state boarding school

bblove100

Could someone share state boarding school experience? Do the boarders have activities at weekends?Strict discipline?  

beastiebistro

bblove100 發表於 24-2-4 22:44
Could someone share state boarding school experience? Do the boarders have activities at weekends?St ...

我個人認為，諗都唔好諗。
英國人基本上：
- 有錢又buy寄宿嘅，會送去寄宿私校
- 有錢唔buy寄宿嘅，一係讀私立day school，一係搬去好區入最好嘅state day school
- 冇錢又想寄宿嘅，嘗試考好啲申請私校bursary
- 冇錢唔諗寄宿嘅，咪讀附近嘅state school，或者考附近嘅grammar school

基本上state boarding入讀嘅都係屋企有問題嘅學生。一係屋企唔方便照顧，一係就係小朋友有問題屋企搞佢唔掂嘅,你會唔會想小朋友同呢啲做同學呢？唯一就係嗰少量有boarding位嘅grammar school勉強可以考慮（因為要考入去，所以學生質素叫做好少少）。

state school（無論係comprehensive或者grammar）始終係政府學校，所有設施/維修/選擇都要等政府錢。我諗呢個世界上（可能除咗北歐之外），冇咩政府會撥足夠資源俾所有嘅state school。學校以至此，何況重要maintain寄宿設施？我就聽過好多case係啲設施爛咗要等政府錢先維修到，有啲活動/甚至選科開開下因為唔夠經費停辦...

當然係我個人意見。

sleung2020

bblove100 發表於 24-2-4 22:44
Could someone share state boarding school experience? Do the boarders have activities at weekends?St ...

bno visa?

wendycyp

beastiebistro 發表於 24-2-4 23:29
我個人認為，諗都唔好諗。
英國人基本上：
- 有錢又buy寄宿嘅，會送去寄宿私校

都係… 不過我見而家越嚟越多人考慮用BNO visa申請俾小朋友去讀state boarding school而父母唔過去，純粹想送小朋友去英國讀書，但又唔想讀私校咁貴

beastiebistro

wendycyp 發表於 24-2-5 11:31
都係… 不過我見而家越嚟越多人考慮用BNO visa申請俾小朋友去讀state boarding school而父母唔過去，純粹 ...

冇得又要馬兒好，又要馬兒不吃草㗎喇。其實讀state school已經同一般人心目中嘅傳統英式教育（睇電視/電影/睇雜誌/報紙見到嗰隻）完全唔同，嗰隻只有私立寄宿學校先提供到。
我個人認為如果家長唔去又唔想讀私校咁貴，不如留喺香港讀IS。

sleung2020

wendycyp 發表於 24-2-5 11:31
都係… 不過我見而家越嚟越多人考慮用BNO visa申請俾小朋友去讀state boarding school而父母唔過去，純粹 ...

英政府睇緊呢個漏洞，隨時讀讀吓俾人踢走

wendycyp

beastiebistro 發表於 24-2-5 11:56
冇得又要馬兒好，又要馬兒不吃草㗎喇。其實讀state school已經同一般人心目中嘅傳統英式教育（睇電視/電影/ ...

同意，仲有agent公開教人咁做，真心唔明(emoji)(emoji)

wendycyp

sleung2020 發表於 24-2-5 14:06
英政府睇緊呢個漏唔，隨時讀讀吓俾人踢走

咁我又唔知有幾多人真係用呢個方法，希望唔會影響申請緊BNO visa嘅家庭就好

bblove100

回覆 wendycyp 的帖子

讀私校boarding school真十分貴，所以睇下有冇用家分享state boarding school讀書和boarding情況

yuyueng

bblove100 發表於 24-2-15 13:44
回覆 wendycyp 的帖子

讀私校boarding school真十分貴，所以睇下有冇用家分享state boarding school讀書和 ...

唔讀boarding讀day school 平一半，其實第時UK讀大學都唔平。

Poyau

bblove100 發表於 24-2-15 13:44
回覆 wendycyp 的帖子

讀私校boarding school真十分貴，所以睇下有冇用家分享state boarding school讀書和 ...

