- 在線時間
- 329 小時
- 最後登錄
- 20-6-30
- 國民生產力
- 5
- 附加生產力
- 1840
- 貢獻生產力
- 0
- 註冊時間
- 14-10-13
- 閱讀權限
- 10
- 帖子
- 763
- 主題
- 0
- 精華
- 0
- 積分
- 2608
- UID
- 1682362
|
shadeslayer 發表於 20-1-29 21:54
簡單答:「主觀是真的話是真話,客觀是真的話也是真話」唔係定義,係我對stillgood20的回應,解釋真話可以 ...
OK,原來係捉呢個「定義過狹」。但你要留意,係佢定義出問題,忽略客觀呢一面。一般人聽到真話,有人只是想到真心說話,有人想到講實事求是的說話,這不關真話本身的定義太闊太窄。好像我說整數,他只說偶數,我說有奇數,你說我放大定義。
\\「主觀是真的話是真話」是明顯過份廣義。主觀就是自己的觀感,世上無人知道其他人的主觀感覺。即係任何人的主觀也沒辦法被証明真假。....\\
I'm getting to know where you're stuck at.
「主觀是真的話是真話」這句要解作:主觀是真\的\(說)話 the saying is in good faith,不能解作:(假如)主觀是真\的話 if the saying is true in one's eyes.
我上面說明,你要分開 fact and opinion。 fact is objective and opinion is subjective. There isn't true or false for subjective statements but they are either honest or dishonest.
Shadeslayer is handsome - true or false? I don't think stillgood20 can say even though he so honestly admires you, unless he saw your pictures or met you before. And then that's his own opinion.
Shadeslayer is stubborn - true or false? I don't think all people would agree if not excluding you.
|
|