今年開始~升中，特別死得人多！(求證後更正)

櫺囹桼

學校知唔知道學科測驗結果？
知道左又如何同其他學校比較？
唔比較又如何話你知貴公子/千金banding？
唔話你知banding，你又如何選擇中學？

youma

What do you mean?

Are you stating that the students cannot know their banding at the time when they choose 2 schools to apply at the first round?

If so, that sounds like a bet!


By the way, is this table an official one? Tks.

el1008

對呀, 所以我話人都deen       連校長都唔知自己間小學有幾多band 1 , 不過, 有辡有唔辡, 各位家長記得好好利用自行收生個30%, 今年有兩次機會呀, 唔好對大抽獎存咁大希望呀     

WYmom

I believe that competition in entering top schools will be even larger this year as we can choose 2 schools in first round and schools have more discretion to choose the best students (30% this year).  Top students will have more choices but average students will in fact be more difficult to enter their desired schools.

Irene_BB

小兒現在小三﹐請問學科測驗是甚麼 (是不是學校平時的測驗﹐還是教育署出的測驗)是不是對升中有影响
我知小五小六考試成績很重要﹐但現在這份表又是甚麼意思﹐我真是一頭霧水

TWMa

小兒現在小三﹐請問學科測驗是甚麼 (是不是學校平時的測驗﹐還是教育署出的測驗)是不是對升中有影响

不是什麼學科測驗, 而是升中分班試成績
各校 Banding 比率影響學生的升中選校, 不相信教統局不把調整後的結果告訴各校, 不要危言聳聽, 製造恐慌   

leeleelumlum

007,

講多d得唔得呀?  
好想知噃!

TWMa

Eddie&Sylvia 寫道:
TWMa :
教統局會把調整後的結果告訴各校, 但好似學校係不能將結果公佈,之前鮮漁行校長就因為將結果公佈, 俾教統局警告

Eddie&Sylvia:
上一次只是 "模擬", 未係正式, 教統局把模擬成績給各校, 讓各校有個心理準備來年的調整大概有幾多啫嘛.
同埋, 要求各校唔好用模擬成績作為收生宣傳, 並不等於不會將今年正式調整結果告知各校, 絕對有理由相信各校清楚自己目前的 Banding 率, 咁又點會 "死得人多"?!

el1008

校長的意思係當中一派位後,教統局會通知你間學校會有幾多學生係band 1 組別

rclamlam

但係無理由學校如果知唔可以話比家長知喎, 咁樣點知應該有幾多個係band 1/2/3既學生呀? 無理由.

xmanman

同意,  如果家長唔知小朋友banding,  如何報校!
所以我都相信校長一定知banding 比率的!

judy

今年開始，統一派位之方法有了一個很大之更改，首先，每個學生可不受地區限制的選取3家學校，這佔全港学額之10%，然後，再選取30家本區的。所以，今年的學生應有两個banding，第一個是全港性的，第ニ個是地區性的。根据派位機制，band 1 先選，然校band2，最後band3。

如果學生不知自己之banding，他們怎選校呢? 教局不通知? 除非教局白痴拉！

放鬆啲拉，學校一定知道學生banding的，不要當人白痴先得！

WYmom

However, even in the past, the parent or teachers also do not know exactly the real banding of the students, they only estimate based on the historical % of bandings of the school, so some borderline students may choose schools wrongly (choose band 1 schools but in fact they are band 2 or vis versa).  This year, the historical % of bandings of each school will change, so the risk of error may be higher.

rclamlam

其實有10%可以揀全況中學, 會更加令到學生更慘, 雖然好似可以揀多左好多學校, 相反學校亦會揀好質素既學生, 來來回回咁, 令到學生同家長選校更花多眼亂.

全港性既BANDING, 好多地區小學既學生可能以為自己好叻, 選名校集中既中學, 可能倒頭來唔係BAND 1生, 跌左落BAND 2.

好似去年好多家長到揀學校都唔係幾明點揀, 今年更複雜, 相信好多家長到揀學校時會更多問題.

judy

However, even in the past, the parent or teachers also do not know exactly the real banding of the students, they only estimate based on the historical % of bandings of the school, so some borderline students may choose schools wrongly (choose band 1 schools but in fact they are band 2 or vis versa). This year, the historical % of bandings of each school will change, so the risk of error may be higher.

我估學校會一如以往知道學生banding，當然也一如以往有borderline。

今年比往年優勝之處是在自行分配階段之学額增至30%，且更選两家學校。

leeleelumlum

嘩, elsa2005, 你個囡間學校都好厲害噃 , 可唔可以pm話我知.

[size=large]007, 007 你呢個高人去咗邊? 快d出嚟解話啦, 好想知道你想講吔, 快d 現身啦   :

elsa2005 寫道:
我估007的意思是踩界的學生會增多，因為行新制，好幾年都未調整過的全港各間小學，各自情況會變化成甚麼樣？真係考到人，而校長所知的數據都只是個大約幾多。好似我囡間小學上學年升中時，校長話希望大家努力d，爭取進步到全級110人入band 1組別，結果派位完後得到的確實數據是104人屬band 1組別。
以上純粹個人意見，007莫怪我胡亂猜測。

88maggie

中央派位前一個月。 :