ISF vs 學之園

Jane1983

點會tough decision? 一間行國際，一間考本地學校，完全兩樣嘢。家長想小朋友行咩路呢？自己唔想清楚，要一個幼童讀兩間幼稚園，日日係街上或車上食lunch 和換校服趕下場。令你為難的，竟然只是logistics 的安排  

gfkwong

好易選。想去傳統名校定國際先？

kittykuma

willyg 發表於 20-3-6 18:57
My son is currently in LH N class (am) and secured K1 place for 20-21. We just got ISF Y1 (pm) offer ...

你有同時返兩間的心，我想學之園比較適合你

yohan

if you are well prepared, apply a few more IS for primary and not just aiming for the top IS, I think it should be easier than the local P1 application.  (afterall IS P1 interviews are unlikely to have 3 or 4 interviews in each school)

Do include some nurturing but not highly saught after IS. Although I think ISF will still give offers to majority of their kindy kids (i went to their open day last year and they sounded reassuring then)

964000

willyg 發表於 20-3-6 18:57
My son is currently in LH N class (am) and secured K1 place for 20-21. We just got ISF Y1 (pm) offer ...

Depends on what you aim for.
ISF kinder is for targeting ISF primary mainly, it may not provide enough English environment for targeting IS cuz it’s 30% English and 70% Chinese if you cannot provide extra English outside school.
ISF is more like a bilingual school rather than IS, so I think you can probably still apply for local schools at P1 if you wish later after you get into ISF foundation. They even teach maths in eng and chi and got quite a lot of homework compare to IS.

Saboc

回覆 willyg 的帖子

Really too much!!! 每年都有 小數家長會有咁嘅諗法，真係恐怖

Saboc

其實我都有見過有小朋友的讀咗兩間幼稚園，但慢慢上到小學其實 佢表現並唔係特別突出

Jane1983

回覆 Saboc 的帖子

仲想突出？唔厭學都偷笑了。

Saboc

回覆 Jane1983 的帖子

係，佢比較曳， 但我相信同佢讀兩間幼稚園無关，主要係反映parenting 發生咗問題. 如果係因為家長自己未諗定或者又想呢有想嗰啲， 過多想滿足嘅要求，小朋友就會高不成低不就

Jane1983

回覆 Saboc 的帖子

咁既安排，有行為問題都好正常。試過幾次係街，見到d工人和小朋友坐係路邊餵飯，兩個書包放係隔離，準備趕下場。流離浪蕩，好淒涼。
如果你要你配偶，日日返兩份工，中午趕到趕命食飯，跟住係商場公廁換衫返工。為的係你未諗清楚，想買個保險，佢唔反臉！？

Activehealth

Jane1983 發表於 20-3-7 16:45
回覆 Saboc 的帖子

咁既安排，有行為問題都好正常。試過幾次係街，見到d工人和小朋友坐係路邊餵飯，兩個書 ...

識有個小朋友，讀幼稚園時上晝讀本地普通話幼稚園，下晝讀國際幼稚園。

佢有一架七人車連司機及一個外傭貼身照顧。上完上晝堂之後，司機直接送至下一站，途中在七人車食晏午睡，再換另一套校服上國際幼稚園，無投訴辛苦。

之後入國際小學Y1（全日際），話放學後好得閒唔知做乜好，阿媽要安排N樣課後活動。

當然，大前提下要有咁嘅資源人手安排。如果無，就唔好攞個小朋友較飛。

mindfulmom

willyg 發表於 20-3-6 18:57
My son is currently in LH N class (am) and secured K1 place for 20-21. We just got ISF Y1 (pm) offer ...

For ISF, you at least got higher chance to enter ISF Primary. No priority to any primary school for LH. Unless you have other priorities like parent alumni or sibling, I'll go for the one with backup.

gfkwong

ISF 好似係80%以上去小學，都算好大，LH無保障，而且越開越多，其實個個都想入男拔coed,加埋得幾百個位，大部分人都考唔到神校。

safeway

kittykuma 發表於 20-3-6 22:12
你有同時返兩間的心，我想學之園比較適合你

Can’t agree more!!!
如果再多這類家長在IS, 真係會搞亂個生態

細佬Bebe

學之園本身都好chur 好多活動功課
Isf都唔係hea既國際學校 入得去既同學仔都勁勁想升上去

兩間個環境要求都咁chur
返哂兩間 真係全家都癲

與其返哂兩間 不如揀好一條路 將啲精力好好咁行個條路啦

點解要有保障呢個concept? 點解唔對自己既選擇同小朋友有啲信心？

rat2020

Isf 其實係少於80% 入到academy,因為係Kindergarden 會不停勸退or deferred kids. 去提升入學率(acedamy).isf 幼稚園係K1嘅時候已經會開始勸退細B及不停叫家長聘請tutor! 還會不停叫家長反思為何你請的tutor跟不上學校進度!(但其實Isf Pre school 嘅內容係偏淺)只係中文要求比較高.所以當中有很多家長發現中途不合適但係都要忍受因為很難再轉校,因為佢英文程度其他國際學校都不再接受！（曾經的用家上）己轉其他國際學校

cris01

回覆 willyg 的帖子

We are in the same situation. Got ISF K offer, but may choose to stay in current school because the drop out rate of ISF K and Academy is very high compared to other schools. There seems to be a lot of complaint about ISF from the current/past parents, which makes us quite scared to take the offer..we don't want our child to keep switching schools. What was your decision in the end?

JanetCMC

請留意新會員
請留意新會員
請留意新會員
（重要事情要講3次）