents).  After including all costs, the fee will be around 5-6k at least.  mmm.......... seem out of my budget a bit......

mimi818

Being a teacher myself, I think the general impression mark would be given by the sensible presentation skills of parents, manner, the way you nuture kids, and somehow the appearance of both parents and children.  Perhaps my elder son now studying in La Salle P.1 and my husband was a KV graduate do contribute to the success of my twins got admitted to KV.  Apart from these, I can recall that we had a nice and relaxed chat and I took some initiative to express more  ( but didn't overtalk ).
Sincere smile and be natural would also make the performance impressed.

jeremyphlam

原帖由 cwcutecute 於 09-12-7 12:50 發表
From my past experience (both my own case and my friends' cases), apart from parents' occupation and kid's performance, SC & KV will also consider whether the parents were graduated from famous local  ...

我諗冇關係，KV直頭唔問父母背景，SC雖然要填，但我呢D係天台中小學畢業的父母個小朋友咪照收。

fc926

不如你試下學之園(凱帆)即插PN下午班,唔好等下年K1,我之前因校車問題想即刻轉PN班,打去學之園,老師同我講左成半個鐘碎我讀下午班,最後我都未應承,她就寄左份acceptance letter兼註冊表格俾我,我相信如果現在讀PN,下年可以繼續讀K1機會好大.學之園D程度都唔錯駕,雖然我都係校車唔到我家而無轉去.