音統處學小提琴

MoneyWong

請問有沒有家長其小朋友在音統處學小提琴學了超過兩年, 一班有十人是不是進度很慢, 需不需要在外面另外補學. 在音統處學多長時間才可以考三級或五級.請有經驗家長指教.
謝謝!

aoj

我都想知呀.  如在音統處長期班學小提琴, 音統會教學生皇家的考試歌嗎 ?  還是只是合奏和演奏 ?

有無子女在音統學緊的BK member分享下

8Gu

請問你們的小朋友是否在學小提琴?

音統處的初班在每年的8-9月apply, 11月入學, 有幸入讀的話, 亦不論你有多少級程度, 一律由最基本開始教。

由於是器樂訓練... 說到合奏和演奏, 可能會是3幾年後的事情。學習了幾年的小朋友, 可在5月看看有沒有插班位吧。

小兒在音統學中樂的器樂, 並非小提琴。 我只是路人甲, 希望你們知多一點而己。

mimi1234

我有朋友個女在音統學小提琴，我記得是兩年前(小朋友讀緊中二)考左五級小提琴，應該都係經音統幫佢報，佢考樂理都係，不過是要另外比錢讀。現在佢個女讀中四，學緊七級，佢從來冇在出面學過，不過就一定要參加樂團，佢都覺得好SIZE 時間。我唔記得佢小一定小二開始學，我個人認為要學七年才考五級，好似耐左 D，你地認為呢？

somimi

音統系由grade 0 開始, 而且一年升一個grade, 除非你有考過皇家/聖三一, 先可跳級, 亦唔會幫報名/教考試歌. 至於入樂團我覺得系好事.

mimi1234

somimi,

因為我同呢個朋友唔係好熟，可能我搞錯左啦，如果唔教考試歌，咁咪好慘？不過我知佢係在音統找鋼琴伴奏，佢同我講為左個女呢個五級考試，都額外洗左成五千元。
佢個女現在中四，學校功課都好忙，所以佢覺得去樂團好SIZE時間，但唔參加又唔得，話除非在自己學校有參加樂團就可以例外，好似話中五、中七都可以免。
你個小朋友是否都在音統學小提琴？覺得好唔好？我都有諗過比我個小朋友插班入去？是否好難？

哈里波特

我的小朋友在音統不是學小提琴, 但都有D idea.

音統好處 :
1) 平
2) 有免費樂理 (都係平的一種)

相反 (唔可以叫壞處的)
1) 小組教, 太慢
2) 時間/地點無得自選
3) 若而家由grade 0開始, 要抽籤, 好難中. 你有心學, 無理由等中籤, 可能等N咁多年都無你份.
4) 今年grade 0 starter 開始有新例, 全期8個grade分三個level, 每個level要大考一次 (唔係升班試), 這次大考, 是要與外邊插班的一齊比併, 唔會因你你音統學生, 有分加. 好多在外面學到好高級的都考插班. 即你隨時學完個elementary就無得學, 唔好以為上左車就可以玩到grade 8.
5) 若插班, 要downgrade (for most case), 如你已有grade 5 ABRSM cert, 佢可能放你入grade 3 or 4.

mimi1234

哈里波特,
你個小朋友學什麼樂器，是否樣樣樂器的新例都相同？如果大考要同出面學到好高級的小朋友爭位，咪分分鐘換哂血？咁有冇話要學幾多年為一個 level？會唔會大概 3 grade 為一個level？聽落都幾危wo。

哈里波特

係樣樣樂器都一樣. 佢唔係有心要換血, 而係咁叫公平wor.  Outsider 通常都會較努力, 所以perform得好d.

唔記得個schedule係3/3/2定點, 其實你可以call Music Office 問, 佢地d人好好.

我估計, 裡面有兩種學生, 一是好budget, 另外就是兩邊學, 外面仲有私人教授.  所以, 若唔係好budge, why don't you take private tutor?  

somimi

哈里波特,
除左好budget外, d家長想細路入樂團, 但又要cert咪兩邊學law.

mimi1234

flutepiano,
小提琴伴奏 (piano part)，我見到有四頁咁多，比賽時可唔可以 copy 2 pages, 唔係彈緊琴點turn page？洗唔洗找人幫turn page？

哈里波特

入樂團不用在音統學, 佢地有個好完善的機制去計分, 好多人都唔係音統的學生黎架.  好似呀女旁邊的band友,已經上年ABRSM grade 8, but Music office band entry requirement is ABRSM grade 3.  Of course, 音統學生, 有d印象分就真.

somimi 寫道:
哈里波特,
除左好budget外, d家長想細路入樂團, 但又要cert咪兩邊學law.

mimi1234

flutepiano,
thanks,
我見琴譜好似冇turn page 位，唔知我有冇睇錯，不過我驚 copy 2 pages 話會侵犯版權，不過我都係八卦下姐，彈琴果個應該會搞得掂。

mimi1234

哈里波特,
樂團有得考？係咪每年都收？如果在ABRSM考左 試, 會唔會豁免考試？

哈里波特

樂團有得考？yes
係咪每年都收？yes
如果在ABRSM考左 試, 會唔會豁免考試？If met their minimum requirement, you can choose exemption.  But it doesn't mean they accept your kid because they choose all the highest mark students joining their band.  They have a very good calculation mark scheme, you can download from Music Office web-site when they open offer.

heihei1998

哈里波特 寫道:
5) 若插班, 要downgrade (for most case), 如你已有grade 5 ABRSM cert, 佢可能放你入grade 3 or 4.

哈里波特,

點解要downgrade 呢?係咪佢哋個syllabus要求較高?

哈里波特

I think but it is most of the case I know.  I think it is because a lot of kids they got the cert, for example ABRSM G5, but they only know 3 pieces & some scales, they're not well practice other songs.  They will arrange audition, but it is only 5 minutes test, how can they know the actual standard of the kids.  So, they take a conservative approach to downgrade/repeat 1 year to ensure the kids has no difficulties on that standard.  For the old syb, they are not required to competite with the outsiders, but some of them are repeater, they will be promote each year if they passed the exam every year.

I think they seldom accept the kids, for example who got ABRSM G5 and then accept him/her to join G6 standard in Music Office.  They must start again G5 beginning, that I called repeat.  For the worst case, if the kids audition cannot well perform sight reading as well as the piece, but they found he/she is a talent, they may put him/her from G4.

heihei1998

Well noted with many thanks !

哈里波特 寫道:
I think but it is most of the case I know.  I think it is because a lot of kids they got the cert, for example ABRSM G5, but they only know 3 pieces & some scales, they're not well practice other songs.  They will arrange audition, but it is only 5 minutes test, how can they know the actual standard of the kids.  So, they take a conservative approach to downgrade/repeat 1 year to ensure the kids has no difficulties on that standard.  For the old syb, they are not required to competite with the outsiders, but some of them are repeater, they will be promote each year if they passed the exam every year.

I think they seldom accept the kids, for example who got ABRSM G5 and then accept him/her to join G6 standard in Music Office.  They must start again G5 beginning, that I called repeat.  For the worst case, if the kids audition cannot well perform sight reading as well as the piece, but they found he/she is a talent, they may put him/her from G4.