mscps 九龍塘瑪利諾小學有如地獄？

PTL_L

gabejang 發表於 23-6-19 09:58
聽落感覺上同MPS 好相似

兩間以前係姐妹校，所以校章、校舍同教學風格都好似，但mcs dse成績一直都比mss好，原因同Ls sjc嘅係一樣。

gabejang

PTL_L 發表於 23-6-21 22:38
兩間以前係姐妹校，所以校章、校舍同教學風格都好似，但mcs dse成績一直都比mss好，原因同Ls sjc嘅係一樣。 ...

係？係咩原因？我心目中sjc 同ls 差不多哈哈

PTL_L

gabejang 發表於 23-6-22 12:26
係？係咩原因？我心目中sjc 同ls 差不多哈哈

地理問題啦，你諗諗mss 、 sjc附近嘅學校同mcs 、lsc附近嘅學校係邊類？港島區傳統單性名校多，就灣仔區女校都5間，仲有中西區3間呢？都未計聖心、嘉諾撒喇，sjc附近男校都3間，未計勁野spcc,QC呢啲，港島區有幾大？分薄哂叻仔叻女。又諗下如果住新界嘅叻仔叻女，如入好多lsc嘅沙呂，你估佢父母想小朋友出九龍塘定去金鐘返學？mcs lsc名氣可以吸納埋新界區嘅小朋友。

zebrama

俾唔到乜嘢意見，但係朋友女兒真實例子，可以作參考


朋友女兒，有大女及細女，大女讀私Happy school (學費都貴，有中學的，啟發型），而細女就讀Mcs, 細女讀書都叻，但性格好怪，可能學校女校又有小圈子，到家姐升中學考番細妹中學，佢話分別好大，話學校嗰啲唔知老師定修女，成日鬧人，唔係鬧人都學習氣氛麻麻地．．

媽咪就客觀嘅，話始終兩間學校唔同文化，冇話邊啲好邊啲唔好，當然學費係冇咁大負擔，加上又係名津校，所以叫大女適應一下

Adrio77

回覆 Jean1769 的帖子

男女co ed 也要看中学老師是否包融、耐心和多元化flexible.  就算,是馬利諾后面全條街也是一線中学、校長、輔訓和紀律老師也幾守舊、因循.  就算學風、學界名聲好、當你收到校聯絡、都是好無愛心只顧校方行政.  千萬不要只看開学早會。聽起來，真給他們騙了

chanti

PTL_L 發表於 23-6-21 22:38
兩間以前係姐妹校，所以校章、校舍同教學風格都好似，但mcs dse成績一直都比mss好，原因同Ls sjc嘅係一樣。 ...

Yes Marymount 以前叫Maryknoll sisters’ school , 再早期創校時叫Holy Spirit School

Poyau

gabejang 發表於 23-6-19 09:58
聽落感覺上同MPS 好相似

About MSS > History

https://www.mss.edu.hk/en/content.php?wid=23

Marymount, originally known as Holy Spirit School for girls, was founded by the Maryknoll Sisters. The school opened on 10th January 1927 at Robinson Road with only 8 classes of students sharing 4 tiny classrooms. In 1930, the school moved to the building at 140 Caine Road which provided 7 classrooms. By 1941, it offered a complete course of studies leading to matriculation. The school was closed during the war. It re-opened as Maryknoll School in 1948.

As the school continued to expand, a school building with improved facilities became necessary. In October 1957, the school moved to its present location in Happy Valley and was renamed Maryknoll Sisters School. Initially, the building housed both Secondary and Primary Sections. It was not until 1961 that the Primary School occupied the premise at Tai Hang Road. During the school year 1978-79, after 52 years of devoted service, the Maryknoll Sisters handed over the sponsorship of the school to the Columban Sisters.

As of September 1983, the name of the school was changed to Marymount Secondary School and Marymount Primary School respectively. By 1993, to meet the needs of increasing student population in the Secondary School, the Columban Sisters turned over to the use of the school the remaining convent area on the fourth floor.
In 1996, the Columban Sisters initiated the transfer of the sponsorship of the school to the Christian Life
Community (CLC), the process of which was completed by September 1997. The CLC is an international Catholic lay community with a keen interest in education and commitment to the service of youth. The CLC has pledged to preserve the same school spirit, foster the traditions and continue to provide quality education at Marymount.

