港大同學會書院面試

al852

請問有冇媽咪今天收到港大同學會書院電話安排面試?

有朋友收到電話3/3個別面試, 但囡囡收唔到. :cry:

哈姆太郎

According to my daughter, some of her classmates have attended interview yesterday, and some will have their interview on Sat.

momomimi

Hi al852,

Don't be upset.  I feel that the group discussion conducted on Wednesday was too simple.  It's also strange that the discussion was assessed by their F.1 student.(My son told me that teachers just wandered between rooms).   I doubt  the school have already shortlisted the applicants early before.  The group discussion is mere to make parents feeling fair and for their students having an experience of being an interviewer.  Moreover, I don't think they should arrange the 2nd interview in such a hurry.  They should send by mail for the successful applicant for 2nd interview as three envelops have been provided to school in the application.
Good luck.

Wendypykwok

momomimi 寫道:
Hi al852,

Don't be upset.  I feel that the group discussion conducted on Wednesday was too simple.  It's also strange that the discussion was assessed by their F.1 student.(My son told me that teachers just wandered between rooms).   I doubt  the school have already shortlisted the applicants early before.  The group discussion is mere to make parents feeling fair and for their students having an experience of being an interviewer.  Moreover, I don't think they should arrange the 2nd interview in such a hurry.  They should send by mail for the successful applicant for 2nd interview as three envelops have been provided to school in the application.
Good luck.

Me too ! i haven't receive any calls or letter for 2nd interview.

paupauyu

Hi 哈姆太郎,

Same as my son's classmate.

哈姆太郎 寫道:
According to my daughter, some of her classmates have attended interview yesterday, and some will have their interview on Sat.

curious1

Anyone knows how many applicants they received?

Charlotte_mom

舊年中一開左5班, 而家小學部只有3班小六, 應該有幾多位可以收外來生既, 放心   

queen

al852,
你朋友的成績會唔會係特別彪炳? 定係佢的姓氏係 a 字頭果 d 呢? 果日 group in 完都成 7 點, 尋日咁快可以收到通知既?

Wendypykwok

queen 寫道:
al852,
你朋友的成績會唔會係特別彪炳? 定係佢的姓氏係 a 字頭果 d 呢? 果日 group in 完都成 7 點, 尋日咁快可以收到通知既?

我今早打電話問過，回覆話校長下放d 學生 application no. 然後約 2nd interview, 全部都係電話通知。 "未接到電話個d ，即係後備" 呢兩句說話純粹我個人意見, 學校沒有正面回答，如果in 完呢批，有人放棄的話，會繼續約其他 wor ! Good luck !!!

al852

唉, 收唔到電話 :cry: . 亞囡囡比有得interview的同學無論在獎項, 成績及操行好一大截. 一戰定生死, 如果正如momomimi話由F.1學生嚟評分, 咁就有啲唔甘心

Wendypykwok

唔駛灰心，一日都 in 唔到咁多，可能會有第二輪呢。平常心去面對啦 !

al852

Wendypykwok, 謝謝您.
囡囡好鍾意間學校, 希望越大, 失望越大.  今日重要比有interview嗰女同學窒, 放學番嚟知道收唔到電話又好唔開心.

momomimi

al852,

Forget it.  Every school have their own agenda  of selection of students.  Maybe HKUGA is not focus on academic results.  
I don't understand why HKUGA have to start the interview in hurry.  As I know, SPCC, SPC, BPS and MMS will conduct the interview tomorrow also.  If the candidates have to attend either HKUGA or above schools, I bet HKUGA will be given up.  

queen

al852,

我都覺得果日咁樣 in 好似兒戲左少少呢, 我亞女又係好鐘意呢間學校, 所以雖然遠左少少, 我都試下同佢報.

不過唔緊要喇, 你囡囡成績好, 可能仲有下個 round 呢, 又或者入到間更好既都唔定呢.
祝我地大家都好運呀

momomimi

delete

momomimi

我都覺得果日咁樣 in 好似兒戲左少少

This is what I feel too.  The group interview was simply asking 4 questions about the drama that the candidates have watched.  The candidates answered seperately instead of discussing it interactively.  I can't agree such assessment is infomative to determine a candidate's competence.

queen

momomimi

真係唔明佢地攪咩鬼, 搵個中一生黎幫手都有既. 當日玩玩下咁, 真係唔知有咩野表現可言. 好難明白佢地收生既標準.

momomimi 寫道:
我都覺得果日咁樣 in 好似兒戲左少少

This is what I feel too.  The group interview was simply asking 4 questions about the drama that the candidates have watched.  The candidates answered seperately instead of discussing it interactively.  I can't agree such assessment is infomative to determine a candidate's competence.

momomimi

queen,

亞仔當晚向我報告完面試過程後, 我第一個感覺就係學校安排咗一個體驗課程比佢啲學生.
純属個人感覺.如有冒犯HKUGA, 唔好意思

queen

momomimi,

我都諗住算喇,  都好過入左表後無晒消息咁囉, 如果你收到 second in 通知, 記得上黎報告好消息呀.

momomimi 寫道:
queen,

亞仔當晚向我報告完面試過程後, 我第一個感覺就係學校安排咗一個體驗課程比佢啲學生.
純属個人感覺.如有冒犯HKUGA, 唔好意思

  

momomimi

算咯, 就算有2nd in 都唔會去啦. 亞仔都唔在意, 兼且我都失咗信心.