LS and IS - Excellent analysis - 教育中的文化元素 - 程介明

samsam123321

佢話名校中有人英文好好而暗示要英文好都唔使讀國際學校。但，我自己觀察，只有部分極名校中的極少數部分人能去到英文native.名女校會好d。但讀is 的學生好有機會將來會走。達唔到native 英文對佢地將來回"國"會有影響。

Artie

simonwan 發表於 16-2-1 01:17

重點是軟性推銷佢有份搞的那家好重視中文但類似國際學校的貴貴私校。

---

samsam123321

del.....

oooray

原帖由 cathygum 於 16-01-31 發表
感覺不是寫給香港的家長看的，新香港人家長可能覺得文中的內容很有用。



  ...

1. 我覺得文章是寫給大眾睇，而不是我等已是國際學校的小眾家長看的;

2. 作者根本不熟悉國際學校，只是間接從接觸的家長中道聽途說回來。等同說來一次school tour,便熟悉國際學校般兒戲;

一句"國際學校與本地學校的最顯著的分別是語言"已完全露了底。如果以此為文章開端，餘下的根本不用再看下去。

HKTHK

回覆 NoahArk 的帖子

I don't think most parents get the point he is trying to make. Feels like 對牛彈琴

FattyDaddy

HKTHK 發表於 16-2-1 14:26
I don't think most parents get the point he is trying to make. Feels like 對牛彈琴 ...

Not getting the point after a garden tour is nothing unusual, people see different things even if it is the same garden, some even see the last article as a subtle advertisement for a particular school, but suggesting those who don't appreciate this Mr Ching are like cows is unlike your usual courteous self.

What if someone says those who appreciate Mr Ching are like flies drawn to manure? I don't think that would be well accepted either :)

samsam123321

DreamKid 發表於 16-1-31 15:18
以為什麼新菜式，原來系餸頭餸尾炒一碟

點解我覺得佢的論點咁似ek 裏的論點？唔通佢都有上？

紅紅

一篇好文章係要令讀者一睇就明，如果只有子女讀Princeton, Cambridge的家長先睇得明固中深意，作者應該要檢討吓自己的寫作技巧和表達能力。如果讀者是一群牛，就要寫得牛都睇得明囉！

HKTHK

回覆 FattyDaddy 的帖子

That is already my nice way of putting it!

yyevita

I understand that the artical is try to say that  education is not an independent thing, it is a reflect of the whole culture which may be inherited and developed for hundreds of years.  If you choose an international school, not just because they do not test kids everyday, but should try to understand and support the culture.  Besides, it is no way to say one culture is better than the other.  

nintendo

oooray 發表於 16-2-1 13:41
1. 我覺得文章是寫給大眾睇，而不是我等已是國際學校的小眾家長看的;

2. 作者根本不熟悉國際學校，只是間 ...

應該係寫比果 D，好精明咁冇選擇 "一般 IS"，而選擇了 "一所新開的學校" 的家長睇。
睇完，即刻覺得自我感覺良好。
唔怪得某一些網友咁熱心咁撐啦。
關公最近真係好忙喎。

yyevita

回覆 Wisleyli 的帖子

Yes， it is not appropriate in some places such as Hong Kong, but not as ugly as it seems to be in other situations.  Besides, it is not the culture the article is about.  

oooray

原帖由 nintendo 於 16-02-01 發表
應該係寫比果 D，好精明咁冇選擇 "一般 IS"，而選擇了 "一所新開的學校"  的家長睇。
睇完，即刻覺得自 ...

係呀!關公晚晚有show睇。但舞關刀呢家，睇得多都悶，不自量力仲好易劈親自己。

shadeslayer

奇實係標題的錯。

原文是普通專欄文章，樓主加上 "LS and IS - Excellent analysis"，大家的期望立即大升。期望高，自然易失望。

italiano

我又覺得篇文章ok喎, 可能正如大家話齋, 係我本身無知