The Secondary School operated up to 29 classes with over 1000 students until 1998, offering arts, science and social disciplines up to Form 7. With the restructuring of the school, the total number of classes will be at 26 by the year 2003. The Primary School operates 24 classes and has about 900 students.

p181013

(emoji)(emoji)(emoji)

mikkbb

用家有緣經過分享一下，供其他人參考

一年班好輕鬆，然後逐漸遞增 (都好正常)，學校校長同大部分老師都係好關愛，我見我女一見到校長就同佢打招呼同攬住佢，可見校長幾受學生歡迎同愛戴，雖然係津校，但學校好鼓勵學生多元發展，電子教學部分亦都多⋯舉個例子，中文除咗書本、作業、工作紙，亦有學古詩文、說話訓練等，其他科亦是，常識同science都有project 同presentation要做⋯學校成績表無名次、無精英班⋯考試前會有d talk、提示卡提醒學生家長正面處理壓力⋯每次考試考4日，學校都會喺中間放一日假，等小朋友可以回一回氣，我覺得好人性化，同埋有輔導班⋯雖然係名校，但感覺無話偏重成績好嘅學生⋯同埋學校及家長教師會都搞好多活動⋯學校生活都幾忙碌⋯

高小比較chur，可能間間學校到呈分試都係咁上下⋯我朋友話佢聽講好輕鬆無乜功課⋯都唔知喺邊度聽返嚟⋯ 唔可以話好多，但一定唔係少同輕鬆⋯不過當然都要睇小朋友，如果小朋友好定自律做功課，咁一定無問題⋯

All in all, 唔同意道聽途說嘅「有如地獄」，如果咁都叫地獄，咁可能係地獄第一層，而出面嘅仲有好多地獄十八層

天外之人

回覆 chamster 的帖子

喺EK睇下了解下好正常,衹可以相信一半,另一半要自己去了解先好,小學能夠開心讀書,其實邊間都可以,我衹可以講好谷既原因,大部份其實都係家長比小朋友的.

itckei2003

唔洗錢, 學校唔谷, 學生背景好, 英文小學, 每年都有勁人插班, 老師算係有愛心, 同學之間關係不錯.

我就好滿​​意, 小女都好滿意.

HK-CR7

天外之人 發表於 24-3-13 10:47
回覆 chamster 的帖子

喺EK睇下了解下好正常,衹可以相信一半,另一半要自己去了解先好,小學能夠開心讀書,其 ...

其實好多負評都係啲無讀過憑印象既評論 呢個級數既學校仲要左諗右諗 咁多年track record唔信 信埋啲所謂朋友既負評
其實好多一線名校都唔谷 都係家長谷

其實遇到呢啲負評 好直接問返提出者一句 你讀過未？多數都無聲出(emoji)

bighero

chamster 發表於 23-6-17 09:06
近年見好少人講，有打算將女兒送去哩到讀書，但引來身邊好多朋友討論，並且作出好多負面評價？！

請問有冇 ...

咁好既女神校都話唔好?

Catnat

我有兩個女，細果個讀MCSPS，大果個讀谷谷三寶。

以讀書0黎講，MCSPS係易好多，冇升學壓力，大部份小朋友都讀得輕鬆，英文流利，用英文教數學十分難得，方便銜接中學或者赴遠方升學的數學課程，當然中文略遜色，同時預咗升到高小就要著緊些準備呈分試。到谷谷三寶果邊，測驗同默書密度、幅度同深度多近50%，依然係一大班同學游刄有餘，又有些同學係要拉牛上樹。

另外，呢幾年MCSPS 都有好多與時並進的措施同教學安排，同埋有大量多元化活動(由多樣化的ECA到STEM同Fun day, Art fair, Dance night等等)。同樣比較下，大女的谷谷三寶ECA由興趣班到各種運動校隊/樂團都應有盡有。

我覺得MCSPS係一間不可多得0既百年名校，然而小朋友的性格和長短處各有不同，又冇話個個都一定適合某間特定學校。反而無論去邊間學校，一班同學各有千秋，成績或比賽排名會有先後，遇到高低起伏時，家長們同小朋友勿忘初心，多些互勵互勉。

jennylady

啊仔同學媽咪話，mscps 程度淺LSPS 好多
名校來講算好輕鬆
St Mary 谷好多。

sainsbury

chamster 發表於 23-6-17 09:06
近年見好少人講，有打算將女兒送去哩到讀書，但引來身邊好多朋友討論，並且作出好多負面評價？！

請問有冇 ...

英文程度、禮儀氣質甚至學界成績，現今嘅MCS相對當年梁詠琪年代嘅MCS確實差咗好多（Source: 一手用家和現職教師），但相對現今其他學校比可能仍然有優勢，視乎家長本身嘅expectation同position。