瑪利曼 VS 天神

Sing13

簡單而言，如果打算出國，就選mps，話晒都是英文小學，往績大概有一半人唔會讀到尾，如果打算考DSE，就選天神，一條龍，起碼中文科都放心啲.

cafeva

Sing13 發表於 19-8-9 02:30
簡單而言，如果打算出國，就選mps，話晒都是英文小學，往績大概有一半人唔會讀到尾，如果打算考DSE，就選天 ...

只可以話MPS學生多出路啫。
睇返小學部，兩間網頁都幾多野睇。

elbar

celiaxue 發表於 19-8-2 20:45
小女考插班試，宜家瑪利曼小學和天神嘉諾撒都收佐，屋企係將軍澳，唔知選邊間，請各位指教。
...

Marymount  

baby1206

Vote for marymount

Anna媽媽

回覆 celiaxue 的帖子

請問是插幾年班？今年插P2學校話無位

halvard

The reason why there is a significant difference in the number of students in S1 and S6 is because many students left the school for IS or went abroad between S3-5.  Its nothing to do with the school, just that these families have other targets and they need to leave the school early in order to be able to catch up with their new schools and have goood results in public exams.
Students in MPS or MSS come from a very wide spectrum, there are very wealthy families but at the same time there are also grassroots families yet many can become goood friends despite the differences in backgrounds.

There are students in MPS going to DGS and St Paul Co-ed, but that is only a very small number.

From what I know, students who are academically sound normally will go abroad and further their studies, and that could not be reflected in the DSE results. (there are graduates from oxford, cambridge, Edinburgh in uk, MIT, UPenn, Cornell, Johns Hopkins in US, etc)

I have no understanding on 天神 but I have many friends who are ‘st marians’. If you are talking about their level of English, it is without a doubt that MSS is definitely better, no matter in terms of verbal delivery or written English as the majority are well equipped since MPS and a very strong foundation is laid.  It is right that many speak native English and it is so easy to outshine others when it comes to speaking. But it is also true that MSS’ Level of Chinese is weak, and students are not as academically aggressive because this is never what MSS or MPS values.

cafeva

halvard 發表於 19-11-5 21:14
The reason why there is a significant difference in the number of students in S1 and S6 is because m ...

有咁多入世界名U嗎？每年都有？果D學生係咪去外國升高中？

halvard

回覆 cafeva 的帖子

i dunno the exact numbers as I havent done a questionnaire on that, but I am pretty certain at least over 15-20 are in those schools PER YEAR.  The school wont do a statistics on that, because that's never what the school thinks is important.  The most important thing is each girl in MSS will grow and blossom, just in a different way.

US and UK unis are always more popular and those that I named are just SOME of them, and I haven't yet mentioned those in Canada and Australia.

The thing is, many families in MSS are pretty well off, sparing over HK300k a year to study abroad is not a problem for many.

There are students going for international schools but thats not the majority, rather the minority of those leaving the school. The majority of those leaving  are really leaving the city and went abroad. Coz the thing is, if you are financially sufficient, why not go directly to the country u aim at pursuing her studies to start early? If they go for international schools, those are HKIS, GSIS, CIS, Li Po Chun and some to island schools in ESF which are very good IS in HK. The families have good networks and are rich, and the reason they stay maybe because their girls don't want to leave yet, or their families wish to spend more time with their children.

b3410

朋友囡囡讀MPS，happy school, 初小讀的好開心。已經到高小，開始擔心，打算明年去插班IS，對DSE冇信心，因為中文實在太。。。。。

mcl203

b3410 發表於 19-11-6 09:32
朋友囡囡讀MPS，happy school, 初小讀的好開心。已經到高小，開始擔心，打算明年去插班IS，對DSE冇信心，因 ...

Marymount既風格係輕鬆，非戰鬥型，英強中弱係難以避免。又咁講，相對弱既仍然3322率唔錯，同GHS似乎差唔多㗎～～～

至於中文，所謂家長擔心小朋友中文，又事實，當部份家長一早行為上接受中文差，又放任小朋友中文差，早已有轉IS或中學初中放洋，中文弱係難以改善，小朋友當然會選擇最輕鬆既路行，反正都唔會考DSE，往績流失率高係有原因～～～

cafeva

mcl203 發表於 19-11-6 10:54
Marymount既風格係輕鬆，非戰鬥型，英強中弱係難以避免。又咁講，相對弱既仍然3322率唔錯，同GHS似乎差唔 ...

