有冇小一細仔媽媽可以分享下?

馬媽媽

Dear ming2,

You are piano teacher and must know very much about music.

To be honest (please forgive me if I say something bad), if the children (not your daughters) no 音樂天份, why they have to spend 50% of their time in music. Is it really good to them? Actually, I don't believe in what the principal said. If the children no 音樂天份 or just treat music as a good hobby, why they have to spend 50% of their school life in music while giving up other valuable and interesting things.

Music at higher level (university or above or professional musician) must  有音樂天份 and just haing interest is not enough. And music path is quite a lonely one at the professional stage and not as funny as the initial stage. Require a lot of practices, practices, practices etc. and never become prefect. Very very few people can become musician.

If one wishes to be a music teahcer only after studying in ICQM or will probably treat music as hobby only after grow up, one must have to think carefully before going to the school while there are other wider and happier roads.

That is my personal opinions.

原帖由 ming2 於 08-10-24 10:46 發表


其實我真係冇諗過佢地係咪特別有咩音樂天份,而要送佢地去APA度讀,只係覺得想搵一間開心,又純品0既學校俾佢地讀架咋....因為宜家基本上間間學校都要學音樂/器樂,咁不如全面少少係學校學埋,咁返到屋企可以有更多0既 ...

[ 本帖最後由 馬媽媽 於 08-10-24 15:24 編輯 ]

SuperSmallTwins

原帖由 kimberleych 於 08-10-21 10:33 發表
放心喇，無問題架．我個寶寶都係聖誕出世，初初我都好擔心，仲攪到自己好緊張，脾氣又差．．．．．．．．

後來，完來小朋友係會應付到架．家下升小三喇．乜都自己攪掂（包括功課／黙書／測驗），同其他小朋友完全無分別． ...

我小朋友都是聖誕出世, 但目前是K1, 请问在考小1时你认为与其他的小朋友有否分别?

馬媽媽

Dear ming2,

Thank you for your sharing.

Concerning the information of " 雖然ICQM 0既音樂科係好似主科咁重要,但又未至於話係放左50% 0既時間係音樂上0既...只係一星期八堂0既音樂堂,同中英數主科0既課堂係有同樣0既比重姐...

再者,校長都話,佢地完成左中學之後,一樣可以係大學選修其他科目去讀,唔係得音樂一科可以揀,所以我覺得都唔需要太擔心佢地條路係咪窄左lor...", I think time will tell us the reality and truth, especially for those in Hong Kong.

I hope the school will give you a clearer picture of how many students can enter the universities.

原帖由 ming2 於 08-10-24 23:16 發表
馬媽媽

大家交流,我唔會有咩介懷0既...

其實我個人認為每一樣野都唔係只得"有"同"冇"兩種答案0既...唔係每一個有音樂天份0既人都會鐘意音樂,或者一定要鐘意去做音樂家,而喜歡音樂0既人亦未必一定係有音樂0 ...