用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 小學雜談 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?
查看: 5740|回覆: 28
go

放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢? [複製鏈接]

Rank: 2


53
1#
發表於 06-12-4 17:28 |只看該作者

放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

各媽咪,
比D意見呀? 選St'Paul or MM好呢? St'Paul是一間好學校, MM又是. 有冇人和我一樣有此情形呢?大家分享一下呀?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2155
2#
發表於 06-12-4 17:41 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

If money is not a big concern, pick St. Paul's.
Govt Subsidized schools are on the downturn after losing the right to choose students.
I just sent letter to St. Paul's convent for my girl and the principal replied that there is no vacancy at this moment.  Don't give up such a good school.

Rank: 2


53
3#
發表於 06-12-4 18:12 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

我都明白這個問題, 但不知這兩間小學, 上中學那間會好D呢?
大家都是英小, (比錢的問題不計在內的話) 那間英文程度出來會好些? 我自知St'Paul一定是收回自己幼稚園, 所以覺得如放棄, 實在有點可惜.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2155
4#
發表於 06-12-4 18:30 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

previous discussion

Rank: 5Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


1869
5#
發表於 06-12-4 23:12 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

Dear godbestyou03,

I was a St Paul's Convent School graduate back in the 80's. Being a Paulinian, I don't see why you have to give up such a good school to MPS. SPCS trained us in many ways including leadership, self-confidence, language ability, literature appreciation, independence of mind, logical thinking and creativity. I am so proud to be a Paulinian.

Despite all the fame and popularity of MPS gained among parents and the general public, I have never put a single thought to apply the school for my daughter. I choose St Paul's Primary Catholic School (Happy Valley) in the Primary One Allocation System and luckily we are being accepted in the first round. This is one of the best thing that could happen to me.

No question about it. Stay in SPCS and let your little one be a proud Paulinian.

YX   

Rank: 4


557
6#
發表於 06-12-5 00:15 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

真的碼?據我所知SPC並不是100%收返晒d幼稚園學生啊!

godbestyou03 寫道:
我自知St'Paul一定是收回自己幼稚園, 所以覺得如放棄, 實在有點可惜.
世上只有媽媽好,我就係一個好媽媽啊 :)

Rank: 2


79
7#
發表於 06-12-5 07:33 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

做咩呢輪咁多人問差唔多既問題既?係唔係睇完有綫電視個"點解呢間係名校"節目呢?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4747
8#
發表於 06-12-5 08:07 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

YongXin 寫道:
Dear godbestyou03,

I was a St Paul's Convent School graduate back in the 80's. Being a Paulinian, I don't see why you have to give up such a good school to MPS. SPCS trained us in many ways including leadership, self-confidence, language ability, literature appreciation, independence of mind, logical thinking and creativity. I am so proud to be a Paulinian.

Despite all the fame and popularity of MPS gained among parents and the general public, I have never put a single thought to apply the school for my daughter. I choose St Paul's Primary Catholic School (Happy Valley) in the Primary One Allocation System and luckily we are being accepted in the first round. This is one of the best thing that could happen to me.

No question about it. Stay in SPCS and let your little one be a proud Paulinian.
YX   


YX,  

But St. Paul's Primary Catholic School is a different school from St. Paul Convent, right?  Why don't you send your kid back to St. Paul Convent Primary then?

Rank: 3Rank: 3


373
9#
發表於 06-12-5 10:06 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

I heard that SPC/SPC parents decided not to participate in the secondary school central allocation. SPC does not need to submit the mark to EMB.

Do SPC students need to take 小三評估,  小六評估 and 中一編班試?

Rank: 1


5
10#
發表於 06-12-5 10:38 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

godbestyou03 寫道:
各媽咪,
比D意見呀? 選St'Paul or MM好呢? St'Paul是一間好學校, MM又是. 有冇人和我一樣有此情形呢?大家分享一下呀?


無話值唔值,價值觀人人唔同.

其實每間學校都有人讚有人彈,有好老師,亦有誤人子弟的老師,校規有人覺應該,亦有人覺不近人情.

例子:-

老師不與家長溝通:正面認為 no news is good news, OK wor;負面感覺這是欠缺溝通.

午饍時間不準送飯盒:正面認為可以訓練小朋友獨立,不驕縱;負面感覺這是太不近人情.

冬天無論任何溫度都不準穿長褲:正面認為可鍛鍊身體;負面感覺這是太不近人情.

參加課外活動有分加:正面認為可鼓勵小朋友多參與不同活動,多元發展;負面認為製造不必要的競爭,功利主義.

所以一個銅板兩面睇,點睇都有好有壞.

我個人意見選校應基於以下因素來考慮:-

1)經濟能力
2)家庭�父母的支援能力(學歷,時間,耐性,愛心)
3)父母對學業的要求
4)英小�中小�一條龍
5)活動教學�傳統教學
6)學校背景
7)學校教學方針�政策
8)小朋友個性
9)交通

Rank: 5Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


1869
11#
發表於 06-12-5 10:43 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

Dear WYmom,

因為我送了女女入我的母校寶血幼稚園讀書(我中學才讀SPCS), 讓她跟我一樣度過愉快又充實的幼稚園生活. 而SPCS小學只收自己的幼稚園生. SPCS是私立, SPPCS是津貼, 報讀的時間和程序都不同.

我當然知道SPCS和SPPCS是两間不同的學校, 但两間都是Sisters of St Paul de Chartres屬下辦的學校, 我對她們辦學非常有信心, 也很有歸屬感.

不時見BK家長在比較學校, 其實, 與期收集一大堆主觀的意見, 我覺得更有意思是去認真研究學校的資料, 再衡量是否適合自己子女, 自己的家庭和對子女的期望. 家長自己的判斷力和直覺就自然會帶領妳作出最佳的決定.

