請問:大陸造o既單簧管得唔得

NO.FOUR

大陸造o既單簧管得唔得 ??
(A)琴行 : 大陸造$1,180;台灣造$2,780
(B)琴行 : 大陸造(中美)$2,430
tomlee : yamaha$2,900;台灣$1,900
因為學校提供個支成日都有問題,吹到亞囝好MON !!

NO.FOUR

Anybody know    

cho-cho

唔好買大陸做啦!
買支yamaha啦! 始終一分錢一分貨.  
吹的樂器真係要好d, 唔好吹得好辛苦.
有d細路有潛質, 但係支樂器差, 影響晒! 真係好晒!
而且佢吹得好, 將來要換支再好d的話, yamaha仲可以賣比其他人, 都有二手市場.  

kaka0814

Yamaha is so far so good.

But for value, I will support all parents to pay for a Buffet B12, currently discount at TomLee at $3600 only, very good and stable.

Don't buy those in China, even they said they are some 中美合資, still very bad... It will just waste you $1000, and probably you will give up playing clarinet.

yinyinBB

唔知可唔可以幫到你, 因為我都有好幾年無接觸.

學校提供個支有問題,你可以去檢查

yinyinBB

嘩!!!  乜而家d Buffet買得咁平, 我以前買過支E11都要$8,xxx, (太耐都唔記得8千幾)

$3600可以買到Buffet Clarinet 真係幾好, 不過我都係覺得要睇

kaka0814

yinyinBB,

if you get your Buffet E11 at $8,XXX, well... you shouldn't be a very long time ago player.

[My Buffet E11 was get at $4,2XX...well... a old guy....     

$3,600 for a Buffet B12 is very worth!! That's very nice clarinet in fact. Much better than Yamaha C-270, so that's why Yamaha got larger 2nd hand market (most people will sell it when they reaches a grade)

Don't buy Yamaha C-450, I know that's wood one, but... very bad sound, ever worse than Buffet B12...

Check your PM please..

yinyinBB

kaka0814

Check your PM thanks!

NO.FOUR

咁多位唔該哂!!   

kaka0814 > 中美合資果支都要2千幾呀!!因為我唔識,所以寫埋出lai請大家俾o下意見!!thousand thanks !!

yinyinBB >
學校提供個支係可以整,但要等.....等.....等。
簧片會有咩問題 ? 見到少少1岩1忽的簧片,我都會叫亞囝換o左佢ga la)
其實亞囝暫時只係學校學,出邊好多都要10歲以上先有班,(我個囝得8歲半),所以買支yahama真係1516,但係買二手,我又唔識,又驚俾人呃!!

Zoey

NO.FOUR,

個人意見, 若果係初學既, 唔駛買得咁靚啦, 真係 '來佬' 野, 可能要去到萬萬聲呢        !

妳 quote  既大陸造, 台灣造 . . . 係未在琴行問既價?   若妳真係有需要買的話, 或者可以試下 pm 我, 睇下我幫唔幫到妳丫    .

NO.FOUR

Zoey > 暫時唔駛"萬萬聲"住o下
不過.....我都希望有1日佢會有機會用o既   
thanks a lot! please check pm. :

kaka0814

我的意見:

Yamaha 係平價入面穩定的管, YCL-250 冇記錯好似 $2700...但....

如果可以, 又真係有心學, 買 Buffet B12 啦!!! $3600 真係好平.... 以前冇特價係去到 $4300 囉!!! 分左期 (好似可以分六期), 每期都係多百五咋... Buffet B12 是法國做的, 而 Buffet 是 單簧管大廠, 聲音比 yamaha 真的好很多, 到咁上下老師會建議你買 Buffet R13, 就是因為這廠比 yamaha 好

如果俾中美合資果支都要2千幾, 算吧, 買 yamaha 啦

簧片還是另一個很長的題目, 有機會再分享。

TIFFMUMMY

kaka0814

Oh No! Just bought one from school YamahaYcL-250 $2750 but they never mention Buffect B12.  Should ask u earlier!!!

kaka0814 寫道:
我的意見:

Yamaha 係平價入面穩定的管, YCL-250 冇記錯好似 $2700...但....

如果可以, 又真係有心學, 買 Buffet B12 啦!!! $3600 真係好平.... 以前冇特價係去到 $4300 囉!!! 分左期 (好似可以分六期), 每期都係多百五咋... Buffet B12 是法國做的, 而 Buffet 是 單簧管大廠, 聲音比 yamaha 真的好很多, 到咁上下老師會建議你買 Buffet R13, 就是因為這廠比 yamaha 好

如果俾中美合資果支都要2千幾, 算吧, 買 yamaha 啦

簧片還是另一個很長的題目, 有機會再分享。

kaka0814

Many Band teacher like Yamaha sound -- it really like when you are talking "Yamaha" -- a bright and high voice. Or I should say it sound like Yamaha piano, people will comment it as 尖 / 弱 for sometime. But this match the requirement of the Wind/brass Band, the louder sound without discussion the sound quality.

Again, Clarinet sound should be much warmer or much deep / wide rather than a "Yamaha" voice. Buffet is a good brand, it's B12 is stable and durable. Anyway, you have ordered your YCL-250, then just save more your $$$ on a later R13, with cost $17000 in Tomlee right now, I guess they will increase their price later.

TIFFMUMMY

No. Four,
其實我都1516左long time買唔買單簧管,但school話第二年學一定要買plus 明年5月會考2級, 所以就......還有單簧片一年已用了3boxes.Too many!!Do you use  Rico Royal(size 2)單簧片?

NO.FOUR 寫道:
yinyinBB >
學校提供個支係可以整,但要等.....等.....等。
簧片會有咩問題 ? 見到少少1岩1忽的簧片,我都會叫亞囝換o左佢ga la)
其實亞囝暫時只係學校學,出邊好多都要10歲以上先有班,(我個囝得8歲半),所以買支yahama真係1516,但係買二手,我又唔識,又驚俾人呃!!

TIFFMUMMY

What!!! $17000 for R13.  U right, I think I better start saving the money now.

kaka0814 寫道:
Many Band teacher like Yamaha sound -- it really like when you are taking "Yamaha" -- a bright and high voice. Or I should say it sound like Yamaha piano, people will comment it as 尖 / 弱 for sometime. But this match the requirement of the Wind/brass Band, the louder sound without discussion the sound quality.

Again, Clarinet sound should be much warmer or much deep / wide rather than a "Yamaha" voice. Buffet is a good brand, it's B12 is stable and durable. Anyway, you have ordered your YCL-250, then just save more your $$$ on a later R13, with cost $17000 in Tomlee right now, I guess they will increase their price later.

yinyinBB

NO.FOUR

我唔明點解要等.....等.....等???
你可以自己

kaka0814

yinyinBB,

有好多 wind/brass band 的老師會叫學生用RICO, 話平喎... 仲可以吹左四五年都唔叫佢轉硬D的 Reed ... 你睇下俾唔俾到多d意見啦... 我打得太多啦

NO.FOUR

TIFFMUMMY > 1年3盒簧片 ,tiffany一定好勤力practice la!! 亞囝學校係用vandoren 2號,佢舊年1盒都用唔哂!! (懶)
點解會考2級,亞囝話會考3級喎   (不過要亞sir pass先得) !!

yinyinBB > 亞囝支clarinet係yamaha,由學校免費提供,但學校俾埋我o地拎返屋企練,所以要整一定等學校整。
咁應該買Buffet or yamaha好d呢 ?

kaka0814

唔關小朋友懶唔懶囉... vandoren d reed 係耐用好多