跑馬地聖保祿 vs 聖芳濟各 邊間好很急 urgent

Hilouey

跑馬地聖保祿 vs 聖芳濟各 邊間好很急 urgent  
各位媽咪可否給些意見

女兒今天學校派表 跑馬地聖保祿 vs 聖芳濟各 邊間好派表啦,
有冇就讀這校家長女兒比些意見


Hilouey

paradise1998

我個人認為要考慮小朋友的能力, 父母所能付出的時間和耐性較為重要.  另外, 你對學校的要求.  聖芳濟程度明顯比較高, 我小朋友現階段已經要應付公民的中, 英, 數, 彈琴和校外英文班, 所以最終我選擇了插班入聖保祿.  我希望她可以享受到愉快的小學生活.

Poppan123

I think Happy Valley St. Paul is better in Moral education. St. Francis is more focus on extra-curricular activites. Academic performance is similar.

I also final choose St. Paul.

    

Hilouey

hi hi

my friend say happy valley st.paul 程度明顯比較高, and many rich man in this school

yuanli

St Francis is better in academic results and conduct.

龍嫂

對，聖芳濟各成績和操行都好過跑馬地聖保祿 ，附近一帶; 所見，聖保祿D女仔好飛(中學)。 聖芳濟各所屬的嘉諾撒會比較踏實樸素，好似聖心、聖芳濟各、聖瑪利、培德咁，D 女仔乖好多。

yuanli 寫道:
St Francis is better in academic results and conduct.

july2005

現在社會有時太純未必是好事，個人覺得如果可以學得醒d,
第時大個做事都會易d執生，無０甘易比人呃

Poppan123

The both have around 80% promoted to their Secondary school each year. Checked from their school report, Happy Valley St. Paul had better performance in HKCEE and HKALE result   

lam322

聖芳濟各都有90%以上可以直升中學.佢地英文程度高好多.校舍都無st.paul咁舊.前幾日st.paul仲出現冷氣機爆炸.真係諗起都驚驚~~   

OnHo

聖方濟各好似無直屬中學架噃

你既意思係咪指有90%可以派到 band 1中學?

Mrssslui

有架.

OnHo 寫道:
聖方濟各好似無直屬中學架噃

你既意思係咪指有90%可以派到 band 1中學?

Mrssslui

both are similar.
至於係唔係飛女,每間學校總有D架啦!
其實都係睇個小朋友自己.
況且都係中學先出現,唔洗咁緊張.

龍嫂 寫道:
對，聖芳濟各成績和操行都好過跑馬地聖保祿 ，附近一帶; 所見，聖保祿D女仔好飛(中學)。 聖芳濟各所屬的嘉諾撒會比較踏實樸素，好似聖心、聖芳濟各、聖瑪利、培德咁，D 女仔乖好多。

[quote]
yuanli 寫道:
St Francis is better in academic results and conduct.

[/quote]

m1m1sam

以英文成績計，兩間的程度差不多。
以整體成績計，St Francis 略高一線。
以操行表現計，St Francis 會好些。

Poppan123

Dear m1m1sam,

May i know whether you have some figures to say St Francis is higher in over acadamic peformance and conduct? Or it is by feelings?

Thanks
  

npMaMa

There are more band 2 students in St. Francis Secondary school than St. Paul's Catholic.  Also, St Paul's HKCEE and HKALE results are better than St. Francis'

m1m1sam

It's from my sister who works in EMB.
BTW, did u read the inspection reports of the schools?

Poppan123 寫道:
Dear m1m1sam,

May i know whether you have some figures to say St Francis is higher in over acadamic peformance and conduct? Or it is by feelings?

Thanks
  

Poppan123

Both school inspection report had only qualitatively mentioned their Eng. Lang level were above HK average but had no quantitive figure on student academic performance!!

Thanks   

singsir

請問大坑真光能否與這兩間學校相比，這間似乎口卑都好好，仲幾難入！

Yuetning

I also wish to ask whether St. Francis is good. Originally, I want to submit P1 Application Form to St. Francis. But yesterday when I visited the school (just looking outside). The campus is pretty small.  

I also wish to know if kids can adapt easily because for P1, P3, P5, they have to attend pm session and P2, P4, P6, they have to attend am session.

yyellow

hi,
你指聖芳濟各是否灣仔合和的那一間?

我想跑馬地St. Paul會好一點. 本人不覺得跑馬地St. Paul的女孩很飛, 反而是"銅鑼灣"那一間是這樣. 跑馬地St. Paul的女孩比較純, 好有紀律. 成績也better than wanchai 聖芳濟.

因為我有親戚的女孩分別現在正讀緊這2間小學. 如果客觀的說, happy valley St. Paul 因校舍是古蹟, 外表看比較古老, 但內裏不是想像那麼舊. 但成績是happy valley St. Paul is better!  

而升中方面, 據本人收到的資料from my 親戚, St. Paul上年近九成入回本身中學 (雖然學校簡介mention 8成, 但每年基本是超8成半, 而上年每班只有數人不入). 而wanchai 聖芳濟只有近八成; 早2年前試過只有2/3班入回本身中學 (7~8成).

這資料只作客觀參考, 最好你自己本人去一去這2間小學, 客觀看看你自己喜歡那一間的學生.  因為人地(包括本人在內)怎樣說, 不及你自己去觀察實際情況. 我的資料也只可作參考.

: