Finally 全軍覆末 @.@

ck07hk

其實講起上黎我個女咪又係全軍覆沒.. 不過我個人就好感激York幼稚園, 佢係我第一間in既幼稚園, 佢地好快就收左我個女, 我好感激佢地無嫌我個女係07年12月B, 之後我都有周圍同呀女in, 全部Rejected.  咁我都明既, 有得選擇梗係柬哂大B先, 如果無York, 我諗我會好旁惶, 人人都話佢地好commercial, 但係我唔介意, 反而我真係好感恩佢地肯收我個女, 希望呀女讀得開心啦! 所以你都唔好太介意!

smartmatt

原帖由 kc_united 於 09-12-7 10:55 發表
我真的不太明白. 為什麼我呀囡沒一間kowloon tong 幼稚園收?  報了 kv, sc, soka, 我用全軍覆末形容, 最貼切!

我同先生都是專業人仕(正正是中產), interview 前實地觀察,  了解學校.  interview 時答話得體大方. 不 ...

As already mentioned, the number of applicants are so high (KV, SC 6-7000) this year the odds are less then 10:1 for getting a place.   We even couldn't get an app form from Cannon as there were so many inquiries.  Many many smart kids will be rejected simply due to the odds.  

Many places at York will be released after the reservations at KV and SC are done as I think most parents like me will have York (SN, etc.) as backup.  Hence, you can try York and other kgs again end of the month or early next year as this year there is the addition of GH kg as some parents will reject KV and SC.

In a normal year doing all the required activities would probably get you a place, but this year the school will want something distinguishing from the kids.  Performance is the key.   Sure, some kids without perfect performance will get a place as I think the teachers are overwhelmed with the numbers.  

Luckily, our boy got offer from KV - our first choice.     One battle over, onwards to 3 years time when the we battle again...

York does come across as very commercial but it has set its self the target of getting your kids into the famous P1 schools - message from the parents pre-interview talk.   Hence, lots of ECA to get certs, etc.   My friend kid is very happy attending the KG and ECA are truly optional.

pauljr

我覺得早/遲交表都有d影响。

cwcutecute

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 09-12-7 14:14 發表


我諗冇關係，KV直頭唔問父母背景，SC雖然要填，但我呢D係天台中小學畢業的父母個小朋友咪照收。

Congratulations! I am sure your kid must be very outstanding during the interview.

CP916

我覺得屋企地址都好大影响。收嘅好多都住Kln Tong, Ho Man Tin.....

chan328

From my own experience, if you really liked those schools, a follow up letter at this moment is very important.  It may give you some surprises later on.

原帖由 kc_united 於 09-12-7 10:55 發表
我真的不太明白. 為什麼我呀囡沒一間kowloon tong 幼稚園收?  報了 kv, sc, soka, 我用全軍覆末形容, 最貼切!

我同先生都是專業人仕(正正是中產), interview 前實地觀察,  了解學校.  interview 時答話得體大方. 不 ...

os2002

仲有協恩,不過記住,收生少,入倒機會就細

http://www.hykg.edu.hk/recruit.php

jean2003

原帖由 kc_united 於 09-12-7 10:55 發表
我真的不太明白. 為什麼我呀囡沒一間kowloon tong 幼稚園收?  報了 kv, sc, soka, 我用全軍覆末形容, 最貼切!

我同先生都是專業人仕(正正是中產), interview 前實地觀察,  了解學校.  interview 時答話得體大方. 不 ...

先講句對不起, 因為以下講既野有d直, hurt到既..先sorry.
你覺得你小朋友表現好? 以下系我朋友o既例子,
原先了解面試6~7分鐘, 都系一般"指定動作", 顏色, 物件...
當日足足in(or"被玩")左約20分鐘..點解?
小朋友自己主動拿起樍木..對住個miss..藍色大綠色細, 紅色長黃色短..仲自己數埋面頂一粒粒個d
miss即刻玩大d, 叫佢去取本書...攞左本教睇鐘o既書. 問系咩..答"時鐘"..打開第一頁...問系咩 答"手錶"...搞下個鐘問幾點.."3點"...叫小朋友自己做十點出離..做埋...
然後要玩餵bb食奶奶...又問bb公仔訓左未..."未"...點解.."覺覺豬要閉眼"...接著..玩煮飯仔...點樣煎腸仔...自己搵鑊,鑊鏟,開火.......最後叫小朋友自己收拾.....小朋友張煮飯仔還煮飯仔擺...bb公仔,奶瓶放番系bb床...

結果系..waiting 都冇.......點解? 矛人知....
媽媽系家庭主婦..爸爸系上市公司某部門o既一哥(Head of Department, GM)..

mianyang_99

原帖由 jean2003 於 09-12-7 16:51 發表

先講句對不起, 因為以下講既野有d直, hurt到既..先sorry.
你覺得你小朋友表現好? 以下系我朋友o既例子,
原先了解面試6~7分鐘, 都系一般"指定動作", 顏色, 物件...
當日足足in(or"被玩")左約20分鐘..點解?
小朋友自 ...