YX



But St. Paul's Primary Catholic School is a different school from St. Paul Convent, right?  Why don't you send your kid back to St. Paul Convent Primary then?

Rank: 3Rank: 3


142
12#
發表於 06-12-5 10:50 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

Hi Yongxin,
Was the class size of SPC also that big in the 80's? I am very glad that my girl has the chance to study at SPC primary now, and she is really enjoying her study there. But my concern is that the class size is 40, sometimes 42-44. It is really quite a big number of students comparing to most other private or DSS schools. Do you think it will affect teaching quality?

Rank: 5Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


2960
13#
發表於 06-12-5 12:07 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

Hi, all

如無意外, 我的小朋友都可以直上spc的.  其實一早己諗好, 若spc真係收番個女(一日未收到cofirmation letter一日都唔敢講到咁實), 我大抽獎就一定唔會抽marymount, 因為在我來說, 兩間學校真係差不多.  既然差不多, 那當然留在spc啦, 常常也聽到人說在scp上學壓力無咁大, 在marymount壓力大很多.  既然兩間學校學術方面都唔差得好多, 那為何不選一間讀得開心d, 輕鬆d既給個女呢? 況且若在sp的kinder或nursary讀緊的都知道, 小朋友真係讀得好開心(亞女以前也在其他學校讀過, 但係反應係呢度佢開心好多, 佢會叫我交學費, 因為佢怕我唔交學費佢會無得番呢間學校), 老師也很好, 學校又多野玩(水池, 沙池等), 每天得很少功課. 基於學校各方面都照顧周到, 所以我好有信心她們的小學, 中學都一樣係咁好, 孩子也可以讀得好開心.  

除非另一間學校係好明顯比spc好的才會考慮, 否則....唔會轉了.  又或者spc真係唔收番先會考慮mm.

**加上sp的校服係好靚的嘛!! 著左靚校服, 人都開心d啦.

Rank: 4


660
14#
發表於 06-12-5 15:09 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

如果不是就讀聖保祿的幼稚園,同時受兩所小學取錄的機會很低很低(即是就讀聖保祿的幼稚園,亦不是高得多).所以聖保祿和瑪利曼之選擇,很大程度取決於你的囡囡進了那一家幼稚園,亦可以說是會不會入讀聖保祿的幼稚園.

雖然有人棄聖保祿選瑪利曼,但不能用有多"值得"來衡量.小朋友學習取向各有不同,最重要的是,父母作為最了解自己小朋友的人,應她在能力範圍內給予最適合她的教育.

至於兩所小學比較,不妨參考BoBoCute所指的先前的討論.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


373
15#
發表於 06-12-5 15:55 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

bk2005 寫道:
I heard that SPC/SPC parents decided not to participate in the secondary school central allocation. SPC does not need to submit the mark to EMB.

Do SPC students need to take 小三評估,  小六評估 and 中一編班試?


Can anyone answer my question? Thanks.

Rank: 5Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


1869
16#
發表於 06-12-5 15:58 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

Dear michellemi,

那時SPCS form 1的class size都有成40人, 一路讀上去form 3就開始有人走去外國讀書, 但都有成30多40人. 全校又分幾個House, 每班都有相約數量的House members, 多D人很好玩的.

我覺得不同幼稚園階段, 樣樣要貼身照顧; 到小學的學習要有自覺性, 大班不是問題.

Rank: 2


33
17#
發表於 06-12-5 21:01 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

I totally agree with you.  I would not participant in 大抽獎 and decide to stay in SPC.

AndyRain 寫道:
Hi, all

如無意外, 我的小朋友都可以直上spc的.  其實一早己諗好, 若spc真係收番個女(一日未收到cofirmation letter一日都唔敢講到咁實), 我大抽獎就一定唔會抽marymount, 因為在我來說, 兩間學校真係差不多.  既然差不多, 那當然留在spc啦, 常常也聽到人說在scp上學壓力無咁大, 在marymount壓力大很多.  既然兩間學校學術方面都唔差得好多, 那為何不選一間讀得開心d, 輕鬆d既給個女呢? 況且若在sp的kinder或nursary讀緊的都知道, 小朋友真係讀得好開心(亞女以前也在其他學校讀過, 但係反應係呢度佢開心好多, 佢會叫我交學費, 因為佢怕我唔交學費佢會無得番呢間學校), 老師也很好, 學校又多野玩(水池, 沙池等), 每天得很少功課. 基於學校各方面都照顧周到, 所以我好有信心她們的小學, 中學都一樣係咁好, 孩子也可以讀得好開心.  

除非另一間學校係好明顯比spc好的才會考慮, 否則....唔會轉了.  又或者spc真係唔收番先會考慮mm.

**加上sp的校服係好靚的嘛!! 著左靚校服, 人都開心d啦.

Rank: 2


79
18#
發表於 06-12-5 23:28 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

AndyRain,

MM D學生好大壓力咩?未聽過喎!之前D人話個個都讀得好HAPPY.你聽邊個講架?

Rank: 2


38
19#
發表於 06-12-5 23:44 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

看看校園的環境、設施。
看看學生的特質、性格,可能會有所啓發。

Rank: 2


79
20#
發表於 06-12-6 00:26 |只看該作者

Re: 放棄S'paul Convent 選Marymount值唔值得呢?

仲可以係OPEN DAY去睇睇,聽講MM今年有八十周年活動.

54830891 寫道:
看看校園的環境、設施。
看看學生的特質、性格,可能會有所啓發。
‹ 上一主題|下一主題
返回列表
發新帖