St.Paul Catholic VS Hon Wah

coffee

my daughter is studying at St.Paul Cat p.2 now, both math & chinese subjects are failed on 1st term test. In fact, i am no confident 繼續陪讀.  So, I would like my daughter 插Hon Wah p.1 on Nov 06.  pls comment.

Mrssslui

why need to repeat?

coffee

repeat p.1 可以同其他同學打好lauguage 基礎Mandarin & English then 一齊升上p.2 lor. as hon wah 是新校, 現沒有p.2 班。

Mrssslui

你女女係幾月出生?

coffee

Mar 99.  但係得115cm 高, 好細粒同思想都好baby. 唔睇年齡, d 人估佢讀p.1 jar. 上個月打過去Hon Wah問, 佢話唔mind 我個係大女repeat 多1 年, 仲叫我個女第2日去interview tim. 請問你仔女讀邊間ah???

Mrssslui

咁如果你心儀呢間學校,佢地又冇P.2咁都冇辦法.

麟媽媽

其實係咪必要留班呢？
因為佢2 年班都算大女喎…
我仔98 年尾出世都讀3 年班。
佢測驗唔合格係點解呢？
唔明定係佢唔肯溫習呢？
轉校係咪可以解決到成績問題呢？

coffee

Hi 麟媽媽,
唔知你記唔記得我, 我成年都無上BK la. 但之前就成日問你野ga. 其實d人話我轉校可能係逃避, 但其實係唔想個女讀得咁辛苦同唔想同ah 女傷感情。 佢d成績p.1 時都是61-70分到, 今年雖然常識和英文有進步75-85分, 但中數唔pass ah. 每個星期都要係home 溫習, 因一星期測一科, 仲要4測2考, 我真係唔知頂得幾來? 又傷感情.叫就溫, 唔叫又唔溫.但ah 女又好like返學,話repeat 都要係度讀wor. 成家人都無人贊成轉校, 但又得我一個人教, 請過2個私人補習, 完全唔掂, 淨係同我個女吹水, 又改錯功課.後來請個貴d 成$150個鐘, 但長遠計又唔花算。點算好?

centre

我都覺得要攪清楚唔合格0既原因先,可唔可以同老師傾0下呀,仲有係你囡囡0既睇法係點?

麟媽媽

Coffee,

我記得你，點會唔記得。
其實轉校唔代表唔使讀，一樣要測驗既，
St. Paul’s 好似華仁一樣，一星期先測一科，
係就係好似長命債咁，但一星期測幾科咪仲辛苦。
中/數唔合格，先講數，佢背熟乘數表未？
未既話一定唔得，因為小二開始計乘數，
其餘只係3個位加減數，無幾難，重點要背好乘數表。
中文難攪D，因為唔係讀課文就得既，好多時作句，
都係要識寫D 字先作到，咁唯有教佢作D 直接D 既。
其實，佢中/數錯埋D 咩多呢？要知佢係唔小心？
定係唔明白？又或係唔識寫D 字？對正下藥先得。

我建議你唔好轉校住，睇吓可唔可以攪到亞女先，
因為St. Paul's 有直屬中學，如果轉出去，
無直屬升中你會好頭痛架！
我亞麟少係細仔，小一都係烏sir sir，
而家小三好似突然開左”Hill”咁，
你比多少少時間個女試吓啦。

coffee

Hi 麟媽媽
好surprise ah.你仲記得我, 有種好warm的感覺ah.
summer 時ah 女已經攪掂咗乘數表lar. 數學係衰係d思考題。有得讀過d就無問題, 但時間不足又溫唔哂。中、英dict可以拿A。 平時又唔肯睇書, 所以comprehension, 作文 & 分析完全唔掂。好似一個機械人咁, 有得背就識, 無得背就死得lor. 多數衰唔小心、 應用題、 重組句子、閱讀理解。是但做完就交卷, 趕收工咁。激死我。希望我個女好似你個仔係小三時開”Hill”就好lar. 其實開hill的意思係咪佢地識得care d分數就會拿高分呢?

Mrs.Wong

Hi coffee,

Maybe you can consider allowing your girl repeat P.2.  啟思 can be a good choice.  I know a girl who failed at a traditional girl school is now having a very happy school life at  啟思.

BaBaBlackSheep

Hi coffee
   我個女都係St.Paul 學生,同你好似,教佢好辛苦,英文又唔掂,中文啲重組 子同閱讀理解仲always  交白卷,當時我都想俾佢repeat,但個女要話唔想,所以都市俾佢上P3.雖然依家中文都係唔合格,但都俾P2時進步咗,所以你再諗清楚先決定係咪一定repeat or 轉校,

ngaichuiwa

hello coffee

my daugther was studying in HW P.1,she told me everyday is happy day,the teacher and the princple are very nice,the classes are very small,so made each student can received great deal of individual attention,but this is a new school,are you sure your family will support you?my daugther's class was 15 students,the other class also 16students,l think not much parents dare let their child join HW, because there so many choices in HK side,but l can tell you, we lived in kowloon,and my daugther was graduated form St' catherine's,why l choose HW,because l trust my feeling,and my daugther loves HW very much.l think the school will put the great effort to enhance their reputation.lt not a tradition school,the style same like the aims of st'catherine's,let the child learn in a happy way. l hope see you in HW later, byebye!  

coffee

Hi Mrs. Wong,
many thanks for yr suggestion, may i know 啟思 is at kln side or HK side?? My daughter 補習老師見議我個女讀真光ah. any comment?

coffee

Hi BaBaBlackSheep,
多謝你的回應, 咁你有無同個女打補針ah?  e.g Learning plus 補Eng, 學林中補中文, 學林數補數 or 補習社ah?我個女都係唔肯走ah, 我都唔知點。如果真係大d會好d, 我都想唔走住。因St. Paul Cat 的校風真係好好.

coffee

Hi ngaichuiwa,
i have visited Hoi Wah opening day last sat. Yes, u are right, all teacher & the princple are very nice.  
My hubby likes HW has a good enviroment & new facilities, also he buy the point is no test/exam. My daughter also like HW but she doesn't want to repeat p.1 there. 我唔想迫佢ah, 佢話repeat 都prefer to stay at St.paul ah. my hubby said 讀得咁辛苦過個係我之麻. 叫我唔好咁care d 分數wor. 第日升唔到St. paul 中先算喎. 都唔知d老想mug. :(

kkbbkk

It seems strange that there is so many Hon Wah  message (ALL GOOD) in BK, especially comparison between Hon Wah and other not so relevant and comparable schools such as ST Paul Catholic . St Paul Catholic is so different from Hon Wah that comparison is totally meaningless.

Any hidden motive / agenda?