用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 海外留學 香港讀醫vs英國讀醫
查看: 34991|回覆: 35
go

[英國] 香港讀醫vs英國讀醫 [複製鏈接]

Rank: 4


905
1#
發表於 23-12-13 15:58 |只看該作者 |倒序瀏覽 |打印

香港讀醫 or 英國讀醫, how to choose?
   17    0    0    0

Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7


11639
2#
發表於 23-12-13 16:51 |只看該作者
一定系香港

Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14


116759
3#
發表於 23-12-13 17:06 |只看該作者
HelloKitty2003 發表於 23-12-13 15:58
香港讀醫 or 英國讀醫, how to choose?
看你想留在那裏發展

Rank: 13Rank: 13Rank: 13Rank: 13


88779
4#
發表於 23-12-13 21:07 |只看該作者
本帖最後由 Yanamami 於 23-12-13 21:07 編輯

學費、生活費是否需要考慮?否則係UK讀,反正而家香港海外醫生免試,咁進可攻退可守。

Rank: 4


527
5#
發表於 23-12-14 21:40 |只看該作者
Yanamami 發表於 23-12-13 21:07
學費、生活費是否需要考慮?否則係UK讀,反正而家香港海外醫生免試,咁進可攻退可守。 ...

Agree

Rank: 10Rank: 10Rank: 10


29494
6#
發表於 23-12-15 06:40 |只看該作者
我仔英國香港都有報

其實睇你情況,我考慮咗幾樣嘢

1)分數 - 小朋友夠唔夠分入香港嘅大學,英國分數上要求應該無咁高,當然你要過到interview同過到個醫科試。同埋international student只係佔總人數8%。

2)面試,Personal Statement - 佢哋都睇重面試,一般面試post interview rate = 50% 左右, 牛劍就20-30%。仲有要有shadowing experience,哩樣比較難攪。

3)經濟條件 - 英國讀醫學費比其他科貴,應該係4萬多英鎊一年,包埋其他要成HK$70-80萬一年

4)就業 - 要睇清楚政府張清單,大部分比較好嘅大學都可以回港就業,但一定要自己確認一下,唔係報咗先發現唔接受就好煩。 另外英國做醫生人工無香港咁高,亦未必有香港咁高地位。

你今年還是明年報大學?今年就唔好諗咁多,因為應該已經完咗報名時間,有offer再諗啦。

點評

TAIOU4    發表於 24-1-16 13:32

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1637
7#
發表於 23-12-15 12:42 |只看該作者
Yanamami 發表於 23-12-13 21:07
學費、生活費是否需要考慮?否則係UK讀,反正而家香港海外醫生免試,咁進可攻退可守。 ...

Agreed。如果經濟許可,攞英國個牌相對寛好多。香港個牌只可係香港掛牌,甚至出去大灣區除咗中大同港大係大灣區開嗰幾間醫院外,基本上都已經唔可以了。英國個牌起碼係香港、澳洲、新加坡、New Zealand..... 都可以免試註冊執業(香港要留意認可邊幾間大學)

其實讀得醫生,相信本人都係有passion的人,只要幫到人邊度讀同邊度做都應該唔會太計較的。作為父母就只想為小朋友嘅出路盡量爭取到最寛,始終現在成個世界都變得太快了

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11


39847
8#
發表於 23-12-16 00:12 |只看該作者
香港醫科收左,唔讀,去外國讀醫?

香港醫護技術移民會執唔到業?

在香港完成專科訓練嘅有經驗醫生,去外國會執唔到業?

真架?

點評

TAIOU4    發表於 24-1-16 13:33

Rank: 6Rank: 6


8814
9#
發表於 24-5-30 11:43 |只看該作者
細個成日聽到..  香港既醫生係英聯邦醫生

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4262
10#
發表於 24-6-1 02:13 |只看該作者
sp3014 發表於 23-12-15 12:42
Agreed。如果經濟許可,攞英國個牌相對寛好多。香港個牌只可係香港掛牌,甚至出去大灣區除咗中大同港大係 ...

