- 在線時間
- 0 小時
- 最後登錄
- 07-4-8
- 國民生產力
- 0
- 附加生產力
- 0
- 貢獻生產力
- 0
- 註冊時間
- 04-6-19
- 閱讀權限
- 10
- 帖子
- 33
- 主題
- 0
- 精華
- 0
- 積分
- 32
- UID
- 25013
|
Re: 但 piano cd 我真係唔覺有...
RMA:
I am just curious to know how many Naxos piano recordings you have heard in order to draw that no-impact conclusion. While Warrren had touched on the historical side and non-piano side of things, please allow me to introduce to you what Naxos has done with respect to the modern perspective of the intrument of your expertise, ie the piano (and I am in no way affiliated to Naxos, except I beg a third opinion to be heard).
If you want impact: Naxos was one of the pioneering labels (and probably the only one back then) that was brave enough to save many neglected piano works and piano composers from oblivion. I guess I don't need to point out what works and which composers - I'm sure you will know as you are so familiar with the piano repertoire.
If you want good pianists that have made an impact on the repertoire: what about Scherbakov on Godowsky? Zarafiants on Scriabin? Austbo on Messiaen? Martin on Alkan (well.. not all, but it *was* a milestone)? Jando on Beethoven? Biret on Brahms? Roscoe on Szymanowski? Paik on Prokofiev? Also, have you given their on-going Liszt and Scarlatti projects any try? I'm sure you will be very satisfied with all these.
I'm not saying Naxos always produces good recordings - I've come across sub-par products in Naxos as often as I have from say, a DG, a Decca, a Sony, a Hyperion, a Chandos, a Danacord, an ECM, a Harmonia Mundi, or a BIS. What makes Naxos really stand out from the crowd, besides their huge repertoire and artist line-up, is their devotion. If you want to understand more, I encourage to you to read last issue of Gramophone where you can find more information about this Label of the Year recepient.
I just hope teachers will deliver a very important message to students that just because a pianist's name is lesser known (to the teacher, or to the place where the teacher lives), that shouldn't stop them from exploring new composers, works, and interpretations.RMA 寫道:
kcarol,
你話佢地有時會搵到勁人,但 piano o既 cd,我就真係唔覺得有。其他o既 genre 我都唔會買 naxos. 雖然佢地係平,但唔係叫超值...
warrrren,
In terms of the interpretation and style of many performer Naxos invited, I am sorry but have to conclude that their impact in solo piano works are rather unsatisfactory.
When you listen to some of their publications (popular repertoire such as Mozart Sonatas and Bach's WTC), you'll find the artists are not really up to standard to provide an exemplary performance to kids/youngsters for studies.
When students are not experienced to judge the musicality, listening to these Naxos CDs and merely copying would be a serious '反效果'. |
|