若４間私小都收, 點樣選擇好呢? - 小一選校

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1489

21^#

發表於 07-10-18 13:54 |只看該作者

Dear TomDog,

I am sorry if I have misunderstood you. All along I am saying all this targeting to those parents who are already or planning to hold more than 3 places at any 1 time, I definitely will do the same as you in your example.
I have a relative, her son is very smart and got accepted by most schools, the parents held more than 6 places for their son, I asked why didn't she give up some places for others, guess what she said? She said, I have paid the deposits and I have the right to hold the places until last minutes, it's too bad other parents didn't train up their kids for better performance at interviews...........life is like that. I guess she also likes to brag about how many offers her son got........I avoided talking to her ever since!

Gwan

原文章由 TomDog 於 07-10-18 13:04 硐表

Gwan,
我想你有點誤解我的意思. 我試試舉個例子:
1. 我個人原則是at any given time, I'm going to hold 1 seat only.
2. 我報了5間學校, 假設全部都入waiting list(很可能, 是不是?).
3. 假設到12月, 只有scho ...

leesasa

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	125

22^#

發表於 07-10-18 14:04 |只看該作者

If I were u, I will choose between GHS andSFA. If your girl is admmitted by all, she must be very smart. Let her go to the higher level school .

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-17 22:40 硐表
GHS = 德望學校 Good Hope School

APS=九龍塘宣道小學 Alliance Primary School

KTA= 九龍塘學校 Kowloon Tong School

SFA=聖方濟各英文小學St. Francis Of Assisi's English Primary School

...

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	123

23^#

發表於 07-10-18 15:52 |只看該作者

I 'll never say my girl is smart even she is admmitted by
all school that we applied.
The reason that I write this topic is getting more comment/ informations about those schools. So that I can choose a right school to my girl without holding some seats for a long time.

原文章由 leesasa 於 07-10-18 14:04 硐表
If I were u, I will choose between GHS andSFA. If your girl is admmitted by all, she must be very smart. Let her go to the higher level school .

fyeung

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2436

24^#

發表於 07-10-20 19:04 |只看該作者

Childhood,

我囡囡今年讀K2,我開始搜集小一資料,我想報的學校,跟你的差不多,除了SFA我沒有打算幫囡囡報.

GHS - 英文好,有中學,不過老師略欠愛心,而且之前BK有媽咪post過此學校壓力大,學生要睇心理醫生
APS - 沒有中學,注重音樂,升中派位不錯
KTS - 沒有中學,有資優班,很多人報
SFA - 沒有中學,有資優班,英文好,壓力大,有聽過插班入DGJS的例子

我的資料不多,希望可以幫到你!

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-16 22:21 硐表
幫個囡囡報咗 DGJS, GHS, APS, KTS, SFA 等私小, 一個假設性的問題: 若真係全部都收她(當然首選DGJS, 但我冇想過會咁好彩), 咁4間學校依次序應該點排名呢? 可否比意見 .其實4間都各有所長, 我自己4間都鍾意.
小女 ...

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	123

25^#

發表於 07-10-20 22:31 |只看該作者

原文章由 fyeung 於 07-10-20 19:04 硐表
Childhood,

我囡囡今年讀K2,我開始搜集小一資料,我想報的學校,跟你的差不多,除了SFA我沒有打算幫囡囡報.

GHS - 英文好,有中學,不過,而且之前BK有媽咪post過此學校壓力大,學生要睇心理醫生
APS - 沒有 ...

Thank you fyeung.
可否講下為何沒有打算報SFA呀?
其實我都係屬意APS, KTS or SFA. 就後先到GHS.

先講GHS, 為一吸引是有中學, 重要係band 1名校中學, 但是如你所講, GHS老師略欠愛心, 校規極嚴. 早前去GHS Interview, 家長要填問卷, 其中一條問你如何教導/協助女兒守校規. Interview當日亦見有位老師當眾責駡一位"她認為"不守規的女仔, 那老師態度似懲教署職員.相信GHS的學生是在高壓政策下,規規矩矩.真係唔想小女在如始環境下長大.規矩當然要守, 但小孩是要教導, 唔係用高壓就可以

fyeung

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2436

26^#

發表於 07-10-20 23:18 |只看該作者

Childhood,

GHS interview架事,我都見有好多家長有發表意見.

我舊同事架小朋友係SFA入面讀,課程好催谷,多功課,我囡囡自問唔係可以坐定定集中精神不停做功課個種,我唔想到時難為左佢,更加難為左自己.

