st.jo & 華仁

KPB4000

2007年9月入小一有20分，哪間機會高?哪間無咁辛苦?
請給議見。     

TIKTIKMA

哪間機會高?  St Joseph

哪間無咁辛苦? Wah Yan  

KPB4000

咁咪好難下決定？
我想囝囝讀得無咁辛苦，但又想第一輪搞掂。
因為我由小到現在都無抽獎命的，我不想自己的倒運禍及他。

pmamylee

其實st.jo 及 華仁都是傳統小學,要上返自己中學,都是要谷成績的,所以小朋友都是要讀得辛苦的.
但st.jo 上中學位少,所以競爭較大.

KPB4000

中學太遙遠了，我都唔敢諗住......   

pmamylee

如果唔諗中學,你有20分,第一輪st. jo的機會很大,因舊年我朋友15分在第一輪都可抽到st. jo,始終st. jo位多.
華仁只得30多個位,機會則很微.

KPB4000

其實兩間的程度我諗都是不相白仲，真的是看看自己有否意思賭一場......   
我比較重視德育的培養，男生在港島灣仔、北角和東區可以哪些其他可考慮的呢？     

Lelu

以官津計，區內無出其右。

若小朋友優資，家庭背景適合，有成功考入直資小學機會者，可搏華仁。 我囝去年亦有20分，去年底已被St. Jo收，現搏候補入理想直資小學。

BearMum

Lelu,

唔好意思, 想問下你為何搏候補入理想直資小學, 而要give up st. Jo?  St. Jo is also a well known school!

KPB4000

我都好有興趣知點解？妳現家覺得st. jo有問題？

BearMum

Hi Lelu

I have some more question, would you mind to help:

<<若小朋友優資，家庭背景適合，有成功考入直資小學機會者，可搏華仁>>

would you please advise 為何要優資?  要有what kind of 家庭背景 for 華仁?

因小兒會入讀華仁小學, 但我兒not優資, 而我not有錢人.  是否我兒not suitable to study at 華仁小學?

麟媽媽

華仁同St. Jo 都係津校，
現時派位制度靠分數同大抽獎，
讀邊間幼稚園都無分別。

CHKWAN 寫道:
有無人知讀那間幼稚園入華仁or St. Jo 幾會高d ?

Lelu

There is keen competition in St. Jo Primary for promotion to St. Jo College.  The existing assessment criteria is the academic result.

Such environment will restrict students to develop their all-round talents(多元智能).

Worst still, it is factual that the resource of a subvented school is less than that of a DSS school.  The teacher/student ratio of a class in St. Jo is around 1:40 whilst the ratio of certain DSS schools in primary one/two is around 1:15.

It is an unfair game and a tragedy of the HK education.

Lelu

Hi BearMum,

You misunderstand my point.  My comment on 優資 and 家庭背景 refers to the selection critieria of DSS/private schools.  

Both St. Jo and Wah Yan admit students in accordance with the existing 自行分配 and 統一派位 system.

BearMum 寫道:
Hi Lelu

I have some more question, would you mind to help:

would you please advise 為何要優資?  要有what kind of 家庭背景 for 華仁?

ThanThan

Hi BearMum,

請問你有幾多分?  因出生率高,20分都派唔倒華仁大有人在。我朋友直屬番禺會都唔得。

BearMum

Hi Than than

20分, first round bingo!

ThanThan

Hi BearMum,

Congradulations!  Lucky you!  

But may I ask why you didn't choose St. Jo during the 1st round?  As you may know you will have a better chance to be picked if you choose St. Jo instead of Wah Yan.

KPB4000

CHKWAN 寫道:
有無人知讀那間幼稚園入華仁or St. Jo 幾會高d ?

st.jo 的幼稚園每年都差不多有95-100%直昇的，我囝囝舊年都衰咗。

ThanThan

Hi KPB4000,

請問你舊年報St. Jo時有幾多分在手?  st.jo 的幼稚園每年都差不多有95-100%直昇約佔幾多學位?