請問澳洲畢業的醫生係咪都可以免試係英聯邦國家執業?

Rank: 3Rank: 3


119
11#
發表於 24-6-9 01:32 |只看該作者
本帖最後由 Gorsila 於 24-6-9 01:51 編輯

回覆 HelloKitty2003 的帖子

香港較經濟,港幣四萬一年,讀六年。
英國不同學校收費不一樣,local fee 除外。
一般英國讀五年,收費四萬幾磅一年,年年加價。未包括生活和住宿費。 Cambridge 讀六年,約七萬磅再加萬多磅 college fee. 亦未包括生活和住宿費。










Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7


12207
12#
發表於 24-6-9 23:12 |只看該作者
本帖最後由 hehehaha2017 於 24-6-9 23:15 編輯

一般來說, 按常理是香港讀醫
第1, 你學費什平

同埋, 你第一年入港大醫科

有機會, 出offer 時, 俾你平  一半學費左右

之後, 到meet 到offer , 大學幫你出埋另一半

你之後, 要寫返封信, 多謝大學

第一年, 幾乎唔洗錢

另外,  醫學院開始降低 醫科獎學金

我印象中, 港大, 考到頭 75%,  可以維持部份獎學金

以前是頭25%

你香港,  讀醫, 你想想

你有可能有工人, 返學搭的士,  飲食, 生活方便, 住屋企
最大 租金 支出是零 , 不用做part time ,  除了生活雜費,  

讀醫, 忙到無時間洗錢, subway 咬個面包就上堂

你外國, 可以搭車,  來回, 之後返到屋企, 無工人, 無家務, 煮個飯

做功課....

好快又一天, 讀書時間 不多



第2, 你北上潮流

但有一樣野, 你唔會北上攪, 就係睇病

因為大陸醫院, 有機會, 你入去

叫你照這樣, 照那樣

無必要的, 都要你照

大陸人會來香港睇醫生

什少香港  返大陸睇醫生

香港人多 自己 同公司醫保,  幾多錢睇病都肯俾的人開始多

特別多了網上保險 公司, 保費什平



英國, 約醫生好難, 有機會, 幾個月才見到

英國醫生供應始終太多

你香港表面開放 外國醫生來香港

根本, 私家執業那些, 根本唔憂做


香港讀醫, 有樣野不好

是 對手太癲,  香港讀醫, 難度非常高, 收生也非常嚴

唯一不好的地方就係咁






5977
13#
發表於 24-6-10 11:23 |只看該作者
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7


12207
14#
發表於 24-6-10 14:11 |只看該作者
本帖最後由 hehehaha2017 於 24-6-10 14:13 編輯
liverpool2023 發表於 24-6-10 11:23
「但有一樣野, 你唔會北上攪, 就係睇病
因為大陸醫院, 有機會, 你入去
叫你照這樣, 照那樣

見到國家醫療已經咁強大, 我哭了
不用考慮 應否買內地醫保

應該係要買,  部份人北上求醫,   香港醫療系統無咁緊張, 事實上是雙贏


香港子女  可以考慮多個 地方讀 醫科了






Rank: 6Rank: 6


9265
15#
發表於 24-6-16 17:08 |只看該作者
一定係香港,抵讀如果收我孩子就好了

Rank: 3Rank: 3


472
16#
發表於 24-7-7 12:53 |只看該作者
大學教授睇症說講 :HKU medicine,Year 1,1st semester已經开始terminated學生 (2024)。入學,唔一定畢到業。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2800
17#
發表於 24-7-8 01:33 |只看該作者
hehehaha2017 發表於 24-6-9 23:12
一般來說, 按常理是香港讀醫
第1, 你學費什平

英國如果醫生供應多,點解難約?

