購買歐洲鋼琴疑問

AndyLeekw

本人欲購買一部歐洲鋼琴給孩子作練習及應付考試之用，因為聽說音色與手感都比日本琴較好。請問那一個牌子的歐洲琴比較好呢。可否說明推介原因及使用經驗。謝謝!

bebebe12345

Dear ming2,
能夠回答這個提問真不容易，深感佩服！
極力推薦想買琴的家長看看。
簡潔而清淅，資料充足，評論中肯。
謝謝！

idachan

ming2,
你真係叻,對琴咁了解!

mom5354

Boston D 琴鍵較短, 而且香港較適合用日本琴, 除非屋企曰日開冷氣, 買琴其實都幾主觀嫁

林嬌嬌

hk 天氣潮濕, 不適宜用歐洲鋼琴(bcoz of 歐洲木質),  hk用日本鋼琴 就比較好. hk family mostly buy Yamaha U1, if space available (height ) , buy U5

.

AndyLeekw 寫道:
本人欲購買一部歐洲鋼琴給孩子作練習及應付考試之用，因為聽說音色與手感都比日本琴較好。請問那一個牌子的歐洲琴比較好呢。可否說明推介原因及使用經驗。謝謝!

JJsMama

ming2, your information is incredibly useful!

I have a few questions:

1.  In your opinion, is there a substantial difference between Sauter and Pleyel?

2.  Since pricing is similar between Pleyer and Boston, which one is of better value?  

3.  Silly question may be.  But, would you say that there is a direct correlation between the price tag and the quality amongst these European brands?  Or does the "brand name" play a big part in pricing?

4.  How does a 'good' Yamaha compare to these European brands?

I am thinking of buying a high quality piano.

Many thanks.

ming2 寫道:
AndyLeekw

你想買歐洲鋼琴,咁你預幾多budget呀??講真句,最靚就當然係Steinway & Sons(西德琴)啦..不過Steinway upright都要成廿幾萬先得...

除左Steinway之外,Bosendorfer(奧地利琴)都唔錯,不過又係要成廿幾萬一隻upright piano,

Sauter(西德) 130M,之前試過手感同聲都好正,但係折完都要成十三萬幾,想平d0既話,Sauter最平0既model係120tlr2,tom lee門市特價應該係七萬幾,

Pleyel (法國琴),我有學生用緊,都幾靚聲同touching 都唔錯架..價錢上都唔太貴,最平0既model都係五萬幾蚊.

至於petrof(捷克琴), 我自己就唔多鐘意,因為我覺得d touching唔係太好,而且d低音又唔夠靚

再唔係Boston都唔錯 (不過係日本琴, designed by Steinway & Sons),最低model好似係126,tom lee門市特價要六萬幾.

以我所知,捷克琴d質素都係麻麻地..

另外,柏斯個d所謂德國琴全部都係東德琴黎,以同樣0既價錢黎比,tom lee個d 歐洲琴0既手感同聲都好過佢...(純為個人感覺)

JJsMama

ming2, thanks again for the detail explanation.  Please check PM.  

ming2 寫道:
JJsMaMa

according to your questions..

1.  In your opinion, is there a substantial difference between Sauter and Pleyel?....呢個要睇番彈琴0既人自己本身0既要求高唔高,聽唔聽得出/彈唔彈得出個分別啦...如果你問我,Pleyel同Sauter兩隻牌子0既比較,我幾年初次接觸一隻Sauter(不過唔記得係咩model,只知折完都要成十萬蚊),我就非常喜歡呢隻琴0既聲同埋touching,到去年我有個學生想換琴繼續學diploma grade時,佢問我意見,我介紹佢Sauter,佢話佢都好鐘意Sauter,不過價錢over budget,結果我地試完Pleyel都覺得唔錯,但係都唔及我早幾個月試0既個隻Sauter 130M (折完都要成十三四萬),個d聲同手感真係非一般0既upright呢...果然係一分錢就一分貨架...

2.  Since pricing is similar between Pleyer and Boston, which one is of better value?  ...Boston係designed by Steinway & Sons,所以有d Steinway 0既專利設計都會有用係Boston個琴度,所以如果講better value,我諗Boston會好少少啦..


3.  Silly question may be.  But, would you say that there is a direct correlation between the price tag and the quality amongst these European brands?  Or does the "brand name" play a big part in pricing?....唔..當然有d琴0既質素同個價錢係有直接0既關係啦...就如我之前講過少少有關Steinway & Sons0既資料咁,當你知道Steinway0既製造過程同埋原理之後,你就會明白點一隻Steinway0既琴係會賣得咁貴,而你會覺得如果有錢你都會買佢架啦...不過有時係琴與琴之間作出比較時,你會發現同一個價錢入面,有d牌子0既質素係比另一d牌子好架...呢d亦都可以係同製造地區有關....就如我之前有提及過,同樣係十幾萬0既歐洲琴,柏斯個d就唔及tom lee個隻Sauter 130M好啦...另外"brand name"呢樣野,唔多唔少都會同pricing有d關係0既,正如我相信yamaha0既adv.點都好似比kawai多,所以yamaha 賣得比kawai貴都唔出奇架...



4.  How does a 'good' Yamaha compare to these European brands?...呢個睇個人喜好啦..有人偏愛日本琴,但亦有人只係鐘意歐洲琴,好難有得比架..

CICISASA

bebebe12345

Check pm, pls