耐人尋味O既結果

jean2003

原帖由 mianyang_99 於 09-12-7 17:41 發表


耐人尋味O既結果

絕對系耐人尋味...有d人或者會懷疑..佢地兩個會唔會好吋嘴呀...我可以肯定..百分百唔系...佢地兩個會唔會學歷唔好呀....爸爸有兩個Master Degree, 其中一個系 distinction, 另一個我唔知, 媽媽系英國某大學畢業...當然呢d野唔會系application form填出離...
又或者會唔會有人講..會唔會小朋友樣衰呀...大佬..in20分鐘, 真系好忙...樣衰既.. 一早叮走左啦...加埋,我記得系咁多..可能當時仲有多d玩(個miss)...
只可以講"強中自有強中手"

哈爾濱

係咪就係因為勁過頭, 學校配合唔到, 所以唔收.

原帖由 jean2003 於 09-12-7 16:51 發表

先講句對不起, 因為以下講既野有d直, hurt到既..先sorry.
你覺得你小朋友表現好? 以下系我朋友o既例子,
原先了解面試6~7分鐘, 都系一般"指定動作", 顏色, 物件...
當日足足in(or"被玩")左約20分鐘..點解?
小朋友自 ...

nc2000

如果全部正確無誤, 咁你朋友個仔已經係強中之強la, 仲係waiting? 咁一定有原因! 請問佢in 邊間幼稚園咁強呢? sc ? kv? 可能間幼稚園鐘意d 聽指令學生, 唔係要d 自動波資優既學生!

原帖由 jean2003 於 09-12-7 17:58 發表

絕對系耐人尋味...有d人或者會懷疑..佢地兩個會唔會好吋嘴呀...我可以肯定..百分百唔系...佢地兩個會唔會學歷唔好呀....爸爸有兩個Master Degree, 其中一個系 distinction, 另一個我唔知, 媽媽系英國某大學畢業... ...

my2007

或者有些所谓"名校老师"喜欢中小学学历的家长,大家磁场夹d

appleng

諗諗下, 我兩年前個仔果年收生標準真係明確d wor.(根據BK 既人分享.
今年真係好奇怪, 好似大抽獎咁....

原帖由 哈爾濱 於 09-12-7 18:05 發表
係咪就係因為勁過頭, 學校配合唔到, 所以唔收.

zzbchu

Hi! kc_united, my daughter is now attending 2-3 playgroup in Tutor Time Wow, one of her class teacher is a former teacher of Tsung Tsin Kindergarten, she told me that school consider not only the performance of the child, but also how they `feel' about the parents, are they nice? Are they easy to communicate?  As teachers are the one that communicate with the parents, that seems important to them, as nobody would like to handle difficult parents.

So, there's no need to feel bad as you cannot control the `feelings' of the interviewer.

For me it's just like a job interview, research shows that it's all about impression, nothing to do with ability.  In another word, that's feelings.

澄曜媽媽

我仔仔大仔(3/07), 可惜好怕羞, 令我之前好擔心, 結果幫他報了十間KG, 5間荃灣, 5間九龍塘, 結果竟然喜出望外, 全部收了!!!

他表現不是十分好, 比較passive, in 得最好是kv, 但都要三催四請先開口, in 創價最差, 不理老師, 只in 了1-2分鐘, 見老師好求其咁, 以為不ok, 但竟也收了.

我總結了原因, 應該是我申請的是下午班的原因, 因而避免了激烈的競爭.

qqbabe

原帖由 jean2003 於 09-12-7 16:51 發表

先講句對不起, 因為以下講既野有d直, hurt到既..先sorry.
你覺得你小朋友表現好? 以下系我朋友o既例子,
原先了解面試6~7分鐘, 都系一般"指定動作", 顏色, 物件...
當日足足in(or"被玩")左約20分鐘..點解?
小朋友自 ...

係未覺得小朋友係資優或者神童, 驚自己會教唔掂 請問介唔介意透露係邊間幼稚園?

jean2003

原帖由 nc2000 於 09-12-7 18:14 發表
如果全部正確無誤, 咁你朋友個仔已經係強中之強la, 仲係waiting? 咁一定有原因! 請問佢in 邊間幼稚園咁強呢? sc ? kv? 可能間幼稚園鐘意d 聽指令學生, 唔係要d 自動波資優既學生!
...

如果唔肯聽指領, 就唔會比老師in(玩)足約20分鐘. 仲有, 唔系waiting, 系waiting都矛....

jean2003

原帖由 my2007 於 09-12-7 18:34 發表
或者有些所谓"名校老师"喜欢中小学学历的家长,大家磁场夹d

或者正確..但只可講既系...唔要填學歷, 就算要填, 我個朋友系Fig Boy, 排頭1D都唔差嫁..

Karen2009

原帖由 jean2003 於 09-12-7 22:51 發表

如果唔肯聽指領, 就唔會比老師in(玩)足約20分鐘. 仲有, 唔系waiting, 系waiting都矛....

學校唔收這些天材兒童甘咪直接 reject 唔需要 waiting 囉, 個小朋友甘勁, 應該唔好俾佢係 HK 讀,因為係外國分分鍾可以跳班讀, 唔好浪費佐佢既才華先係囉