Rank: 12Rank: 12Rank: 12


71936
18#
發表於 24-8-12 15:02 |只看該作者
hehehaha2017 發表於 24-6-9 23:12
一般來說, 按常理是香港讀醫
第1, 你學費什平

兩大醫科 AL 4A* 才算穩
相對英國 G5 及 King's 要求高
不過主力比星星 不用UCAT

Cambridge A*A*A
Oxford A*AA
UCL A*AA
Imperial AAA
King's A*AA

Cambridge
https://www.undergraduate.study.cam.ac.uk/courses/medicine-mb-bchir

Minimum offer level

A level: A*A*A
IB: 41-42 points, with 776 at Higher Level
Other qualifications: Check which other qualifications we accept

You can't apply to this course if you: 

will not be 18 years old on 1 November of year 1. This is due to national restrictions 

have failed or been excluded from another medical school

We strongly recommend:

that you get some work experience before you apply. This can be paid or voluntary, in a health or social care organisation

that you look at free resources available online. See the Medical Schools Council work experience guide for more information

You should also check the  Key Criteria for Medical Admissions.
https://www.undergraduate.study.cam.ac.uk/files/publications/key_criteria_for_medical_admissions.pdf

Subject requirements

To apply to most of our Colleges for Medicine, you will need A level/IB Higher Level or the equivalent in:

Chemistry

2 other science or mathematics subjects from:

Mathematics

Biology or Human Biology

Physics

Further Mathematics

You will usually need A*/7 in Chemistry and another science or mathematics subject.

If you’re taking a science subject not listed above, please contact the College you wish to apply to for advice.

Chemistry, Mathematics and Further Mathematics may not always be the best combination of subjects for this course. Candidates taking these 3 A levels only are advised to contact a College before applying.

To apply to Corpus Christi, Gonville and Caius, Fitzwilliam, Girton, Homerton, Murray Edwards, Newnham, Robinson, or Selwyn, you will need A level/IB Higher Level or the equivalent in:

Chemistry

At least one other science or mathematics subjects from:

Mathematics

Biology or Human Biology

Physics

Further Mathematics

Please note that in the past three admissions rounds, 93% of applicants for Medicine offered three or more science/mathematics A Levels and, of these, 19 per cent were successful in obtaining a place. Of the applicants who offered only two science/mathematics A Levels, fewer than 3% were successful in gaining a place.

You will usually need A*/7 in Chemistry and another science or mathematics subject.

If you’re taking a subject not listed above, please contact the College you wish to apply to for advice.

What Medicine students have studied 

Most Medicine students (who had studied A levels and started at Cambridge in 2018, 2019 and 2023) achieved at least A*A*A* (82% of entrants).

The majority of IB students achieved at least 44 points overall and/or grades 777 at Higher Level. 

All A level entrants had studied Chemistry and almost all had studied at least two of: 

Biology

Further Mathematics

Mathematics 

Physics

Check our advice on choosing your high school subjects. You should also check if there are any required subjects for your course when you apply.

······

Admissions test

You will need to take the University Clinical Aptitude Test.
You will need to register in advance for this test.

Applicants to A100
For UCAT results, we will look at an applicant’s overall cognitive subtest score. We will not be using the situational judgement score as part of our assessment for 2025 entry.
We will use results as part of our selection for interview and when making offers. We will consider your results alongside all the other information we know about you.

Visit our UCAT page for more information.
https://www.undergraduate.study.cam.ac.uk/apply/how/medicine-admission-test

······

Oxford
https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/courses/course-listing/medicine

Course overview

UCAS code: A100
Entrance requirements: A*AA (excluding Critical Thinking and Thinking Skills)
Course duration: 3 years (BA); 6 years (BM BCh)

Subject requirements

Required subjects: Chemistry with either Maths, Further Maths, Biology or Physics.
Recommended subjects: Not applicable
Helpful subjects: Not applicable

Other course requirements

Admissions tests: UCAT
Written Work: None

Admissions statistics*

Interviewed: 23%
Successful: 8%
Intake: 149
*3-year average 2021-23

Contact

Email: [email protected]

Academic requirements 

Qualification 
Requirement

A-levels:
A*AA in three A-levels (excluding Critical Thinking and Thinking Skills) taken in the same academic year. Candidates are required to achieve at least a grade A in both Chemistry and at least one of Biology, Physics, Mathematics or Further Mathematics. We expect you to have taken and passed any practical component in your chosen science subjects.