18年DSE 中文4+ 成6X%, 咁算弱咩?
聽樓上講入名U數字, 直情係比想像中更強喎!

mcl203

cafeva 發表於 19-11-6 11:06
18年DSE 中文4+ 成6X%, 咁算弱咩?
聽樓上講入名U數字, 直情係比想像中更強喎!

英強中弱，弱既意思係相對既比較，所以咪有同GHS差唔多既觀察囉。中文既5+，4+，比大部份中學還好吧～

至於中文程度，係小學階段觀察，係真係比較弱，始終學校係英小，全英教學（除左中文和RE/PE)，學生係重英輕中，係比同級中小弱好多既。始終如先前所說，部分家長早有放洋計劃，放任態度，又如何可以令小朋友唔放棄中文呢。

不過，去到高中又計劃留港升學，就另一種行為，始終都會谷一谷去考DSE。仲有，中學部係似乎有部份位係去收國際學生，佢哋中文係有先天弱勢。

annie133

halvard 發表於 19-11-6 09:18
回覆 cafeva 的帖子

i dunno the exact numbers as I havent done a questionnaire on that, but I am pre ...

不是這樣計的，一般不會計離開了學校的人，個D已經入左人地數了，學校留不留到勁人也是參考指標，不是人人想出國。如計MSS本身畢業生有多少入了top U，我見一年畢業生才3成人外國大學，總數都係廿人到，我估不會很多。
不過一樣野可以肯定，MSS的校友真的很愛學校，很多fans.

cafeva

annie133 發表於 19-11-6 14:00
不是這樣計的，一般不會計離開了學校的人，個D已經入左人地數了，學校留不留到勁人也是參考指標，不是人人 ...

咁又奇啦, 話MSS DSE 好, 3大成5X%, 你話人地少人考DSE要'著草'. 而家有人話走左果D好多去top U, 你又話唔算數 (MPS 出身, 點會唔關MPS事?)....咁大仇口....  其實.... 妳係咪...抽唔中.扣唔入又插唔到班呢

mcl203

annie133 發表於 19-11-6 14:00
不是這樣計的，一般不會計離開了學校的人，個D已經入左人地數了，學校留不留到勁人也是參考指標，不是人人 ...

估~~~

mcl203

cafeva 發表於 19-11-6 14:15
咁又奇啦, 話MSS DSE 好, 3大成5X%, 你話人地少人考DSE要'著草'. 而家有人話走左果D好多去top U, 你又話唔 ...

～～～

annie133

cafeva 發表於 19-11-6 14:15
咁又奇啦, 話MSS DSE 好, 3大成5X%, 你話人地少人考DSE要'著草'. 而家有人話走左果D好多去top U, 你又話唔 ...

「着草」意思係唔想考中文啫，其實而家間間學校都會，不用太大反應，是我用辭不當，我得閒改番。
我小朋友都大，仲抽乜鬼學校，只不過工作上接觸很多不同學校的學生。
唔講啦，咁多fans，我着草啦bye！

baby1206

annie133 發表於 19-11-6 14:44
「着草」意思係唔想考中文啫，其實而家間間學校都會，不用太大反應，是我用辭不當，我得閒改番。
我小朋友 ...

睇曬你所有留言，好明顯有踩mps mss偏見，扮乜專家呢？更何況你又唔係有小朋友讀緊，自己又唔係old girl一味話朋友個女乜乜乜，又推d著草論出嚟，有人出聲反駁你，又話學校多fans，唔夠人講又delete msg。成年人啦講嘢負下責任，自己反省下啦仲笑。

baby1206

本帖最後由 baby1206 於 19-11-6 15:33 編輯

再講，唔好開口埋口就話mps校友好愛學校，好多fans，你自己又何嘗唔係好愛st Mary Maryknoll? 個個post都要讚下。
MPS辦校都92年，舊生，舊生家長多不勝數，學校辦得好，自然多人支持，成績方面呢，咁多年黎就算有升升跌跌都可以一直keep到b1A，學你講st Mary個句留言，爛船都有三分釘嘅。
做人持平d，我自己就算好buy mps 都唔會踩人地學校同學生。

halvard

多謝各位嘅回覆，真的很開心EK有咁多願意中立同持平咁去分析嘅朋友
一間學校如果得家長支持，學生都唔鐘意，舊生無歸屬感，好同叻極都有限

大家成年人，入得嚟睇同問嘅係想知道真正嘅答案，如果唔肯定，靠估同感覺去答係不負責任

答得就要對自己講嘅嘢負責任，我唔肯定嘅絕對唔講，講，係希望有心讀嘅知道情況係點樣

總唔能夠只係起EK攞嘢又咁自私唔分享掛