如何解讀A level result？

babadogcat

大家好，希望請教

見Warwick school A level A*~A 係大約66%

Oundle school A*~A 係 67%
D’overbroeck’s 也差不多6X%

見個result 差唔多係咪已經可以理解他們屬於同grade 學校？

問過agent：因為現在學校A*~A為4x%左右，應該找些成績明顯與現在差距更多的例如OIC.  但係個人比較喜歡傳統學校，可惜年齡上孩子比同級大了一年，選擇上有所限制，可能真係Sixth form college 只會接受申請。

唔該先

3b

babadogcat 發表於 23-5-15 18:36
大家好，希望請教

見Warwick school A level A*~A 係大約66%

或者以你想修讀的學科成績作比較， 而不是單純睇平均數

babadogcat

3b 發表於 23-5-15 19:46
或者以你想修讀的學科成績作比較， 而不是單純睇平均數

多謝你提點

beastiebistro

babadogcat 發表於 23-5-15 18:36
大家好，希望請教

見Warwick school A level A*~A 係大約66%

個人認為睇學校整體成績無咩意義。

1. 除非一間學校100% A*-A，否則即係一定有人考得好有人考得唔好。冇咩學校識變魔術，會將一個明明攞C嘅學生變成攞A*，亦冇咩學校會將一個明明攞A*嘅學生教到攞C。一間學校嘅平均成績係40%A*-A唔等如你個小朋友只得40%攞A*-A，或者老師能力只能教到40%攞A*-A。唔好神化啲數據。

2. Agent梗係叫你去OIC，佢收最多commission吖嘛。但係呢啲變相補習學校A工廠，除咗操卷之外冇咩structured嘅寄宿體驗。我認為嘥晒去英國嘅經驗。

3. 如果好「港式」咁齋攞成績嚟比較學校嘅好壞，咁實在會miss咗太多好學校。例如你舉例嗰三間，其實計local reputation，得Oundle係比較出名嘅傳統英式寄宿學校。Warwick School雖然歷史悠久，但係相對上係地區性學校，而且寄宿比例奇低。而D'overbroecks到幾年前都仲係一間sixth form college。兩間喺local reputation方面都同Oundle冇得比，夾硬要話佢哋因為平均成績相近就當係水平相近嘅學校，損失就大喇。

如果你小朋友喺現時學校讀得開心，又覺得學校教得唔錯，根本冇需要轉校。如果一定要搵學校轉，咁搵間local reputation高啲寄宿體驗好啲嘅轉啦，唔好盲目睇整體成績。

babadogcat

beastiebistro 發表於 23-5-15 20:19
個人認為睇學校整體成績無咩意義。

1. 除非一間學校100% A*-A，否則即係一定有人考得好有人考得唔好。冇咩 ...

真係好多謝你咁詳細分享，好珍貴！孩子自己要求去找些可以chur 少少的學校令自己做更好，或者佢好淸楚自己如果再比人逼下，同其他同學的學習氣氛會更好，所以向我提出。
而Warwick school 係因為會搬去附近，佢可以返屋企所以我留意一下，當然佢繼續寄宿，我哋也好願意。

再次多謝你

Poyau

babadogcat 發表於 23-5-15 18:36
大家好，希望請教

見Warwick school A level A*~A 係大約66%

三校2022年 A level 成績差不多
Oundle A* 比例較另外兩間高
最好看看心儀科目各校往績如何

2022 A level A* | A*-A | A*-B
----------------------------------------------------------
Oundle School 35% 65% 87%
d'Overbroeck's 31% 66% 87%
Warwick School 32.1% 66.3% 87.1%

DfE 2022 A level APS(Grade) | AAB^
----------------------------------------------------------
Oundle School 48.66(A) | 46.6%
d'Overbroeck's 47.74(A-) | 32.1%
Warwick School 47.73(A-) | 48.1%

Independent schools 45.61(A-) | 39.7%

^ % of students achieving ≥AAB for a min. of 2 facilitating A level subjects

Oundle School
https://www.oundleschool.org.uk/academic/examination-results/

https://www.find-school-performance-data.service.gov.uk/school/122129/oundle-school/16-to-18/advanced-level-qualifications?accordionstate=0

d'Overbroeck's
https://www.doverbroecks.com/a-level-results/

https://www.doverbroecks.com/news/a-level-results-2022/

https://www.find-school-performance-data.service.gov.uk/school/123318/d'overbroeck's/16-to-18/advanced-level-qualifications?accordionstate=0

Warwick School
https://www.warwickschool.org/alevel-results

https://www.find-school-performance-data.service.gov.uk/school/125781/warwick-school/16-to-18/advanced-level-qualifications?accordionstate=0

babadogcat

Poyau 發表於 23-5-15 20:56
三校2022年 A level 成績差不多
Oundle A* 比例較另外兩間高
最好看看心儀科目各校往績如何

多謝，會再仔細研究

Poyau

babadogcat 發表於 23-5-15 21:05
多謝，會再仔細研究

不用客氣
想有傳統寄宿體驗考慮 Oundle

Boarding ratio
----------------------------------------------------------
Oundle School 73.63%(835/1,134)
d'Overbroeck's 42.45%^(315/742)
Warwick School 4.42%^(55/1,243)

^ Incl Weekly/Flexi boarding

Oundle School
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/northamptonshire/peterborough/oundle-school/

Day/boarding type: Day and Full Boarding
Gender profile: Coeducational
Size: 1134

Oundle School fees:

Boarding fees per term:
£10,705 to £14,090
Day fees per term:
£6,865 to £9,025
Scholarships & bursaries:
Available

