灣仔聖約瑟vs聖保羅男校，點揀？

Lelu

請指教，謝謝。

Mrssslui

Sure St. Joseph.

ngyw

Dear Lelu,

你係咪抽中St. Joseph呀?如果係,恭喜晒!

比我揀,我都選St. Joseph.

Lelu 寫道:
請指教，謝謝。

SharonChan

no doubt, St Joseph

works

我係"唔想操心型",到小四時唔想同小朋友博殺!

我反而會撰聖保羅男校,升中唔使爭硼頭!    

Lelu

我對聖保羅男校中學現況所知甚少；只知是DSS中學。 聞說會考及聯校比賽成績已無復當年之勇。 知她銳意改革，轉直資，但請問可有進一步資料分享。 謝謝。

works 寫道:
我係"唔想操心型",到小四時唔想同小朋友博殺!

我反而會撰聖保羅男校,升中唔使爭硼頭!    

works

兩間都係好學校!是但入一間都唔會錯得去邊!

你反而要諗諗學費,宗教是否你的關注? 而讀聖約瑟既話,你就要預在要好著緊囝囝既成績.因為頭1/3好成績既學生就好穩陣升中,中間既1/3就要抽1/2,尾既1/3就唔使想! :-|

所以好多一入去讀聖約瑟既小朋友家長,好早就要撲定高班既試卷,提早同小朋友溫習!

Lelu

謝謝指教。我正担心小兒未來六年將在成績優勝劣敗的壓力中渡過。 但另一方面，我又對聖保羅男校中學的質素有保留。 真苦惱！

學費,宗教和地區不是我考慮的關鍵因素。

works 寫道:
兩間都係好學校!是但入一間都唔會錯得去邊!

你反而要諗諗學費,宗教是否你的關注? 而讀聖約瑟既話,你就要預在要好著緊囝囝既成績.因為頭1/3好成績既學生就好穩陣升中,中間既1/3就要抽1/2,尾既1/3就唔使想! :-|

所以好多一入去讀聖約瑟既小朋友家長,好早就要撲定高班既試卷,提早同小朋友溫習!

  

bk2005

Originally, I think St Paul is better than St Joseph. Based on the repoonse here, it seems that my information is outdated.

However, if the difference is not significant, I would still prefer St Paul. Less pressure ma! You and your child will be happier in the coming 6 yrs.

steven819

Both are good schools. If you can 100% sure that you son will not be the lower 1/3 when he is in P6, then St Joseph is a good choice because the school fee is less. Think about this. If it is so unfortunate that he cannot get to the secondary school, he'll probably not be able to accept by other band 1 school. Probably good DDS school will reject him too.  On the other hand, if he is not so good in St Paul boy, he can still go to St Paul's College. He may start to work hard and get good HKCEE result. That what boy's usually do. Say, he is still not doing very well in secondary school. You can still sent him aboard for University education. St Paul's College is still a good school in some oversea university's eye. Added to that St Paul Boy has excellent alumni connections. Remember, connection is very important when someone just started his career.

Lelu 寫道:
請指教，謝謝。

mattsmum

there are over 300 students per year in st. jo (all get in by lucky draw) and 90 students ( all hand picked ) in st. paul, guess where your kid would likly to be the the first 1/3.

JoJoJo

1. (聖約瑟) 津貼 小學+中學 12年學費有限。(聖保羅) 直資 小學+中學 12年學費大約四十萬元 (每月三至四千元)。
2. (聖約瑟) 小學和中學因為直屬關係,所以中學有85%收返小學,原則上係原校上。(聖保羅) 直資 小學升中學,原則上也是原校上。
3. 成績方面(聖約瑟)和(聖保羅)大家都是名校,都係好top。
總結 : 如果每個月多三四千元,可以用呢幫小朋友找其他東西來增加知識。另外可能(聖保羅)D學生有錢關係,經常投數校規大古老,這正命(聖保羅)都是傳統學校;唔辛苦,邊有世間財,要成績好,更係要努力啦。至於升中方面,其本上大家都可以升上原校。應該都係揀(聖約瑟)。

Zen

JoJoJo 寫道:

2. (聖約瑟) 小學和中學因為直屬關係,所以中學有85%收返小學,原則上係原校上。(聖保羅) 直資 小學升中學,原則上也是原校上。

以目前未結龍情況，小學８班，中學５班，只有約60%可以直升．

Charlotte_mom

仲要同出面學生爭wor

works

係呀!仲要同出面爭! :-|

我有個朋友囝囝小五時都考頭100內,一到小六,小朋友自己既成績都冇差到,但因有其他小朋友高在分,結果佢就跌出100外,但都係100頭果種,但佢冇抽獎命,唔中,要出去撲其他中學!而有個考得差過個小朋友既(考成150),因為抽得中,反而有得留! 激到我朋友死死下!  

pmamylee

Lelu
灣仔聖約瑟-->
同學間之競爭很大,因為要全級100名內才可直升上中學.
聖保羅男校-->
由於是直資,所有學生可直升上中學,競爭及壓力少.
至於中學, 論名氣, 聖約瑟較聖保羅男校大一點, 起碼近年聖約瑟出過多個十優生.

HuiTung

Not at all.  There's also no guarantee that all St Paul Boy's primary students can go to its secondary school.

JoJoJo

對不起我錯了,因為我唔知小學有8班那麼多,雖然中學收85%,但是它只有5班,小升中大約係60%。不過都唔敢要,升不到同校,到時都可以找直資。

pmamylee

HuiTung
St Paul Boy's primary 是直資小學,中學是否?
如是,以我所知,應可直上中學,除非成績很差(例如有不合格).
新小拔,St. Paul Co-edu, St. Paul Convent,都是直資,
它們的小學生都是絶大部份上回自己的中學.
特別是新小拔,它說是百分百保證上回自己的中學.

HuiTung

pmamylee,

This info was revealed by a member when he discussed the interviewing process of SP Boy's lately.  Just like what you said "應可直上中學,除非成績很差".  This is also applied to SP Boy's up to this moment.