- 在線時間
- 5470 小時
- 最後登錄
- 24-9-20
- 國民生產力
- 66
- 附加生產力
- 85747
- 貢獻生產力
- 0
- 註冊時間
- 06-10-23
- 閱讀權限
- 10
- 帖子
- 29233
- 主題
- 286
- 精華
- 3
- 積分
- 115046
- UID
- 107125
|
原帖由 ChiChiPaPa 於 11-6-1 05:22 發表
ANChan59,
謝謝你分享這文章。你可以再找多些研究文章看。基本上,你會發覺BFLPE是存在的,當然每項研究都有侷限,你可提出質疑。
EviePa 分享的多是寶貴的自身經驗,而我較信研究和數據,因此很多時都和他有不同的看法,今次 ...
ChiChiPaPa
BFLPE is a very interesting effect, I searched a few articles immediately and just shared one with other parents. I guess some parents may want to know the details of those researches and not just Prof Hau's laymanised version & examples.
The BFLPE does exist in certain conditions, I don't query about it. In most researches has the limitations and assumptions, like base on PISA, or gifted students..... Example from Prof Hau, both students are 80, if "BF" score 72 in a SP 70, the "SF" only 80 in BP 85...... BFLPE also exist????? How about realty??? How to define BF/MF/SF, BP/MP/SP???? Hau's example is too causal to explain a complicated scenario.
Of course, everyone can share his/her views here, I appreciate eviepa's sharing, but I hesitate to share on this topic. The rationale is my son came from CMI primary school, studies in EMI secondary school, I can't say EMI better than CMI, it's political incorrect/jump into conclusion to say this in BK........He is a medium size fish in a big pond in HK, may be a medium pond compared with Harrow . I can't stop other parents, base on single sample to compare CMI vs EMI and draw the conclusion as per the topic title. *** Deleted ***
Furthermore, I may share more of my view once my son finish the secondary school and get into university. It's a gentlemen agreement between my son and I, as some of his friends and parents monitor my posts.
This sub-forum is very interesting, most posters are web-pals for years or have certain characters. Always teased each other in the forum just like old friends. It's not my style yet, I may need some breakthrough.
*******************************************
Before ending, just share a conversation between my son and I in G8 after receiving the report card....
"Hey, you dropped so many ranks in the 2nd examination, how can you survive in HKDSE? How can you get into university?......."
"Dad, take it easy, I am in the middle rank of the form and good enough to get good grades in HKCEE now, no problem in HKDSE. Which university and which program is the key....."
"Dad, do you remember I scored more than 75 in Ming Pao's HKCEE English paper when I was in P4.......... Why you worry about my English standard?"
In G9, he bounced back 50+ ranks and opened up all options for himself - pure science or mixed science streams and IB..... Happy medium to big fish in a medium pond.........
************************************
What's the reflection for me? Expectation Gaps and Expectation Management........
ANChan59
[ 本帖最後由 ANChan59 於 11-6-1 15:51 編輯 ] |
|