ISC reference number:
71122
DfE reference number:
940 / 6007

Boys - age range & pupil numbers:
Day: 11 to 18 (158)
Boarding: 11 to 18 (500)
Sixth form: (237)

Girls - age range & pupil numbers:
Day: 11 to 18 (141)
Boarding: 11 to 18 (335)
Sixth form: (173)

d'Overbroeck's
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/oxfordshire/oxford/doverbroecks/

Day/boarding type: Day, Weekly/Flexible Boarding and Full Boarding
Gender profile: Coeducational
Size: 742

d'Overbroeck's fees:

Boarding fees per term:
£13,480 to £17,330
Day fees per term:
£6,650 to £10,655
Scholarships & bursaries:
Available

ISC reference number:
36194
DfE reference number:
931 / 6104

Boys - age range & pupil numbers:
Day: 11 to 18 (232)
Boarding: 13 to 18 (138)
Sixth form: (172)

Girls - age range & pupil numbers:
Day: 11 to 18 (195)
Boarding: 13 to 18 (177)
Sixth form: (248)

Warwick School
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/warwickshire/warwick/warwick-school/

Day/boarding type: Day, Weekly/Flexible Boarding and Full Boarding
Gender profile: Boys only
Size: 1243

Warwick School fees:

Boarding fees per term:
£9,970 to £12,159
Day fees per term:
£4,319 to £5,042
Scholarships & bursaries:
Available

ISC reference number:
43651
DfE reference number:
937 / 6020

Boys - age range & pupil numbers:
Day: 7 to 18 (1188)
Boarding: 13 to 18 (55)
Sixth form: (286)

beastiebistro

babadogcat 發表於 23-5-15 20:41
真係好多謝你咁詳細分享，好珍貴！孩子自己要求去找些可以chur 少少的學校令自己做更好，或者佢好淸楚自己 ...

好嘅英國學校，着重鼓勵學生自學，就算我仔嘅學校整體成績算好好啦，都冇逼呢樣嘢㗎喎。

逼／競爭呢啲咁「港式」嘅氛圍，可能喺啲補習sixth form A工廠先會有喇。如果你小朋友覺得要人逼先可以發揮嘅，咁佢真係可能要去啲A工廠讀書喇。

Having said that，我冇話唔應該aim higher。只係就算要aim higher都唔好靠睇學校過去嗰年嘅整體成績去篩選，成績呢啲嘢年年都可以變，但係學校多年累積嘅reputation係唔會變乜滯嘅。

我個人再次建議，唔好睇數據揀學校。

Poyau

寄宿比例過半男女校有不少選擇
看看 Oundle 外有無其他心儀

Wellington College
Canford School
Oundle School
Uppingham School
Marlborough College

Haileybury
Chaterhouse
Rugby School
Shrewsbury School
Cranleigh School

King's Canterbury
Bradfield College
St Edward's Oxford
......

England Co-ed Boarding Schools #50
https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=redirect&goto=findpost&ptid=3866111&pid=49231668

beastiebistro

babadogcat 發表於 23-5-15 20:41
真係好多謝你咁詳細分享，好珍貴！孩子自己要求去找些可以chur 少少的學校令自己做更好，或者佢好淸楚自己 ...

既然你搬去Warwick附近，咁你應該睇睇我母校Rugby school喇。傳統9大公學之一，local reputation夠晒高但香港唔多人識，因為唔鍾意同agent合作唔俾commission。而且係全寄宿比例高嘅學校，但係又有兩成走讀生，兩種選擇都有。

964000

beastiebistro 發表於 23-5-15 20:19
個人認為睇學校整體成績無咩意義。

1. 除非一間學校100% A*-A，否則即係一定有人考得好有人考得唔好。冇咩 ...

我朋友的孩子就是Oundle 畢業，大讚，science 強，男女校，他說高度推介.

beastiebistro

964000 發表於 23-5-15 21:40
我朋友的孩子就是Oundle 畢業，大讚，science 強，男女校，他說高度推介.

確實係好學校，根本同另外兩間唔同級數...
所以我成日都話，列晒啲數據／睇數據嘅，永遠唔會揀到好學校...

Poyau

babadogcat 發表於 23-5-15 18:36
大家好，希望請教

見Warwick school A level A*~A 係大約66%

Oundle 學術佳 寄宿比例高 值得考慮
學校俱相當教學水平 同儕可互勉互勵
如本身成績可考入A工廠
去 Oundle 應同樣可取佳績

babadogcat

beastiebistro 發表於 23-5-15 21:18
既然你搬去Warwick附近，咁你應該睇睇我母校Rugby school喇。傳統9大公學之一，local reputation夠晒高但香 ...

已經問左，年紀大了一年唔收了(emoji)

babadogcat

Poyau 發表於 23-5-15 22:21
Oundle 學術佳 寄宿比例高 值得考慮
學校俱相當教學水平 同儕可互勉互勵
如本身成績可考入A工廠

再次感謝解說

phoebenam

我仔都係咁講，A工廠出得多A*，係因為佢收嘅學生本身成績好，而唔係學校令到佢地攞A

babadogcat

phoebenam 發表於 23-5-16 19:12
我仔都係咁講，A工廠出得多A*，係因為佢收嘅學生本身成績好，而唔係學校令到佢地攞A ...

多謝你和仔仔意見

phoebenam

babadogcat 發表於 23-5-16 20:28
多謝你和仔仔意見

唔洗客氣，不過我仔都係揀左A工廠讀a level

sumikogurashi

phoebenam 發表於 23-5-16 19:12
我仔都係咁講，A工廠出得多A*，係因為佢收嘅學生本身成績好，而唔係學校令到佢地攞A ...

但學校係咪會加力操卷和個個星期quiz ?