較整體水平佳的寄宿官校選擇有限

England State Boarding schools
DfE 2023 A level APS(Grade) #13
https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=redirect&goto=findpost&ptid=3879808&pid=49296529

阿熊主人

wendycyp 發表於 24-2-5 11:31
都係… 不過我見而家越嚟越多人考慮用BNO visa申請俾小朋友去讀state boarding school而父母唔過去，純粹 ...

我第一個agent話聽過可以咁做，不過最後佢都補句叫你自己check清楚。第二個agent就好明確話唔可以咁做。

sleung2020

阿熊主人 發表於 24-2-15 21:03
我第一個agent話聽過可以咁做，不過最後佢都補句叫你自己check清楚。第二個agent就好明確話唔可以咁做。 ...

得唔得都好，點解要做蝗蟲去搶人哋福利，除非成家人移民

BBG1

我識有几個bno 去，D仔女都係讀私校。

Poyau

bblove100 發表於 24-2-15 13:44
回覆 wendycyp 的帖子

讀私校boarding school真十分貴，所以睇下有冇用家分享state boarding school讀書和 ...

官校寄宿可參考以下 pdf
Shaftesbury School 無再提供寄宿

https://www.boarding.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/SBF-Parents-Guide-November-2021.pdf

https://www.sast.org.uk/2023/07/06/update-boarding-at-shaftesbury-school/

UPDATE: BOARDING AT SHAFTESBURY SCHOOL

Shaftesbury School’s boarding provision, Barton Hill House, has seen a terminal decline in numbers over recent years resulting in a huge financial strain on the school. Following a public consultation earlier this summer, our proposal to close the boarding house went to the Southwest Advisory Board this week. Having reviewed all the feedback, and financial information, they agreed with our proposal, and made the difficult decision to close the boarding provision.

KIMLIFEINUK

Poyau 發表於 24-2-15 14:43
較整體水平佳的寄宿官校選擇有限

England State Boarding schools

thanks for the link, very helpful.

I was checking the top few schools the other day. The entry grades are quite high, the min requirement is like 38 points for best 5 subjects, 68 points for best 8 subjects etc.

Their a level result is very good. Must be really hard to get in.

小沁

我可分享一些經驗，阿仔讀成績算top嘅grammar school boarding，阿女就係私校寄宿，所以都可比較一下兩者之間分別。grammar school boarding 設施一定唔及私校靚，基本設備有嘅，但簡陋，資源唔多，課外活動基本嘢有囉，但weekend唔會好似私校咁安排晒多元化嘅活動，私校有專人洗熨執床，阿仔就要自己做，始終一分錢一分貨。仔嘅學校老師質素參差，當然我覺得私校都一樣，老師嘅嘢大家明啦，就算香港名校都好多hea教老師(emoji)至於校規我覺得state school較私校寛鬆，校風的確私校較佳，就算阿仔間grammar school成績算好，但學生背景唔及私校優勝，食煙打架都有。

KIMLIFEINUK

小沁 發表於 24-2-27 01:12
我可分享一些經驗，阿仔讀成績算top嘅grammar school boarding，阿女就係私校寄宿，所以都可比較一下兩者之 ...

Thanks for sharing, I am thinking to apply for sixth form boarding, do u mind if I pm you? Thanks in advance!

小沁

KIMLIFEINUK 發表於 24-2-27 04:55
Thanks for sharing, I am thinking to apply for sixth form boarding, do u mind if I pm you? Thanks  ...

阿仔話sixth form會係另一片天，無論成績同品行都會好好多，因為係一次大換血(emoji)如仲有嘢想了解，可pm我(emoji)

sleung2020

阿熊主人 發表於 24-2-15 21:03
我第一個agent話聽過可以咁做，不過最後佢都補句叫你自己check清楚。第二個agent就好明確話唔可以咁做。 ...

政府已經知道呢個漏洞，隨時讀讀吓俾人趕出校