International Baccalaureate (IB):
39 (including core points) with 766 at HL. Candidates are required to take Chemistry and at least one of Biology, Physics or Mathematics to Higher Level.

······

Admissions test

Test: 

University Clinical Aptitude Test (UCAT)

Test date:

8 July – 26 September 2024 (Applicants must create their own UCAT account and book a test date within this window. Please see our dedicated pages on UCAT for more information)

Registration deadline: 

19 September 2024 (12 noon BST)   

All candidates must also take the University Clinical Aptitude Test (UCAT) as part of their application.

Separate registration for this test is required and it is the responsibility of the candidate to ensure that they are registered.

We strongly recommend making arrangements in plenty of time before the deadline. Please visit our UCAT webpage for further information.

······

UCL
https://www.ucl.ac.uk/medical-school/study/undergraduate/mbbs-admissions/entry-requirements/2025-entry

GCE A-levels

We require three A-levels studied at the same time (which must be completed within two years). The examinations for the three A-levels must be sat at the same time.  We do not accept qualification re-sits, including re-starting Year 12. A-levels from recognised UK examination boards are the only “advanced levels” accepted. Chemistry and Biology must be studied at A-level. The third subject is the student’s own choice and can be any subject other than General Studies or Critical Thinking.

Our standard conditional offer will be grades A*AA to include A*A in Chemistry and Biology, either order.

Contextual Offers: please visit the course webpage for further details about our Access UCL scheme.

We would expect any “extra” qualifications that an applicant has undertaken to be completed and passed.

······

International Baccalaureate

Candidates taking the International Baccalaureate Diploma (IB) must offer three subjects including Chemistry and Biology at Higher Level, plus three subjects at Standard Level.

If Mathematics and English Language are not offered as part of the diploma, they should be offered as GCSE or IGCSE at grade B/6.

Our standard conditional offer will be 39 points out of 45 overall. The grades for the three Higher subjects must make up at least 19 points and must include Biology and Chemistry, with scores 6 and 7, either order. Scores below 5 in any subject are not acceptable.

Contextual Offers: please visit the course webpage for further details about our Access UCL scheme.

······

Imperial
https://www.imperial.ac.uk/study/courses/undergraduate/medicine/

Entry requirements

We consider all applicants on an individual basis, welcoming students from all over the world.

A-levels

Minimum entry standard

AAA

To include:

A in Biology

A in Chemistry

A in a third subject

All qualifications must be taken in the same sitting.

Not accepted: General Studies and Critical Thinking 

Science Practical Endorsement: If you are made an offer you will be required to achieve a pass in the practical endorsement in all science subjects that form part of the offer.

Typical offer

AAA - A*AA (A* in Biology or Chemistry)

Made to at least 80% of A-level applicants in 2023.

······

International Baccalaureate

Minimum entry standard

38 points

To include:

6 in Biology at higher level

6 in Chemistry at higher level

Preferred Mathematics syllabus: Both Applications and Interpretations and Analysis and Approaches are accepted.

Typical offer

39 points

Made to at least 80% of IB applicants in 2023.

Admissions test (UCAT)

From Admissions Cycle 2025–2026

Imperial will utilise University Clinical Aptitude Test (UCAT) for Admissions Cycle entry 2025-2026 onwards, as part of our selection process for entry to Medicine (MBBS – A100). Those who have deferred their entry from 2024-2025 to start in the A100 programme in academic year 2025-2026 will not need to resit UCAT. 

The UCAT

You will need to take the University Clinical Aptitude Test (UCAT) to study this course. 