雖然有家長話GHS都多功課,有10幾樣

不過,佢地有中學,唔似SFA咁一定要谷好成績升中.

咁你大抽獎填邊間?

以上只是我得知的小小資料,希望有媽咪可以比多d意見!

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-20 22:31 硐表

Thank you fyeung.
可否講下為何沒有打算報SFA呀?
其實我都係屬意APS, KTS or SFA. 就後先到GHS.

先講GHS, 為一吸引是有中學, 重要係band 1名校中學, 但是如你所講, GHS老師略欠愛心, 校規極嚴. 早前去GHS Interv ...

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	123

27^#

發表於 07-10-20 23:25 |只看該作者

原文章由 fyeung 於 07-10-20 23:18 硐表
Childhood,

GHS interview架事,我都見有好多家長有發表意見.

我舊同事架小朋友係SFA入面讀,課程好催谷,多功課,我囡囡自問唔係可以坐定定集中精神不停做功課個種,我唔想到時難為左佢,更加難為左自己.

雖然有家長話 ...

大抽獎報邊間真係末決定

, 等呢一兩個月私校結果再算.

martie

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2274

28^#

發表於 07-10-21 18:08 |只看該作者

It is always good to prepared for the best.　ｉＡＭ　ＡＬＩＴＴＬＥ　ＰＥＳＳＩＭＩＳＴＩＣ　　ＡＮＤ　　ＷＯＵＬＤ　ＡＬＳＯ　　ＡＤＶＩＳＥ　ＹＯＵ　ＴＯ　　ＰＲＥＰＡＲＥ　　ＦＯＲ　　ＴＨＥ　ＷＯＲＳＴ　ｉｅ　JUST WAITING FOR THE LUCKY DRAW.

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-16 22:21 硐表
幫個囡囡報咗 DGJS, GHS, APS, KTS, SFA 等私小, 一個假設性的問題: 若真係全部都收她(當然首選DGJS, 但我冇想過會咁好彩), 咁4間學校依次序應該點排名呢? 可否比意見 .其實4間都各有所長, 我自己4間都鍾意.
小女 ...

fyeung

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2436

29^#

發表於 07-10-21 22:11 |只看該作者

Childhood,

i.c.
咁真光及民生又點睇?
有中學架.到時唔使煩升中.

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-20 23:25 硐表

大抽獎報邊間真係末決定 , 等呢一兩個月私校結果再算.

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	123

30^#

發表於 07-10-21 23:13 |只看該作者

原文章由 fyeung 於 07-10-21 22:11 硐表
Childhood,

i.c.
咁真光及民生又點睇?
有中學架.到時唔使煩升中.

民生口脾一般, 真光就唔係咁鍾意,我有個朋友她自己在真光畢業, 但她卻沒有送她的囡囡入讀真光. 她說真光在學術或課外活動等都係一般般.
有中學或一條龍對我來講並不是最重要, 找到間合適的才重要.

GoodOldMum

洋房

Rank: 2


	100

31^#

發表於 07-10-21 23:58 |只看該作者

I totally agree with you. Let's take my son as an example, my son has been admitted by ICQM and we paid the deposit fee of HK$1,000. One month later, my son was also admitted by the GT College. After receiving the GT offer, I immediately wrote a letter to the Principal of ICQM to withdraw from their offer hoping the reserved seat could be released to other talented child. I understand that waiting is really very annoying.

[quote]原文章由 gwan 於 07-10-18 13:54 硐表

I have a relative, her son is very smart and got accepted by most schools, the parents held more than 6 places for their son, I asked why didn't she give up some places for others, guess what she said? She said, I have paid the deposits and I have the right to hold the places until last minutes, it's too bad other parents didn't train up their kids for better performance at interviews...........life is like that. I guess she also likes to brag about how many offers her son got........I avoided talking to her ever since!

gwan

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1489

32^#

發表於 07-10-22 08:26 |只看該作者

GoodOldMum,

I am sure those parents who want their kids to get into ICQM would appreciate your act greatly. It just happens I have 2 friends who are waiting for seats from ICQM, let me say thank you to you on behalf of them!!

gwan

原文章由 GoodOldMum 於 07-10-21 23:58 硐表
I totally agree with you. Let's take my son as an example, my son has been admitted by ICQM and we paid the deposit fee of HK$1,000. One month later, my son was also admitted by the GT College. Af ...