You must book the test yourself and must only take it once in an admissions cycle. It must be taken in the year that you apply.  

Tests can be taken between July and September. See the University Clinical Aptitude Test website for registration and test dates. We encourage you to book your test slot at local centre as soon as registration opens. 

How we use the UCAT

Applicants who meet the academic threshold are ranked based on their UCAT scores. UCAT cut-off scores are calculated each year, as a result of ranked candidate UCAT scores versus number of expected interview sessions. As a result, the absolute UCAT cut-off changes each year. 

All candidates will be required to score a minimum threshold in each subsection: Verbal Reasoning, Decision Making, Quantitative Reasoning, Abstract Reasoning and Situational Judgement, as well as achieve or exceed the set total sum of subsection scores. UCAT ANZ results will be considered.

All candidates who attend the test are declaring that they are fit to sit the test. If circumstances occur which might affect performance, candidates are encouraged to refer to the UCAT Fitness to Test Policy. If accepted, Pearson Vue who administrate UCAT may give you the opportunity to retake the test. Minor test issues will be communicated to the Medical School.  We were not able to consider special circumstances for anyone who did not communicate them to Pearson Vue.  

For those students identified as Widening Participation, have declared carer status, or involved in Imperial Outreach programme, an adjustment will be applied to the set total sum of subsection scores. The adjustment reflected the overall difference in performance between flagged and non.

The UCAT score will be used to help rank candidates to invite for interview. We anticipate inviting the top third [approximately] ranked candidates to interview.

As this is our first year using UCAT, we are not able to provide a minimum threshold score for 2025 entry.

In line with past BMAT thresholds, our final cut offs vary every year depending on the cohort’s set of results. Contextual, non-contextual and Overseas variance in the thresholds may also apply.

King's
https://www.kcl.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/courses/medicine-mbbs

Subject requirements

Required subjects:

Chemistry and Biology

Preferred subjects:

No preferred subjects

A-Levels

Required grades:

A*AA

Please note that A-level General Studies, Critical Thinking, Thinking Skills and Global Perspectives are not accepted by King's as one of your A levels.

Must include grade A in Biology and Chemistry.

Notes:
If you are taking linear A-levels in England, you will be required to pass the practical endorsement in all Science subjects. This is with the exception of private candidates who are unable to take the practical component.

We do not consider the EPQ at any point of the assessment process.

All applicants must take the UCAT. Please see further details below.

International Baccalaureate

35 points including 766 at Higher Level

Must include grade 6 in Higher Level Biology and Chemistry.

Notes:
The total point score of 35 includes TOK/EE.

GCSE/IGCSE English Language and Mathematics requirement can be met via IB Standard Level/Middle Years grade 5, if not studied/studying at Higher Level

All applicants must take the UCAT. Please see further details below.

······

Rank: 10Rank: 10Rank: 10


29494
19#
發表於 24-8-12 17:20 |只看該作者
英國讀醫難在2個位
1. 考UCAT BMAT (明年無BMAT) - 因為每年每間學校收唔到10%國際生,所以cut-off grade高,local考 2800 (UCAT) 或10 (BMAT),國際生要3000 或 13。以上為排名比香港好或差不多嘅醫學院。
2. Interview - 如果唔係英國當地長大,又或者唔習慣受壓下interview,可能難handle。
以上是我見阿仔今年報大學經驗,不一定啱,純分享。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4916
20#
發表於 24-8-12 17:34 |只看該作者
Joe8889 發表於 24-8-12 17:20
英國讀醫難在2個位
1. 考UCAT BMAT (明年無BMAT) - 因為每年每間學校收唔到10%國際生,所以cut-off grade ...

英國醫學院大部分用MMI interview, 請問CUHK和HKU醫科面試係點樣呀?兩個教授對一個考生?問醫學野?
‹ 上一主題|下一主題
返回列表
發新帖 回覆
你需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 註冊